The Flow of Institutional Charisma: Quanzhen Taoism and Local Performing Arts in Republic Shandong and Henan

Guoshuai Qin, Wanrong ZhangReligions 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the institutional structure of Quanzhen Taoism, a major religious order, was adopted and adapted by local performing arts in Republican-era China. It reveals that performing troupes mimicked Taoist lineage systems, sacrificial ceremonies, and organizational structures to enhance their own social standing and legitimacy, demonstrating a fascinating flow of "institutional charisma."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the influence of Quanzhen Taoist teachings on popular culture, particularly theater, has been studied, the specific impact of its institutional organization on local performing arts has been largely overlooked. This paper addresses this gap by investigating how performing troupes in Shandong and Henan provinces during the Republican period (1912-1949) adopted and modified Quanzhen Taoism's organizational frameworks. The authors aim to understand the mechanisms and motivations behind this adoption, particularly how it helped performers navigate their often marginalized social status.

Methods

The research is primarily based on historical documents, including local gazetteers, sociological surveys from the Republican era, and oral accounts collected by scholars at the time. The authors also conducted interviews with contemporary performers. They analyze these sources to identify patterns of imitation and adaptation in the organizational structures of various performing arts genres, focusing on elements like lineage poems, sacrificial rituals, and guild formation.

Datasets

The paper draws upon a range of historical documents and oral accounts, including:

  • Investigation of Popular Entertainment in the Xiangguo Temple (1936)
  • Henan Quyi Zhishi Ziliao Huibian (a compilation of articles on performing arts from the 1980s)
  • Oral accounts collected by research teams during the Republican era.
  • Interviews with contemporary performers, such as Xu Liping.

No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced; the study relies on existing historical and ethnographic materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Institutional Charisma" as a Driver: The paper introduces the concept of "institutional charisma" to explain how the established, organized nature of Quanzhen Taoism provided a model for local performers seeking legitimacy and social elevation.
  • Mimicry of Taoist Structures: Performing troupes adopted key Quanzhen organizational elements, including:
  • Lineage Poems (Paishi): Used to name disciples and establish generational succession, mirroring Taoist practice.
  • Patriarchal Worship: Honoring Quanzhen patriarchs like Qiu Changchun as their own spiritual founders.
  • Sacrificial Ceremonies: Replicating Taoist rituals for accepting disciples.
  • Guilds (Ever Spring Guild): Forming associations for mutual support, akin to Taoist organizations.
  • Adaptation, Not Just Imitation: While imitating Quanzhen structures, performers also modified them to suit their own needs and local contexts. This included altering historical narratives and lineage poems.
  • Social Mobility and Legitimacy: The adoption of religious structures was a strategy for performers, often from marginalized social strata, to gain respectability, overcome discrimination, and improve their social standing.
  • Quanzhen's Enduring Legacy: The study highlights how Quanzhen Taoism, even in its institutional form, continued to exert a significant influence on popular culture and social organization in Republican China.

Key Results

The paper identifies at least eight genres of local performing arts in Shandong and Henan that show close ties to Quanzhen Taoism, particularly its Longmen School. These include Taoist Ballade (Daoqing), Henan Zhuizi, Shuoshu (storytelling), Shandong Laozi, Shandong Kuaishu, Guangzhou Dagu, Puyang Qinshu, and Yongcheng Da'nao. For each, the authors demonstrate how they incorporated Quanzhen organizational elements, such as lineage poems and patriarchal worship. They also highlight variations, such as altered historical accounts and lineage poems, indicating creative adaptation rather than mere replication.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Source Limitations: The authors acknowledge that oral accounts, while valuable, may not always be perfectly accurate, especially regarding origins and history. They emphasize the need for prudence when interpreting these materials.
  • Focus on Republican Era: The study's primary focus is on the Republican period, with some discussion extending beyond it. Further research could explore these connections in different historical periods.
  • Understanding Deviations: While noting deviations and variations in the adopted structures, the paper suggests that these were not random but calculated adaptations driven by performers' needs. Future work could delve deeper into the specific socio-economic and cultural factors that shaped these variations.
  • Broader Regional Impact: The study focuses on Shandong and Henan. Expanding the scope to other regions could reveal more about the widespread influence of Quanzhen Taoism on performing arts.
  • The "Dialectical Movement": The authors conclude by referencing Rolf Stein's concept of a "ceaseless dialectical movement" between great religions and popular traditions, suggesting this dynamic is key to understanding the Quanzhen-performing arts relationship. Further exploration of this dynamic could be a fruitful avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quanzhen Taoism and its relationship with local performing arts is an important yet inadequately studied subject, to date, due to the shortage of and limited access to new sources. However, on the basis of historical documents, oral statements and field research, we determined at least eight genres of local performing arts closely related to Quanzhen Taoism, especially its sublineage, the Longmen School, in Republic Shandong and Henan. They traced back their own history to Quanzhen Taoist patriarch WANG Chongyang, adopted the Quanzhen Taoist lineage poem to name their disciples, and created the Ever Spring Guild (Changchun hui 長春會), in the name of Quanzhen Taoist QIU Changchun 丘長春, to assist each other. In other words, the Quanzhen Taoist institution was imitated by the local performing arts and, at the same time, the local artists performed some reasonable adaptations and accommodations to meet their own needs. By reviewing the local performing arts in Shangdong and Henan provinces, we can further understand Quanzhen Taoism in popular cultural traditions and local societies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2023flow,
  author = {Guoshuai Qin and Wanrong Zhang},
  title = {{The Flow of Institutional Charisma: Quanzhen Taoism and Local Performing Arts in Republic Shandong and Henan}},
  booktitle = {Religions},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/rel14050560},
}
Figure