The Generalization and Robustness of Transformer-Based Language Models on Commonsense Reasoning

Ke ShenAAAI 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the generalization and robustness of transformer-based language models (LLMs) on commonsense reasoning tasks. It reveals that current LLMs, despite impressive performance on benchmarks, may not generalize well to unseen data and can be susceptible to dataset biases. The authors propose a risk-centric evaluation framework to better diagnose LLM performance beyond simple accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid advancement of LLMs has led to remarkable progress in natural language processing, particularly in commonsense reasoning. However, concerns about LLMs' reliability, including issues like hallucination and bias, are growing. This paper tackles the critical question of whether LLMs truly "understand" commonsense or if their high performance on existing benchmarks is an overestimation due to dataset-specific learning. Specifically, it addresses:

  • Generalization: Do LLMs trained on one commonsense reasoning dataset perform well on others, or do they struggle to adapt to new, unseen data?
  • Robustness: How do LLMs behave when faced with ambiguous or subtly altered inputs, and can their confidence scores reliably indicate the correctness of their predictions?
  • Evaluation: Are current evaluation methods sufficient to capture the true capabilities and limitations of LLMs in commonsense reasoning, especially in real-world scenarios?

Methods

The paper outlines three main studies:

  1. Generalization Ability Evaluation: The authors propose a methodology using statistical significance analysis and a "performance loss metric" to measure how well transformer-based language models generalize across different commonsense reasoning benchmarks. This involves fine-tuning a model on one benchmark and testing it on others to quantify any performance drop.
  2. Confidence Behavior Analysis: To understand LLMs' self-awareness of uncertainty, the researchers designed "confusion probes." These probes are used to create ambiguous inference tasks, including situations with no clear correct answer or with controversial answers. They analyze the confidence distribution of LLMs when presented with these perturbed inputs.
  3. Risk-Centric Evaluation Framework: The paper introduces a novel framework that defines two types of risk and proposes four metrics for evaluating LLMs. This framework aims to move beyond simple accuracy and provide a more nuanced understanding of model performance. A "risk-adjusted calibrator" (DwD) is also presented to adjust raw LLM confidence scores.

Datasets

The paper mentions the use of five established commonsense reasoning benchmarks for evaluation. While specific names are not exhaustively listed, examples like those from Bhagavatula et al. (2020), Singh et al. (2021), Santos et al. (2022), and Kejriwal et al. (2023) are referenced, indicating a reliance on existing, widely-used datasets for commonsense QA. The paper does not introduce any newly created benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Overestimation of Performance: Current benchmark performance might be an overestimation of LLMs' true commonsense reasoning capabilities, especially when applied to novel problems without specific training data.
  • Dataset Bias is a Concern: LLMs may be susceptible to dataset bias, leading to a lack of generalization. Sophisticated adversarial attacks are not always necessary to reveal these generalization issues.
  • Confidence Doesn't Always Equal Correctness: LLMs' confidence scores, traditionally used as a proxy for risk, may not reliably indicate the correctness of their predictions, especially in ambiguous situations.
  • Need for Beyond Multiple-Choice: The reliance on multiple-choice QA formats for evaluation might be limiting, as it doesn't fully capture real-world conversational interactions and could be amenable to automated scoring without true understanding.

Key Results

  • Generalization Failure: The experimental study on RoBERTa showed that models do not generalize well when fine-tuned on one commonsense benchmark and tested on another.
  • Confidence Distribution: When faced with perturbed inputs, incorrect answers often show a confidence distribution close to random, similar to pre-perturbation levels. The model may still favor the originally correct answer even when it's theoretically incorrect.
  • Risk Reduction: The proposed risk-adjusted calibrator (DwD) demonstrated significant reductions in in-domain and out-of-domain decision risks for RoBERTa (28.3% and 18.9% respectively) and reduced composite risk for ChatGPT NLI (17.9%).

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The authors acknowledge that they haven't yet verified whether their findings on generalization apply to generative GPT-series models.
  • The current evaluation methods, particularly multiple-choice QA, may not fully reflect real-world conversational interactions and could be over-reliant on specific formats.

Future Work:

  • Broader Evaluation: Employing a wider range of evaluation methods, including human-in-the-loop evaluations, is crucial for a more comprehensive understanding of LLMs' commonsense reasoning and robustness.
  • Generative Model Verification: Extending the generalization studies to generative LLMs like GPT is essential for their broader application.
  • Knowledge-Based Analytical Systems: The authors envision an innovative application of LLMs in developing knowledge-based analytical systems that allow domain experts to interact using natural language queries, moving beyond complex, formal queries.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2024generalization,
  author = {Ke Shen},
  title = {{The Generalization and Robustness of Transformer-Based Language Models on Commonsense Reasoning}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v38i21.30410},
}
Figure