The greenhouse gas balance of European grasslands

Philippe Ciais, Jean‐François Soussana, Nicolas Vuichard, Sebastiaan Luyssaert, Axel Don, Ivan A. Janssens, Shilong Piao, René Dechow, Juliette Lathière, Fabienne Maignan, M. Wattenbach, Pete Smith, Christof Ammann, Annette Freibauer, Ernst‐Detlef Schulze, the Carboeurope Synthesis Team2010 · DOI

TL;DR

European grasslands are significant carbon sinks, absorbing an estimated 57-74 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹, but this is partially offset by methane and nitrous oxide emissions. While grasslands are efficient at storing carbon in soil, further research with more sites and longer time series is crucial to reduce uncertainties and better understand their role in the global carbon cycle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Grasslands, covering a substantial portion of Europe, play a critical role in the global carbon cycle. However, accurately quantifying their carbon balance (Net Biome Productivity - NBP) has been challenging due to limited and short-term eddy-covariance data, coupled with the complexities of grassland management (grazing, mowing, fertilization) and the difficulty in directly measuring Net Primary Productivity (NPP). Previous estimates have been uncertain, and there's a need to understand how these ecosystems contribute to carbon sequestration while also considering their greenhouse gas emissions (CO2, CH4, N2O). This paper aims to synthesize available data and modeling to provide a more robust estimate of the European grassland carbon and greenhouse gas balance.

Methods

The study employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Eddy-covariance data synthesis: They compiled data from 11 "golden sites" across Europe with multi-year eddy-covariance measurements, focusing on Net Ecosystem Exchange (NEE) and accounting for lateral carbon inputs (manure) and exports (harvest).
  • Process-based modeling (PASIM): The PASIM model was used to estimate spatial-temporal distribution of NPP across Europe, providing a continental-scale perspective. This model was also used to correct for extensive management practices, leading to a refined NPP estimate.
  • Data-driven upscaling: They combined eddy-covariance observations of Gross Primary Production (GPP) with modeled NPP/GPP ratios from PASIM to derive a data-oriented NPP estimate.
  • Statistical and fuzzy logic models for N2O: N2O emissions were estimated using national UNFCCC statistics (disaggregated), a fuzzy logic model, and the PASIM model.
  • Livestock CH4 emissions: CH4 emissions were derived from UNFCCC statistics based on animal categories.
  • Mass balance calculations: Heterotrophic respiration (Rh) was calculated as a residual term in mass balance equations.

Datasets

  • Eddy-covariance data: Data from 11 "golden sites" across Europe were used, representing intensive management and long growing seasons.
  • PASIM model outputs: Used for simulating NPP and providing ratios for upscaling.
  • EUROSTAT NewCronos database: Used for classifying grassland management intensity (pasture, meadows, rough grazing) at the NUTS-2 regional level.
  • FAOSTAT database: Used for national-scale management intensity information.
  • UNFCCC statistics: Used for estimating N2O and CH4 emissions.
  • CORINE/PELCOM satellite-based land cover dataset: Used for comparison of grassland area estimates.
  • ORCHIDEE vegetation model: Used for estimating the impact of historical land use change on NBP.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grasslands are significant carbon sinks: The study confirms that European grasslands are net carbon sinks, absorbing a substantial amount of CO2. This is crucial because grasslands are widespread and often overlooked compared to forests.
  • NPP is higher in grasslands than forests/croplands: Grasslands exhibit higher Net Primary Productivity (NPP) than croplands and forests, likely due to intensive management and favorable climate conditions.
  • Carbon sequestration efficiency: Grasslands are more efficient at sequestering carbon in the soil per unit of carbon input compared to forests. This highlights their potential for managing carbon sinks.
  • Non-CO2 gases are a major offset: Methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from grasslands significantly offset the carbon sink, counterbalancing a substantial portion (70-80%) of the NBP. This is a critical finding for understanding the net greenhouse gas balance.
  • Management intensity matters: The study emphasizes how management practices (fertilization, grazing intensity) influence both carbon sequestration and greenhouse gas emissions, suggesting an "optimum" management intensity might exist.
  • Data limitations are significant: The authors repeatedly highlight the uncertainties stemming from limited sites, short measurement periods, and the difficulty in measuring certain fluxes (e.g., VOC, DOC).

