The Genomic Variation and Differentially Expressed Genes on the 6P Chromosomes in Wheat–Agropyron cristatum Addition Lines 5113 and II-30-5 Confer Different Desirable Traits

Wenjing Yang, Haiming Han, Baojin Guo, Kai Qi, Jinpeng Zhang, Shenghui Zhou, Xinming Yang, Xiuquan Li, Yuqing Lu, Weihua Liu, Xu Liu, Lihui LiInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates two wheat lines carrying an extra copy of the 6P chromosome from Agropyron cristatum, revealing significant genomic and gene expression differences that explain their distinct agronomic traits. By combining genome resequencing and transcriptome analysis, the researchers identified key genes and pathways related to flowering time, photosynthesis, and metabolism, offering valuable insights for improving wheat through alien gene introgression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wheat, a global staple crop, faces challenges in improving yield and quality due to a narrowing genetic diversity. Wild relatives, like Agropyron cristatum, offer a rich source of desirable genes. However, effectively utilizing these genes requires understanding the genomic variations and their impact on gene expression when introduced into wheat. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of how differences in the Agropyron cristatum 6P chromosome, when present in two distinct wheat addition lines (5113 and II-30-5), lead to their observed phenotypic differences in traits like heading date, grain number, and grain weight.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-omics approach:

  • Genome in situ hybridization (GISH): Used to confirm the presence and identity of the A. cristatum 6P chromosomes in the wheat background.
  • Phenotypic evaluation: Detailed field observations of heading date, grain number per spike (GNS), and thousand-grain weight were conducted for both addition lines and the control wheat cultivar.
  • Genome Resequencing: Whole-genome sequencing of the two addition lines was performed to identify single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and insertion/deletion polymorphisms (InDels) specifically on the 6P chromosomes.
  • Transcriptome Analysis (RNA-Seq): Gene expression profiling was conducted on leaf tissues at the floret differentiation stage to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between the two lines.
  • Bioinformatic Analyses: Gene Ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) enrichment analyses were used to understand the biological functions and pathways associated with the identified genetic variations and DEGs.
  • Quantitative Real-time PCR (qRT-PCR): Used to validate the expression levels of selected genes identified through RNA-seq.

Datasets

  • Wheat- Agropyron cristatum 6P addition lines: Lines 5113 and II-30-5 were used.
  • Control Wheat Cultivar: Fukuho ( Triticum aestivum L.) was used as the recipient parent.
  • Genomic DNA: Extracted from leaf tissues of the addition lines for resequencing.
  • RNA: Extracted from leaf tissues of the addition lines for transcriptome analysis.
  • Reference Genome: Integrated reference sequences of Chinese Spring RefSeq v2.1 were used for mapping sequencing reads.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant genomic divergence on the 6P chromosome: Even though both lines are wheat-A. cristatum 6P addition lines, their 6P chromosomes harbor substantial genetic differences (over 143,000 SNPs and 62,000 InDels). This highlights the dynamic nature of alien chromosome introgression and potential for generating novel variation.
  • Variation concentrated in specific chromosomal regions: Interestingly, the genomic variations were not uniformly distributed but were concentrated in the middle of chromosome arms and the proximal centromere region. This suggests specific mechanisms or evolutionary pressures might be at play in these regions.
  • Phenotypic differences are driven by gene expression and sequence variation: The study effectively links observed phenotypic differences (e.g., early heading in II-30-5, high GNS in 5113) to both genetic variations and differential gene expression.
  • Circadian rhythm and photosynthesis are key players: Enrichment analysis pointed towards the circadian rhythm pathway being crucial for the early heading phenotype of II-30-5. Furthermore, upregulated photosynthesis-related genes in II-30-5 likely contribute to its higher thousand-grain weight.
  • Carbon and lipid metabolism are also affected: Genes involved in carbon fixation and fatty acid biosynthesis showed both sequence variations and differential expression, suggesting their role in the observed differences in grain weight and quality.

