The generation mechanism of spike-and-slow wave discharges appearing on thalamic relay nuclei

Bing Hu, Yu Guo, Feng Shi, Xiaoqiang Zou, Jing Dong, Long Pan, Min Yu, Chaowei Zhou, Cheng Zhang, Wanyue Tang, Haochen Sun, Luonan ChenScientific 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel computational model of the corticothalamic network to investigate the generation and control of absence epilepsy seizures originating in the thalamus's specific relay nuclei (SRN). The study reveals that specific connection strengths and signal transmission delays are critical for seizure onset and that external stimulation can effectively inhibit these seizures, offering potential insights for future therapeutic interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Absence epilepsy, characterized by brief lapses in consciousness and characteristic spike-and-slow wave discharges (SWDs) on EEG, is a significant neurological disorder, particularly affecting children. While the general involvement of the corticothalamic (CT) network is established, the precise origin and underlying mechanisms of absence seizures remain elusive. Previous theoretical work has largely focused on seizure generation within the excitatory pyramidal neurons (EPNs) of the cortex. This paper addresses the gap in understanding seizure generation specifically within the thalamic relay nuclei (SRN), which are implicated in absence epilepsy. Furthermore, it explores novel control mechanisms for these thalamus-originated seizures, moving beyond purely cortical models.

Methods

The researchers employed a modified mean-field model of the corticothalamic network, incorporating four neural populations: specific relay nuclei (SRN), thalamic reticular nucleus (TRN), inhibitory interneurons (IIN), and excitatory pyramidal neurons (EPN). They utilized a system of delay differential equations to describe the dynamic characteristics of these neural populations. The core methodology involved:

  • Bifurcation Analysis: Systematically varying critical coupling strengths between neural populations to identify transitions between different brain states, including normal low-firing, simple oscillation, seizure, and saturation states.
  • External Stimulation: Applying external voltage stimuli to the EPN and SRN to investigate their effect on seizure activity and explore control mechanisms.
  • Delay Analysis: Investigating the impact of signal transmission delays, particularly in inhibitory pathways, on the generation of SWDs and polyspike phenomena.
  • Numerical Simulations: Employing the standard fourth-order Runge-Kutta method for simulations with a small integral step size.

A key methodological aspect is the focus on the SRN as the origin of seizures, differentiating it from prior studies primarily centered on cortical EPNs. The model also incorporates delays in inhibitory pathways, which are crucial for capturing complex seizure dynamics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a computational model and simulations, with parameter values drawn from existing literature and biological ranges.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Thalamic Origin of Seizures: The model demonstrates that absence seizures can indeed originate and be generated within the specific relay nuclei (SRN) of the thalamus, not solely in the cortex.
  • Critical Role of Connectivity: Seizure states in the SRN are highly sensitive to specific coupling strengths between neural populations within the CT network. Tuning these connections can transition the system into or out of a seizure state.
  • Delay-Induced Polyspike Waves: Signal transmission delays, particularly in inhibitory pathways like TRN→SRN and IIN→EPN, play a crucial role. Sufficiently large delays are necessary for the emergence of polyspike wave phenomena, suggesting a temporal aspect to seizure complexity.
  • Bidirectional Control via External Stimulation: External voltage stimuli applied to the SRN and EPN can effectively inhibit seizures. Interestingly, this control is often bidirectional, meaning both increasing and decreasing the stimulus strength can suppress seizure activity, hinting at complex regulatory mechanisms.
  • TRN's Limited Direct Seizure Role: While the TRN is part of the CT network, the model suggests it doesn't directly exhibit obvious seizure phenomena itself, but rather influences SRN activity.

Key Results

  • Transition to Seizure States: By systematically varying coupling strengths (e.g., $v_{es}$, $v_{ee}$, $v_{ei}$, $v_{re}$, $v_{rs}$, $v_{sr}$), the model showed transitions from normal brain states to seizure states in the SRN. For instance, increasing $v_{es}$ led to states (1) low firing, (2) simple oscillation, (3) seizure, and (4) saturation.
  • Seizure Inhibition: External stimuli ($S$) applied to the SRN demonstrated bidirectional control, inhibiting seizures when $S$ was either increased or decreased from a certain range. Similar bidirectional control was observed with stimuli on the EPN ($C$) and TRN ($T$).
  • Delay Threshold for Seizures: A delay threshold (e.g., $\tau_1 > 0.16$ s for TRN→SRN) was identified for the onset of typical SWDs. Larger delays were found to induce polyspike wave phenomena.
  • Frequency Range: The dominant frequency of the simulated epileptic seizures consistently fell within the 2-4 Hz range, characteristic of SWDs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The mean-field model is an idealization. Factors like synaptic plasticity, detailed connection structures, and delays in excitatory pathways, which are not fully captured, could influence seizure dynamics. The study acknowledges that a spiking neural network model might be necessary for more detailed investigations.
  • Damping Rate Effect: The paper notes that the damping rate of the SRN had little effect on seizures in their simulations, which might be an oversimplification given the known importance of damping rates in neuronal activity.
  • External Stimulation vs. Internal Regulation: While external stimuli showed control, the paper suggests that more refined studies on internal brain regulation mechanisms are needed for a deeper understanding of seizure control.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that their model and methods can be extended to study other types of seizures (e.g., spasmodic attacks, secondary generalized seizures) and that data-driven approaches like network biomarkers could complement their model-driven findings. They also highlight the need for further experimental studies on the role of GABAB pathways in absence epilepsy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In this paper, we use a model modified from classic corticothalamic network(CT) to explore the mechanism of absence seizures appearing on specific relay nuclei (SRN) of the thalamus. It is found that typical seizure states appear on SRN through tuning several critical connection strengths in the model. In view of previous experimental and theoretical works which were mainly on epilepsy seizure phenomena appearing on excitatory pyramidal neurons (EPN) of the cortex, this is a novel model to consider the seizure observed on thalamus. In particular, the onset mechanism is different from previous theoretical studies. Inspired by some previous clinical and experimental studies, we employ the external stimuli voltage on EPN and SRN in the network, and observe that the seizure can be well inhibited by tuning the stimulus intensity appropriately. We further explore the effect of the signal transmission delays on seizures, and found that the polyspike phenomenon appears only when the delay is sufficiently large. The experimental data also confirmed our model. Since there is a complex network in the brain and all organizations are interacting closely with each other, the results obtained in this paper provide not only biological insights into the regulatory mechanisms but also a reference for the prevention and treatment of epilepsy in future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2018generation,
  author = {Bing Hu and Yu Guo and Feng Shi and Xiaoqiang Zou and Jing Dong and Long Pan and Min Yu and Chaowei Zhou and Cheng Zhang and Wanyue Tang and Haochen Sun and Luonan Chen},
  title = {{The generation mechanism of spike-and-slow wave discharges appearing on thalamic relay nuclei}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-23280-y},
}
Figure