The Future Proofing Study: Design, methods and baseline characteristics of a prospective cohort study of the mental health of Australian adolescents

Aliza Werner‐Seidler, Kate Maston, Alison L. Calear, Philip J. Batterham, Mark Larsen, Michelle Torok, Bridianne O’Dea, Kit Huckvale, Joanne R. Beames, Lyndsay Brown, Hiroko Fujimoto, Alexandra Bartholomew, Debopriyo Bal, Susanne Schweizer, S. Rachel Skinner, Katharine Steinbeck, Julie Ratcliffe, Ju Lee Oei, Svetha Venkatesh, Raghu Lingam, Yael Perry, Jennifer L. Hudson, Katherine Boydell, Andrew Mackinnon, Helen ChristensenInternational Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the "Future Proofing Study" (FPS), a large-scale, prospective cohort study designed to understand the complex factors influencing adolescent mental health in Australia. By collecting a rich, multi-modal dataset over five years, the FPS aims to identify risk and protective factors for mental health conditions, paving the way for more effective prevention and early intervention strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescence is a critical period for the onset of mental health conditions, with approximately half of all mental health disorders emerging before the age of 18. Despite effective treatments, access and demand remain significant challenges, highlighting the urgent need for robust prevention and early intervention strategies. While existing research has provided valuable insights, there's a critical gap in large-scale, comprehensive studies that integrate diverse data sources to understand the multifaceted nature of adolescent mental health trajectories. Specifically, understanding the interplay of individual, social, and environmental factors, as well as the potential of digital tools for monitoring and intervention, remains an area requiring further investigation.

Methods

The Future Proofing Study (FPS) employs a prospective cohort design, following adolescents over five years. A key methodological innovation is the integration of multiple data streams:

  • Self-report questionnaires: Annual assessments capture mental health symptoms (depression, anxiety, psychological distress, suicidal ideation), wellbeing, sleep quality, and a broad range of individual and environmental factors.
  • Smartphone-collected data: This includes cognitive functioning tasks (executive function, working memory), typing and speech characteristics, ecological momentary assessment (EMA), and passive sensor data (GPS, accelerometry, gyroscope). This aims to identify digital predictors and correlates of mental health.
  • Linkage to government records: Data on health (hospital admissions, service utilization) and education (academic performance) are linked to provide objective information.
  • Embedded Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial (cRCT): The study also includes a cRCT investigating the effectiveness of two digital prevention programs (SPARX-FP for depression and Sleep Ninja for insomnia) delivered in schools.

This multi-modal approach allows for a comprehensive understanding of mental health development, moving beyond traditional self-report measures.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this paper is the baseline data from the Future Proofing Study (FPS) cohort.

  • FPS Baseline Cohort: Consists of 6388 adolescents recruited from 134 Australian secondary schools. Data collection occurred between August 2019 and March 2022, with some extensions due to COVID-19.
  • Comparison Data: The paper references various Australian population estimates for demographic characteristics and mental health prevalence to contextualize the FPS cohort.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus is on describing the established cohort and its baseline characteristics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Prevalence of Mental Health Challenges: The baseline data reveals a significant prevalence of mental health conditions among Australian adolescents, with notable rates of depression, anxiety, and psychological distress.
  • Gender and Sexuality Diversity Disparities: Adolescents identifying as female, gender diverse, sexuality diverse, or Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander reported significantly higher rates of mental health symptoms compared to their cisgender, heterosexual, and non-Indigenous peers. This highlights critical areas for targeted support.
  • The Power of Multi-Modal Data: The study's strength lies in its integration of diverse data sources. Combining self-reports with objective smartphone data and health records offers a more nuanced and potentially predictive understanding of mental health than any single source alone.
  • Digital Tools as a Frontier: The use of smartphone sensors and apps for data collection and intervention delivery represents a forward-thinking approach to adolescent mental health research, leveraging technology that is ubiquitous among this age group.
  • Regional and Socioeconomic Disparities: Adolescents in regional areas and those attending less advantaged schools showed higher rates of depression and anxiety, underscoring the importance of addressing socioeconomic and geographic inequalities in mental health support.

Key Results

  • Baseline Cohort Size: 6388 adolescents participated in the baseline assessment.
  • Prevalence Rates:
    • 15.1% met the clinical threshold for depression.
  • 18.6% met the clinical threshold for anxiety.
  • 31.6% experienced psychological distress.
  • 4.9% reported suicidal ideation.
  • Demographic Differences:
    • Female adolescents reported higher symptom levels than males.
  • Nonbinary adolescents reported even higher symptom levels than females across most measures.
  • Adolescents in regional areas were more likely to meet clinical thresholds for depression and anxiety.
  • Adolescents in less advantaged schools (lower ICSEA) were more likely to report symptoms above clinical thresholds for depression, anxiety, and psychological distress.
  • Gender diverse participants were significantly more likely to reach clinical thresholds for depression, anxiety, psychological distress, and suicidal ideation.
  • Sexuality diverse participants also showed significantly higher likelihoods of meeting clinical thresholds for these conditions.
  • Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander participants were significantly more likely to meet clinical thresholds for depression, anxiety, psychological distress, and suicidal ideation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Bias: The opt-in nature of the study, requiring parental and adolescent consent, along with smartphone ownership, may have introduced sampling biases, potentially leading to a slightly more advantaged and less linguistically diverse sample than the general Australian population.
  • COVID-19 Context: Baseline data collection coincided with COVID-19 lockdowns, which may influence findings and presents a unique opportunity to study long-term impacts of disruption.
  • Intervention Effects: If the embedded cRCT demonstrates intervention effects, the control arm will serve as the primary cohort sample, which could be considered a limitation for pure cohort study analysis.
  • Future Work: The FPS is designed to continue monitoring prevalence levels and changes in mental health over time, particularly in high-risk groups. The rich, multi-modal data will be used to identify predictors and mediators of mental health outcomes, inform the development of personalized prevention and early intervention strategies, and explore the effectiveness of digital interventions. The study aims to provide a major contribution to understanding adolescent development, experience, and behavior as risk and protective factors for mental ill-health and wellbeing.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper provides current and comprehensive data about the status of adolescent mental health in Australia. The FPS cohort is expected to provide significant insights into the risk, protective, and mediating factors associated with development of mental health conditions during adolescence.
BibTeX
@article{wernerseidler2022future,
  author = {Aliza Werner‐Seidler and Kate Maston and Alison L. Calear and Philip J. Batterham and Mark Larsen and Michelle Torok and Bridianne O’Dea and Kit Huckvale and Joanne R. Beames and Lyndsay Brown and Hiroko Fujimoto and Alexandra Bartholomew and Debopriyo Bal and Susanne Schweizer and S. Rachel Skinner and Katharine Steinbeck and Julie Ratcliffe and Ju Lee Oei and Svetha Venkatesh and Raghu Lingam and Yael Perry and Jennifer L. Hudson and Katherine Boydell and Andrew Mackinnon and Helen Christensen},
  title = {{The Future Proofing Study: Design, methods and baseline characteristics of a prospective cohort study of the mental health of Australian adolescents}},
  journal = {International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1002/mpr.1954},
}
Figure