Key Results

  • Phenotypic differences: II-30-5 headed 10 days earlier than 5113, had a higher thousand-grain weight (by 16.6 g), and larger/paler seeds. Conversely, 5113 had a significantly higher grain number per spike (GNS) (by 28.0).
  • Genomic variation: 143,511 SNPs and 62,103 InDels were identified between the 6P chromosomes of 5113 and II-30-5.
  • Differential gene expression: 757 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified between the two lines.
  • Enriched pathways: GO and KEGG analyses revealed enrichment in circadian rhythm, carbon metabolism, carbon fixation, and lipid metabolism pathways.
  • Specific gene findings: Photosynthesis genes (PsbA, PsbT, YCF48) were upregulated in II-30-5. Genes related to carbon fixation and fatty acid biosynthesis (ACS, FabG) showed modification variations and were upregulated in 5113.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Challenge of pinpointing causal variants: While many variations and DEGs were identified, directly linking specific sequence variations to particular phenotypic traits remains a significant challenge. The study acknowledges that finding sites directly associated with a given phenotype requires further investigation.
  • Effect of sequence variation on gene expression: The paper notes that the effect of sequence variation on gene expression needs further exploration.
  • Uncharacterized genes: Many genes with high-impact mutations were found to have uncharacterized functions, presenting an opportunity for future research into their roles and potential for wheat improvement.
  • Further functional validation: While qRT-PCR validated some expression changes, more in-depth functional studies (e.g., gene knockout or overexpression) would be beneficial to confirm the precise roles of identified genes in conferring desirable traits.
  • Broader germplasm utilization: The study suggests that understanding the genetic diversity of 6P chromosomes is crucial for creating more germplasm resources and improving the efficiency of utilizing A. cristatum alien genes in wheat breeding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wild relatives of wheat are essential gene pools for broadening the genetic basis of wheat. Chromosome rearrangements and genomic variation in alien chromosomes are widespread. Knowledge of the genetic variation between alien homologous chromosomes is valuable for discovering and utilizing alien genes. In this study, we found that 5113 and II-30-5, two wheat-<i>A. cristatum</i> 6P addition lines, exhibited considerable differences in heading date, grain number per spike, and grain weight. Genome resequencing and transcriptome analysis revealed significant differences in the 6P chromosomes of the two addition lines, including 143,511 single-nucleotide polymorphisms, 62,103 insertion/deletion polymorphisms, and 757 differentially expressed genes. Intriguingly, genomic variations were mainly distributed in the middle of the chromosome arms and the proximal centromere region. GO and KEGG analyses of the variant genes and differentially expressed genes showed the enrichment of genes involved in the circadian rhythm, carbon metabolism, carbon fixation, and lipid metabolism, suggesting that the differential genes on the 6P chromosome are closely related to the phenotypic differences. For example, the photosynthesis-related genes <i>PsbA</i>, <i>PsbT,</i> and <i>YCF48</i> were upregulated in II-30-5 compared with 5113. <i>ACS</i> and <i>FabG</i> are related to carbon fixation and fatty acid biosynthesis, respectively, and both carried modification variations and were upregulated in 5113 relative to II-30-5. Therefore, this study provides important guidance for cloning desirable genes from alien homologous chromosomes and for their effective utilization in wheat improvement.
BibTeX
@article{yang2023genomic,
  author = {Wenjing Yang and Haiming Han and Baojin Guo and Kai Qi and Jinpeng Zhang and Shenghui Zhou and Xinming Yang and Xiuquan Li and Yuqing Lu and Weihua Liu and Xu Liu and Lihui Li},
  title = {{The Genomic Variation and Differentially Expressed Genes on the 6P Chromosomes in Wheat–Agropyron cristatum Addition Lines 5113 and II-30-5 Confer Different Desirable Traits}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms24087056},
}
Figure