TL;DR
This paper presents the first results of relative positioning and velocity estimation using the Chinese Area Positioning System (CAPS), a novel navigation concept that leverages communication satellites. The findings demonstrate CAPS's potential for high-precision positioning, achieving centimeter-level accuracy with carrier-phase measurements, and suggest it could offer a new navigation mode.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSSs) like GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, and BeiDou provide essential positioning, navigation, and timing (PNT) services. However, current GNSSs face challenges, including signal vulnerability to interference and the difficulty of maintaining highly stable atomic clocks on orbiting satellites, which directly impacts positioning accuracy. To address these limitations, researchers proposed the Chinese Area Positioning System (CAPS). CAPS shifts the atomic clock from the satellite to the ground control station, transmitting navigation signals via communication satellites. This design aims to improve clock stability and reduce costs. This paper tackles the question of how well this new CAPS system performs for high-precision relative positioning and velocity estimation, especially compared to existing GNSS capabilities.
Methods
The study evaluates CAPS using both code and carrier-phase measurements. For relative positioning, a differential model is employed to mitigate errors like orbit and virtual clock biases, which are common in satellite navigation. The core of the method involves analyzing the differences in measurements between two receivers to achieve higher precision. For velocity estimation, the Doppler measurement from the CAPS signal is utilized. A key aspect of the carrier-phase positioning is the ambiguity resolution, which is crucial for achieving centimeter-level accuracy. The authors employ a geometry-free method for ambiguity estimation, acknowledging the challenges posed by the limited number and near-stationary nature of the CAPS satellites (GEO satellites). The experiments involve both post-processing and real-time kinematic (RTK) approaches.
Datasets
The experiments were conducted in Beijing, China, using real data collected on August 1, 2017, and August 24, 2017. The data was gathered by two self-developed CAPS receivers. The CAPS system utilized four GEO satellites and one IGSO satellite. For validation in the real-time experiment, a NovAtel GPS/BDS RTK and INS integrated terminal was used to provide "true" coordinates and velocity.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Decentralized Clock for Stability: Moving the atomic clock to the ground control station in CAPS is a fundamental design choice that simplifies clock management and potentially enhances stability compared to satellite-based clocks.
- Carrier-Phase Advantage: Similar to traditional GNSSs, carrier-phase measurements in CAPS offer significantly higher precision than code measurements, especially when ambiguities are fixed.
- CAPS Constellation Influence: The geometric distribution of CAPS satellites (primarily GEO) influences positioning accuracy, with better results in the east-west direction.
- Ambiguity Resolution Challenges: The near-stationary nature of GEO satellites in CAPS presents a challenge for traditional ambiguity resolution techniques, necessitating alternative approaches like the geometry-free method.
- Potential for New Navigation Mode: The successful demonstration of relative positioning and velocity estimation suggests CAPS could serve as a viable new navigation mode, potentially complementing or enhancing existing GNSS services.
Key Results
- Measurement Noise: The noise of CAPS code measurements is approximately 0.25 m, and carrier-phase measurements are around 0.13 cm.
- Static Relative Positioning:
- Using code measurements: 1.26 m (horizontal), 1.80 m (vertical).
- Using carrier-phase (ambiguities fixed): 2.83 cm (horizontal), 3.15 cm (vertical).
- Kinematic Relative Positioning:
- Using carrier-phase: 5.21 cm (horizontal), 10.41 cm (vertical).
- Velocity Estimation:
- Static: ~0.04 m/s accuracy.
- Kinematic: ~0.11 m/s accuracy.
- Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) Performance: While poorer than post-processing, RTK results showed accuracies of approximately 2.83-3.15 cm in static mode and 6.31-10.78 cm in kinematic mode.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the current CAPS system is in its development and test phase, and the data and experiments are limited. The availability of satellites was on a short-term basis, and continuous service was not yet established. The study also notes that the real-time positioning results exhibited a periodic feature that requires further investigation and more experiments. Future work will involve further system improvements, longer data collection periods, expanded experimental areas across China, and comparisons with current GNSSs like BDS and GPS. The addition of anti-multipath processing in future CAPS receivers is also suggested to mitigate errors.
Summary updated