Abstract
The world’s natural population growth has generated a paradoxical challenge between food security and safety (environmental quality). In this paper, we address this question to establish the security-safety paradox by examining increased fertiliser use on decreasing land endowment, and we establish how policy inducement reflects on the food security versus safety issue. Based on the generalised method of moment (GMM) estimations and panel data of 72 countries from 2002 to 2010, we for the first time answer this question and offer insightful developments in this direction. Firstly, we observe that shrinking land endowment has significant direct and indirect impacts (agricultural protection and food trade policies). Our analysis demonstrates that a decrease in the land endowment increases the fertiliser use intensity. Secondly, policy for agricultural protection induces different effects on security and safety issues in development and world economies. Developed countries have introduced policies to reduce fertiliser usage trading food security for safety. By contrast, developing countries have introduced policies to increase food security trading food safety for security. Thus, developed countries tend to import food from developing countries to bridge the gap, and developing countries achieve economic gains.
Introduction: The Security-Safety Paradox
As the global population marches toward a projected 9 billion by 2050, the agricultural sector faces a fundamental "security–safety paradox." This dilemma describes the tension between the imperative of food security—ensuring a sufficient and stable food supply—and the requirement for food safety, defined here as the preservation of environmental quality and the mitigation of non-point source (NPS) pollution.
With agricultural land per capita steadily shrinking, farmers globally are turning toward "industrial intensification." This process primarily involves the heavy application of fertilizers and pesticides to maximize yields on limited land. While this intensification secures the immediate food supply, it often compromises environmental safety by causing significant soil and water pollution. This paper investigates how land endowment and government policies mediate this relationship, moving beyond traditional income-based models like the Environmental Kuznets Curve.
Methodology: System GMM and Impact Decomposition
To analyze the complex dynamics of agricultural intensification, the researchers employed a System Generalised Method of Moment (GMM) estimation. This robust econometric approach is particularly suited for agricultural data for several reasons:
- Accounting for Inertia: Agricultural behavior is often path-dependent; fertilizer application rates in one year are highly correlated with those of the previous year. GMM effectively handles these lagged variables.
- Resolving Endogeneity: In economics, variables often influence each other simultaneously. For instance, while land scarcity drives fertilizer use, the resulting environmental degradation might trigger new regulatory policies. GMM uses instrumental variables to untangle these reciprocal "chicken-and-egg" problems.
- Impact Decomposition: The study uniquely splits the impact of land endowment into direct effects (where land scarcity directly necessitates higher chemical intensity) and indirect effects (where land scarcity triggers policy shifts, such as changes in agricultural protection, which then influence chemical use).
Data and Variables
The study utilizes a dynamic panel dataset covering 72 countries (29 developed and 43 developing) from 2002 to 2010. Data was synthesized from the World Bank and the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAOSTAT). Key metrics include:
- Fertiliser Use Intensity: Measured in kilograms per hectare (kg/ha).
- Land Endowment: Agricultural land area per capita.
- Agricultural Protection (NRA): The Nominal Rate of Assistance, representing the ratio of agricultural subsidies to output.
- Net Food Import Rate: The difference between imports and exports relative to domestic supply.
Results: The Scarcity Trap and the Preference Divide
The analysis reveals a significant inverse relationship between land endowment and chemical intensity. Across the entire sample, a 1% decrease in land endowment per capita leads to a 0.193% increase in fertilizer use intensity. This "scarcity trap" suggests that as land becomes more limited, the pressure to over-apply chemicals becomes nearly unavoidable under current technological paradigms.
The Preference Divide
The research identifies a stark divide in how nations manage the security-safety trade-off:
- Developed Economies (Trading Security for Safety): These nations typically exhibit higher average fertilizer intensity (~130 kg/ha) but show a clear downward trend. They prioritize environmental safety, often introducing policies to reduce domestic chemical usage and scaling back agricultural protection (subsidies) that might otherwise encourage over-production.
- Developing Economies (Trading Safety for Security): With lower initial fertilizer intensity (~50 kg/ha) but an upward trend, these nations prioritize food security and economic growth. For these countries, the physical reality of land scarcity is a much more powerful driver of chemical use than government policy.
Discussion: Environmental Outsourcing through Trade
A provocative insight from the study is the phenomenon of environmental outsourcing. As developed nations reduce domestic production to protect their local soil and water, they do not necessarily consume less food. Instead, they bridge the supply gap by importing food from developing nations.
In this arrangement, developed countries effectively "export" their environmental footprint. The pollution associated with high-intensity farming is shifted to developing nations, which accept the environmental cost in exchange for the economic gains of food exports. This global trade dynamic allows developed nations to maintain high safety standards at home while relying on production in regions where fertilizer use is rising and environmental regulations may be less stringent.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The research underscores that land endowment is a fundamental driver of agricultural chemical use, mediated heavily by national policy and global trade. The findings suggest that simply adjusting subsidies may be effective in developed nations but will have limited impact in developing nations where land scarcity is the primary motivator.
To break the link between food security and environmental degradation, the authors call for joint international research and development to create "green" intensification technologies. Such innovations are essential to provide high yields without heavy chemical reliance. Future research is encouraged to apply this mediation model to pesticides and other agricultural inputs to further map the complexities of the global food security-safety dilemma.
Acknowledgements: This research was supported by funding sponsored by an agreement between FAO and CSC of China, the Humanities and Social Science Fund from the Ministry of Education (16YJC790112, 15YJA790093), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (71673041), and the Fundamental Research Funds for Central Universities (N150604006). We thank participants at the 2015 CES conference in Chengdu and the 2016 Sino-Korea regional economics conference for their helpful comments.
Summary updated