Abstract
Background: The optimal fraction of nitrous oxide ($N_2O$) in oxygen ($O_2$) for rapid lung collapse during one-lung ventilation (OLV) remains undefined. This study aimed to determine the 50% ($EC_{50}$) and 95% ($EC_{95}$) effective concentrations of $N_2O$ for this purpose.
Methods: 38 patients undergoing video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) were studied. Lung collapse was evaluated using a Lung Collapse Score (LCS). $N_2O$ fractions were adjusted using the Dixon up-and-down method starting at 30%.
Results: The $EC_{50}$ and $EC_{95}$ of $N_2O$ for successful lung collapse were 27.7% and 48.7%, respectively.
Conclusions: Concentrations of approximately 28% and 49% $N_2O$ in $O_2$ effectively facilitate lung collapse in 50% and 95% of patients, respectively.
Introduction
In thoracic surgery, particularly video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS), achieving rapid and complete collapse of the non-ventilated lung is critical for surgical access and safety. Lung collapse occurs in two phases: an initial rapid phase due to elastic recoil and a subsequent slower phase driven by absorption atelectasis. While nitrous oxide ($N_2O$) is known to accelerate the second phase due to its high solubility—the "second gas effect"—the precise concentration required has historically relied on clinical intuition rather than empirical data. This study quantifies the effective concentrations ($EC_{50}$ and $EC_{95}$) of $N_2O$ needed to facilitate rapid lung collapse.
Methods
The study enrolled 38 consecutive patients scheduled for elective VATS. Patients with significant pulmonary comorbidities, such as COPD or severe asthma, were excluded to ensure a standardized baseline of lung mechanics.
The Dixon up-and-down method was employed to determine the effective concentrations. The initial patient received 30% $N_2O$ in $O_2$. Success was defined as a Lung Collapse Score (LCS) ≥ 8, assessed by a blinded surgeon 5 minutes after pleural opening. Subsequent concentrations were adjusted by 10% increments based on the previous patient's outcome.
Results
Of the 38 patients, 36 were included in the final analysis. The study found that higher fractions of $N_2O$ significantly increased the probability of successful lung collapse within the 5-minute window.
Statistical analysis using probit regression identified the $EC_{50}$ as 27.7% (95% CI: 19.9%–35.7%) and the $EC_{95}$ as 48.7% (95% CI: 39.0%–96.3%). Notably, a 50% $N_2O$ fraction resulted in a 100% success rate in the tested subgroup, whereas a 10% fraction resulted in 0% success.
Discussion
The results demonstrate that $N_2O$ concentrations commonly used in clinical practice (e.g., 50%) are highly effective for facilitating lung collapse. The "second gas effect" of $N_2O$ creates a relative vacuum in the alveoli, accelerating the absorption of remaining oxygen and leading to faster atelectasis.
While the LCS is a subjective measure, it directly reflects the surgeon's requirements for a clear operative field. The study's safety profile was excellent, with no instances of significant desaturation or hemodynamic instability. However, limitations include the focus on a relatively healthy patient population and the subjective nature of the scoring system. Future research should explore these dynamics in patients with impaired lung function or obesity.
Conclusion
For patients undergoing VATS, an $N_2O$ concentration of approximately 49% in oxygen provides a highly reliable (95%) probability of rapid lung collapse, optimizing surgical conditions without compromising patient safety.
Summary updated