The Gene Ontology resource: enriching a GOld mine

Seth Carbon, Eric Douglass, Benjamin M. Good, Deepak R. Unni, Nomi L. Harris, Christopher J. Mungall, Siddartha Basu, Rex L. Chisholm, Robert J. Dodson, Eric Hartline, Petra Fey, Paul D. Thomas, Laurent-Philippe Albou, Dustin Ebert, Michael J. Kesling, Huaiyu Mi, Anushya Muruganujan, Xiaosong Huang, Tremayne Mushayahama, Sandra A. LaBonte, Deborah A. Siegele, Giulia Antonazzo, Helen Attrill, Nick H. Brown, Phani V. Garapati, Steven J. Marygold, Vitor Trovisco, Gilberto dos Santos, Kathleen Falls, Christopher J. Tabone, Pinglei Zhou, Joshua L. Goodman, Victor B. Strelets, Jim Thurmond, Penelope Garmiri, Rizwan Ishtiaq, Milagros Rodríguez-López, Marcio Luis Acencio, Martin Kuiper, Astrid Lægreid, Colin Logie, Ruth C. Lovering, Barbara Kramarz, Shirin C. C. Saverimuttu, Sandra M. Pinheiro, Heather Gunn, Renzhi Su, Katherine E. Thurlow, Marcus C. Chibucos, Michelle G. Giglio, Suvarna Nadendla, James B. Munro, Rebecca C. Jackson, Margaret J. Duesbury, Noemi del-Toro, Birgit H. M. Meldal, Kalpana Paneerselvam, Livia Perfetto, Pablo Porras, Sandra E. Orchard, Anjali Shrivastava, Hsin-Yu Chang, Robert D. Finn, Alex L. Mitchell, Neil D. Rawlings, Lorna J. Richardson, Amaia Sangrador-Vegas, Judith A. Blake, Karen R. Christie, Mary E. Dolan, Harold J. Drabkin, David P. Hill, Li Ni, Dmitry M. Sitnikov, Midori A. Harris, Stephen G. Oliver, Kim Rutherford, Valerie Wood, Jaqueline Hayles, Jürg Bähler, Elizabeth R. Bolton, Jeffrey DePons, Melinda R. Dwinell, G. Thomas Hayman, Mary L. Kaldunski, Anne E. Kwitek, Stanley J. F. Laulederkind, Cody Plasterer, Marek Tutaj, Mahima Vedi, Shur-Jen Wang, Peter D'Eustachio, Lisa Matthews, James P. Balhoff, Suzi A. Aleksander, Michael J. Alexander, J. Michael Cherry, Stacia R. Engel, Felix Gondwe, Kalpana Karra, Stuart R. Miyasato, Robert S. Nash, Matt Simison, Marek S. Skrzypek, Shuai Weng, Edith D. Wong, Marc Feuermann, Pascale Gaudet, Anne Morgat, Erica Bakker, Tanya Z. Berardini, Leonore Reiser, Shabari Subramaniam, Eva Huala, Cecilia N. Arighi, Andrea H. Auchincloss, Kristian B. Axelsen, Ghislaine Argoud-Puy, Alex Bateman, Marie-Claude Blatter, Emmanuel Boutet, Emily Bowler, Lionel Breuza, Alan J. Bridge, Ramona Britto, Hema Bye-A-Jee, Cristina Casals-Casas, Elisabeth Coudert, Paul Denny, Anne Estreicher, Maria Livia Famiglietti, George E. Georghiou, Arnaud Gos, Nadine Gruaz-Gumowski, Emma Hatton-Ellis, Chantal Hulo, Alexandr Ignatchenko, Florence Jungo, Kati Laiho, Philippe Le Mercier, Damien Lieberherr, Antonia Lock, Yvonne Lussi, Alistair MacDougall, Michele Magrane, Maria Jesus Martin, Patrick Masson, Darren A. Natale, Nevila Hyka-Nouspikel, Ivo Pedruzzi, Lucille Pourcel, Sylvain Poux, Sangya Pundir, Catherine Rivoire, Elena Speretta, Shyamala Sundaram, Nidhi Tyagi, Kate Warner, Rossana Zaru, Cathy H. Wu, Alexander D. Diehl, Juancarlos Chan, Christian A. Grove, Raymond Y. N. Lee, Hans-Michael Müller, Daniela Raciti, Kimberly Van Auken, Paul W. Sternberg, Matthew Berriman, Michael Paulini, Kevin L. Howe, Sibyl Gao, Adam Wright, Lincoln Stein, Douglas G. Howe, Sabrina Toro, Monte Westerfield, Pankaj Jaiswal, Laurel Cooper, Justin ElserNucleic Acids Res 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

The Gene Ontology (GO) resource, a cornerstone for understanding gene and protein functions, has been significantly enhanced over the past two years. Key advancements include the improved GO-CAM annotation framework for more detailed functional modeling, a redesigned website for better accessibility, and a substantial increase in both the number of GO annotations and the breadth of annotated gene products, all while maintaining data quality and reproducibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Gene Ontology (GO) aims to provide a standardized, computable vocabulary for describing gene and gene product functions across all organisms. However, as biological knowledge expands and the volume of data grows, challenges arise in maintaining the accuracy, comprehensiveness, and usability of this resource. Specifically, the GO needs to:

  • Represent complex biological processes: Standard GO annotations, while useful, often lack the granularity to fully capture the causal relationships and context of molecular activities within pathways.
  • Ensure data quality and consistency: With millions of annotations, manual review and validation are crucial to keep pace with new discoveries and correct errors.
  • Improve accessibility and usability: Researchers need efficient ways to access, query, and utilize GO data for their analyses.
  • Integrate with other biological resources: Seamless interoperability with other ontologies and databases is essential for a connected biological knowledge graph.

