The Future Agricultural Biogas Plant in Germany: A Vision

Susanne Theuerl, Christiane Herrmann, Monika Heiermann, Philipp Grundmann, Niels Landwehr, Ulrich Kreidenweis, Annette ProchnowEnergies 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Germany's biogas sector, historically reliant on energy crops and subsidies, is at a critical juncture. This paper envisions a future agricultural biogas plant as a cornerstone of the circular bioeconomy, primarily utilizing residues, operating with high flexibility, modularity, and automation, and becoming economically competitive and environmentally beneficial.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenges and limitations of the current German agricultural biogas production model. For nearly two decades, this model has been heavily subsidized and focused on energy crop cultivation. This approach has led to societal debates about food vs. fuel, biodiversity loss, increased land prices, and questions about the cost-effectiveness and environmental benefits compared to other renewable energy sources. With subsidies expiring and the need for a more sustainable bioeconomy, the authors argue for a fundamental shift in biogas production. They aim to outline a vision for future biogas plants that are more integrated, flexible, and efficient, moving away from a sole focus on energy generation to a broader role in resource management and the circular economy.

Methods

The paper is primarily a visionary review and conceptual outline, rather than a research paper presenting new experimental data or algorithms. The authors synthesize existing knowledge and propose future research directions. Their "method" involves:

  • Systemic Multidisciplinary Research Approach: Emphasizing the need for collaboration across microbiology, engineering, automation, data science, agricultural, environmental, and socio-economic fields.
  • Knowledge-Based, Information-Driven, and Automated Operation: Proposing a paradigm shift in plant operation, moving from operator experience to data-driven insights and automation. This involves:
  • Understanding the Digestion Process: Deepening knowledge of microbial communities, their functions, and ecological roles.
  • Monitoring the Digestion Process: Developing faster, more affordable, and on-line methods for physico-chemical and microbial parameter detection.
  • Modelling the Digestion Process: Creating advanced mechanistic and data-driven models that integrate real-time data for process prediction, control, and optimization.
  • Flexible and Modular Design: Advocating for plants that can adapt to diverse feedstocks, varying operational conditions, and on-demand biogas supply.
  • Integration into the Circular Bioeconomy: Highlighting the role of biogas plants in closing nutrient cycles, utilizing residues, and producing valuable co-products.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Residue-Centric Biogas: The future of biogas lies in maximizing the use of diverse organic residues, minimizing competition with food production and environmental impact.
  • Flexibility is Key: Future biogas plants must be flexible in feedstock input, digester operation, microbial communities, and biogas output to adapt to varying conditions and demands.
  • Microbiome as a Management Target: A deeper understanding and active management of the biogas microbiome are crucial for stable, efficient, and resilient digestion processes.
  • Automation and Data-Driven Control: Moving beyond operator experience to sophisticated monitoring, modeling, and automated control systems is essential for managing complex, flexible biogas plants.
  • Biogas as a Bioeconomy Hub: Biogas plants can be central to the circular bioeconomy, not just for energy but also for nutrient recycling, biomaterial production, and chemical feedstock generation.
  • Modular Design for Adaptability: Modular components will allow plants to be tailored to specific needs and easily upgraded or reconfigured.

Key Results

As this is a vision paper, there are no quantitative results in terms of performance metrics. The key "results" are the proposed characteristics and requirements for future agricultural biogas plants:

  • Integral part of the circular bioeconomy.
  • Primarily based on residues.
  • Flexible with regard to feedstocks, digester operation, microbial communities, and biogas output.
  • Modular in design.
  • Knowledge-based, information-driven, and largely automated operation.
  • Efficient, cost-decreasing, and profitable for operators.
  • Favorable for the national economy.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors explicitly state that significant research is required across multiple disciplines to realize this vision. Key areas for future work include:

  • Understanding the Digestion Process: Elucidating microbial community dynamics, functions, and ecological roles, especially in response to diverse feedstocks and fluctuating conditions.
  • Developing Advanced Monitoring: Creating fast, affordable, and on-line sensors for physico-chemical and microbial parameters.
  • Improving Modelling: Developing comprehensive, predictive models that integrate microbial and physico-chemical data for process control and optimization.
  • Engineering for Flexibility: Designing robust digester technologies and operation strategies that can handle variable feedstocks and produce biogas on demand.
  • Feedstock Research: Characterizing new feedstocks (especially residues), optimizing supply chains, and developing solutions for difficult-to-digest materials.
  • Bioeconomy Integration: Identifying and optimizing pathways for coupling biogas production with food, feed, and biomaterial production.
  • Business Models and Environments: Developing viable business models and supportive environments for future biogas production.
  • Environmental Impact Assessment: Continuously evaluating the environmental performance of new technologies and feedstock choices, particularly regarding indirect land-use change.
  • Mobile and Modular Plants: Further development and commercialization of mobile and modular biogas plant concepts.

Summary updated

Abstract

After nearly two decades of subsidized and energy crop-oriented development, agricultural biogas production in Germany is standing at a crossroads. Fundamental challenges need to be met. In this article we sketch a vision of a future agricultural biogas plant that is an integral part of the circular bioeconomy and works mainly on the base of residues. It is flexible with regard to feedstocks, digester operation, microbial communities and biogas output. It is modular in design and its operation is knowledge-based, information-driven and largely automated. It will be competitive with fossil energies and other renewable energies, profitable for farmers and plant operators and favorable for the national economy. In this paper we discuss the required contribution of research to achieve these aims.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{theuerl2019future,
  author = {Susanne Theuerl and Christiane Herrmann and Monika Heiermann and Philipp Grundmann and Niels Landwehr and Ulrich Kreidenweis and Annette Prochnow},
  title = {{The Future Agricultural Biogas Plant in Germany: A Vision}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/en12030396},
}
Figure