Key Results

  • Net Biome Productivity (NBP): Estimated to be a carbon sink ranging from 57 to 74 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹ across EU-25 grasslands.
  • Net Primary Productivity (NPP): Estimated at 750 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹ (corrected for extensive management), which is about 20% higher than croplands and 70% higher than forests.
  • Carbon Sequestration Efficiency (CSE): Estimated at 0.09-0.11, indicating grasslands are efficient at storing carbon in soil.
  • N2O emissions: Estimated to offset 13±5% of the carbon sink.
  • CH4 emissions: Estimated to offset 63±25% of the carbon sink.
  • Combined non-CO2 gas offset: Roughly 70-80% of the carbon sink is offset by N2O and CH4 emissions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in NBP estimates: The study acknowledges that the NBP estimates are rough extrapolations based on a limited number of sites with intensive management, potentially leading to an overestimation of the carbon sink.
  • Missing fluxes: VOC emissions and DOC losses were not fully accounted for in the NBP calculation from eddy-covariance data, potentially leading to sink overestimation.
  • Data scarcity: The lack of long-term, site-specific data, especially for disturbance events like plowing, and comprehensive soil carbon inventories across Europe limits the accuracy of the estimates.
  • Future work: The authors emphasize the need for:
  • Larger numbers of sites and longer time series of observations.
  • Improved up-scaling methods.
  • Better integration of farm-level management practices and satellite observations.
  • Independent soil carbon inventories.
  • Specific measurements of DOC export and VOC emissions.
  • Models capable of simulating nitrogen cycling, management specifics, and disturbances like plowing.
  • Collection of geospatial information on management intensity.
  • Predicting future grassland GHG balance under climate change and adaptation scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

The long-term carbon balance (NBP) of grasslands is estimated by combining scarce multi-year eddy-covariance observations at ecosystem observation sites where information on carbon inputs and harvesting removals is available. Following accounting for carbon leached to rivers, we estimated grasslands to be net carbon sinks of 74±10 g C m−2 yr−1. Uncertainties arise from the small number of sites and the short measurement period. Only 11 sites, out of a total of 20 grassland sites in Europe where eddy covariance systems are installed, were set-up for estimating NBP. These 11 selected sites are representative of intensive management practice and we lack information on disturbance history, such as plowing. This suggests that the grassland NBP estimate is likely biased towards overestimating the sink, compared to the European average. Direct measurements of Net Primary Productivity (NPP) are not possible in grasslands given permanent biomass removal by grazing and mowing, uncertainties in rhizodeposition and production of volatile organic carbon compounds lost to the atmosphere. Therefore, the grassland process-based ecosystem model PASIM was used to estimate the spatial-temporal distribution of NPP, providing a European average value of 750±150 g C across extensively grazed, intensively grazed pastures, and forage production systems. In Europe the NPP of grasslands seems higher than that of croplands and forests. The carbon sequestration efficiency of grasslands, defined as the ratio of NBP to NPP, amounts to 0.09±0.10. Therefore, per unit of carbon input, grasslands sequester 3–4 times more carbon in the soil than forests do, making them a good candidate for managing onsite carbon sinks. When using the 100 yr greenhouse warming potential for CH4 and N2O, their emissions due to management of grasslands together offset roughly 70–80% of the carbon sink. Uncertainties on the European grassland greenhouse gas balance, including CO2, CH4 and N2O fluxes are likely to be reduced in the near future, with data being collected from more sites, and improved up-scaling methods.
BibTeX
@misc{ciais2010greenhouse,
  author = {Philippe Ciais and Jean‐François Soussana and Nicolas Vuichard and Sebastiaan Luyssaert and Axel Don and Ivan A. Janssens and Shilong Piao and René Dechow and Juliette Lathière and Fabienne Maignan and M. Wattenbach and Pete Smith and Christof Ammann and Annette Freibauer and Ernst‐Detlef Schulze and the CARBOEUROPE Synthesis Team},
  title = {{The greenhouse gas balance of European grasslands}},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.5194/bgd-7-5997-2010},
}

Loading related content...

Figure