This paper addresses these challenges by detailing the recent developments and ongoing efforts within the Gene Ontology Consortium to evolve the resource.

Methods

The paper highlights several key methodological advancements:

  • GO-CAM (Gene Ontology Causal Activity Models): This is a significant development, moving beyond simple gene-to-term annotations. GO-CAMs provide a formal, computable model that links standard GO annotations and enriches them with biological context, particularly focusing on causal influences between molecular activities using the Relation Ontology. This allows for more detailed representation of biological pathways and processes.
  • ShEx (Shape Expressions) for GO-CAM Validation: To ensure the quality and consistency of the rapidly growing GO-CAM repository, a computational schema using ShEx has been implemented. ShEx allows for real-time checks and feedback during model creation, as well as automated detection and reporting of errors in existing GO-CAMs. This complements existing OWL reasoning checks.
  • Noctua Curation Platform: This platform supports the collaborative creation and review of both standard GO annotations and GO-CAMs. It includes an editorial page for browsing and searching, a form-based interface for easy GO-CAM creation, and a graph visualization tool for editing causal relationships. Noctua also facilitates the integration of existing GO annotations into GO-CAMs.
  • Ontology Refinement and Inter-ontology Inferences: The GO ontology is continuously updated through a collaborative process involving domain experts. This includes creating new terms, obsoleting or merging existing ones, and improving taxon constraints. The paper also discusses the strategic use and limitations of leveraging external ontologies (e.g., Uberon, Cell Ontology, ChEBI) for maintaining GO and enabling inferences.
  • Redesigned Website and Tools: The geneontology.org website has been redesigned for improved access to documentation, downloads, and tools. New features include a historical archive of GO data and a redesigned GO ribbon widget for visualizing gene functions.

Datasets

The paper discusses the GO knowledgebase itself as the primary dataset, which includes:

  • Standard GO Annotations: Assertions linking genes to GO terms with supporting evidence.
  • GO-CAMs: More complex models linking multiple GO annotations and causal relationships.
  • Ontology Files: The hierarchical structure of GO terms.

The paper also mentions the use of external ontologies such as Uberon, Cell Ontology, ChEBI, and Relation Ontology as crucial components for building and enriching the GO knowledgebase.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GO-CAMs are a paradigm shift: Moving from simple annotations to causal models unlocks a much richer and more expressive representation of biological functions, enabling more sophisticated queries and analyses.
  • Computational validation is essential: The implementation of ShEx for GO-CAMs is critical for managing the scale and complexity of this new annotation type, ensuring data integrity.
  • Collaboration is key to GO's success: The paper repeatedly emphasizes the consortium model, highlighting collaborations with various research groups and databases (e.g., SynGO, Rhea, GREEKC, Alliance of Genome Resources) that are vital for refining the ontology and expanding annotations.
  • Usability and accessibility are paramount: The website redesign and improved toolset (like the GO ribbon) are crucial for making the vast GO resource accessible and actionable for the broader scientific community.
  • Reproducibility is a growing focus: The creation of a historical archive of GO data and the emphasis on consistent formats aim to support the reproducibility of past research and facilitate temporal analyses.

