Abstract
Southern and eastern African populations that speak non-Bantu languages with click consonants are known to harbour some of the most ancient genetic lineages in humans, but their relationships are poorly understood. Here, we report data from 23 populations analysed at over half a million single-nucleotide polymorphisms, using a genome-wide array designed for studying human history. The southern African Khoisan fall into two genetic groups, loosely corresponding to the northwestern and southeastern Kalahari, which we show separated within the last 30,000 years. We find that all individuals derive at least a few percent of their genomes from admixture with non-Khoisan populations that began ∼1,200 years ago. In addition, the East African Hadza and Sandawe derive a fraction of their ancestry from admixture with a population related to the Khoisan, supporting the hypothesis of an ancient link between southern and eastern Africa.
Introduction
The Khoisan populations of southern Africa, distinguished by their unique click-consonant languages and hunter-gatherer lifestyles, represent some of the most ancient genetic lineages in modern humans. Despite their significance, their internal structure and historical relationships have remained largely opaque. Key questions have persisted: Are Khoisan groups genetically uniform? How do they relate to East African click-speakers like the Hadza and Sandawe? To what extent has the "Bantu expansion"—the migration of agriculturalists across Africa—impacted their genetic landscape? Previous research using limited markers like mtDNA or Y chromosomes lacked the resolution to answer these questions.
Methodology
To reconstruct this complex history, researchers utilized several advanced genomic tools:
- Human Origins Array: A custom array of ~565,000 SNPs was used to avoid the European bias of standard medical arrays. One panel was specifically ascertained from a Ju|’hoan Khoisan individual to capture Khoisan-specific variation.
- Linkage Disequilibrium (LD) Decay: Using the ROLLOFF method, the team dated admixture events by measuring how recombination breaks down DNA "blocks" from mixed populations over time.
- TreeMix: This statistical framework modeled population trees with "migration edges," accounting for both population splits and subsequent gene flow.
- Split-Dating: A novel method estimated divergence times based on the accumulation of new mutations since population separation.
Study Populations
The study analyzed 187 individuals across 22 African populations:
- 16 Khoisan populations from the Tuu, Kx’a, and Khoe-Kwadi language families.
- 5 Bantu-speaking populations (e.g., Himba, Tswana) for regional comparison.
- East African click-speakers: The Hadza and Sandawe.
- Reference Data: Outgroups including the Dinka, Yoruba, and various Eurasian populations.
Key Insights and Ideas
The analysis revealed that genetic clustering is driven more by geography than by linguistic classification. The Khoisan are split into two primary genetic groups: the Northwestern Kalahari and the Southeastern Kalahari.
Other notable findings include:
- The Damara Paradox: While the Damara speak a Khoisan language, they are genetically nearly identical to neighboring Bantu-speaking populations, indicating a complete language shift with minimal interbreeding.
- Ubiquitous Admixture: No "pure" hunter-gatherer populations exist; even the most isolated groups like the Ju|’hoan show at least a small percentage of non-Khoisan ancestry.
- The Southern-Eastern Link: There is a clear genetic bridge between southern and eastern Africa. The Hadza and Sandawe carry a significant "ghost" signature of Khoisan-related ancestry.
Key Results
- 30,000-Year Divergence: The NW and SE Kalahari Khoisan groups diverged approximately 30,000 years ago, representing a remarkably deep split within a single region.
- Recent Admixture: Admixture with non-Khoisan groups (likely Bantu farmers or East African pastoralists) began roughly 1,200 years ago across all studied groups.
- Quantifying Ancestry: The Hadza and Sandawe derive approximately 23% and 18% of their ancestry, respectively, from a population related to the southern Khoisan. Non-Khoisan ancestry in other groups ranges from ~6% in the Ju|’hoan_North to ~90% in the Damara.
Limitations and Future Directions
The 30,000-year split estimate is considered an upper bound, as subsequent gene flow can mask older signals. Furthermore, while the study confirms a link between southern and eastern Africa, it does not definitively locate the origin of modern humans. The data is consistent with origins in either region. Future research incorporating ancient DNA will be essential to further clarify these migratory paths and the timing of these "ghost" population movements.
Summary updated