Key Results

  • GO-CAM Repository Growth: Over 2838 GO-CAMs have been created, with 533 containing causal relations, indicating significant adoption and utility.
  • Annotation Increase: The number of GO annotations increased by 10% (to over 8 million), annotated gene products by 26% (to over 1.5 million), and annotated scientific articles by 6% (to over 160,000) over the past two years.
  • Ontology Refinement: 672 new GO terms were created, 661 were obsoleted, and 752 were merged, resulting in a net decrease of 627 terms, reflecting ongoing efforts to streamline and update the ontology.
  • Website Redesign: A new website hosted on GitHub pages aims to provide quicker access to documentation, downloads, and tools.
  • Historical Archive: A reconstructed archive of 173 monthly GO releases from 2005 to 2018 has been made available, enhancing data traceability and reproducibility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of ChEBI Roles: The paper notes that ChEBI roles cannot always be reliably used to make inferences that are true in all contexts within the GO ontology, and thus will no longer be used for this purpose.
  • Future Work on GO-CAMs: The consortium expects the number of pathway-oriented GO-CAMs to rise rapidly and plans to migrate all standard manual GO annotations from Alliance member groups to GO-CAMs.
  • Future Work on Ontology: Future plans include producing the history of all GO term changes since 2005 and developing a GO enrichment tool that can analyze gene sets at different points in time to support reproducibility.
  • Improving Taxon Constraints: Efforts are ongoing to integrate taxon constraints from external ontologies into GO and ensure their proper inheritance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{carbon2021gene,
  author = {Seth Carbon and Eric Douglass and Benjamin M. Good and Deepak R. Unni and Nomi L. Harris and Christopher J. Mungall and Siddartha Basu and Rex L. Chisholm and Robert J. Dodson and Eric Hartline and Petra Fey and Paul D. Thomas and Laurent-Philippe Albou and Dustin Ebert and Michael J. Kesling and Huaiyu Mi and Anushya Muruganujan and Xiaosong Huang and Tremayne Mushayahama and Sandra A. LaBonte and Deborah A. Siegele and Giulia Antonazzo and Helen Attrill and Nick H. Brown and Phani V. Garapati and Steven J. Marygold and Vitor Trovisco and Gilberto dos Santos and Kathleen Falls and Christopher J. Tabone and Pinglei Zhou and Joshua L. Goodman and Victor B. Strelets and Jim Thurmond and Penelope Garmiri and Rizwan Ishtiaq and Milagros Rodríguez-López and Marcio Luis Acencio and Martin Kuiper and Astrid Lægreid and Colin Logie and Ruth C. Lovering and Barbara Kramarz and Shirin C. C. Saverimuttu and Sandra M. Pinheiro and Heather Gunn and Renzhi Su and Katherine E. Thurlow and Marcus C. Chibucos and Michelle G. Giglio and Suvarna Nadendla and James B. Munro and Rebecca C. Jackson and Margaret J. Duesbury and Noemi del-Toro and Birgit H. M. Meldal and Kalpana Paneerselvam and Livia Perfetto and Pablo Porras and Sandra E. Orchard and Anjali Shrivastava and Hsin-Yu Chang and Robert D. Finn and Alex L. Mitchell and Neil D. Rawlings and Lorna J. Richardson and Amaia Sangrador-Vegas and Judith A. Blake and Karen R. Christie and Mary E. Dolan and Harold J. Drabkin and David P. Hill and Li Ni and Dmitry M. Sitnikov and Midori A. Harris and Stephen G. Oliver and Kim Rutherford and Valerie Wood and Jaqueline Hayles and Jürg Bähler and Elizabeth R. Bolton and Jeffrey DePons and Melinda R. Dwinell and G. Thomas Hayman and Mary L. Kaldunski and Anne E. Kwitek and Stanley J. F. Laulederkind and Cody Plasterer and Marek Tutaj and Mahima Vedi and Shur-Jen Wang and Peter D'Eustachio and Lisa Matthews and James P. Balhoff and Suzi A. Aleksander and Michael J. Alexander and J. Michael Cherry and Stacia R. Engel and Felix Gondwe and Kalpana Karra and Stuart R. Miyasato and Robert S. Nash and Matt Simison and Marek S. Skrzypek and Shuai Weng and Edith D. Wong and Marc Feuermann and Pascale Gaudet and Anne Morgat and Erica Bakker and Tanya Z. Berardini and Leonore Reiser and Shabari Subramaniam and Eva Huala and Cecilia N. Arighi and Andrea H. Auchincloss and Kristian B. Axelsen and Ghislaine Argoud-Puy and Alex Bateman and Marie-Claude Blatter and Emmanuel Boutet and Emily Bowler and Lionel Breuza and Alan J. Bridge and Ramona Britto and Hema Bye-A-Jee and Cristina Casals-Casas and Elisabeth Coudert and Paul Denny and Anne Estreicher and Maria Livia Famiglietti and George E. Georghiou and Arnaud Gos and Nadine Gruaz-Gumowski and Emma Hatton-Ellis and Chantal Hulo and Alexandr Ignatchenko and Florence Jungo and Kati Laiho and Philippe Le Mercier and Damien Lieberherr and Antonia Lock and Yvonne Lussi and Alistair MacDougall and Michele Magrane and Maria Jesus Martin and Patrick Masson and Darren A. Natale and Nevila Hyka-Nouspikel and Ivo Pedruzzi and Lucille Pourcel and Sylvain Poux and Sangya Pundir and Catherine Rivoire and Elena Speretta and Shyamala Sundaram and Nidhi Tyagi and Kate Warner and Rossana Zaru and Cathy H. Wu and Alexander D. Diehl and Juancarlos Chan and Christian A. Grove and Raymond Y. N. Lee and Hans-Michael Müller and Daniela Raciti and Kimberly Van Auken and Paul W. Sternberg and Matthew Berriman and Michael Paulini and Kevin L. Howe and Sibyl Gao and Adam Wright and Lincoln Stein and Douglas G. Howe and Sabrina Toro and Monte Westerfield and Pankaj Jaiswal and Laurel Cooper and Justin Elser},
  title = {{The Gene Ontology resource: enriching a GOld mine}},
  journal = {Nucleic Acids Res.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1093/nar/gkaa1113},
}
Figure