"The Eyes Have No Sight, the Ears Have No Hearing"—On the Research of User Experience Based on Vision and Hearing

Shangshang YangInternational Journal of Frontiers in Sociology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This research explores the intersection of ancient Chinese aesthetic philosophy—specifically from the Han Dynasty text Huainanzi—and modern User Experience (UX) design. By reinterpreting the concept that true perception transcends literal sensory input, the study investigates how visual and auditory design elements can be leveraged to meet both explicit and latent user needs. The paper argues for a holistic approach to industrial design that prioritizes emotional resonance and cultural affinity, providing a framework for creating products that achieve a deeper level of communication with the user.

Introduction

While modern UX design is a well-established field, much of the existing research in China has historically relied on Western frameworks, such as Donald Norman’s three levels of emotional design (instinct, behavior, and reflection). The authors identify a significant gap in the literature: a lack of connection between UX principles and traditional Chinese culture. Furthermore, early industrial design often suffered from "functional myopia," prioritizing practicability while neglecting the deeper sensory and emotional layers that define a superior user experience.

By using the Huainanzi as a philosophical lens, this paper seeks to explore how visual and auditory design can be integrated into physical products to address both the articulated and "invisible" needs of the modern consumer.

The Philosophy of Transcendental Perception

The core of this research is founded on the Huainanzi paradox: "The eyes have no sight, the ears have no hearing." In a design context, this suggests that when a product is truly successful, the sensory input becomes so intuitive that the user no longer consciously "processes" the sight or sound; they simply experience the product. The design becomes invisible because it aligns perfectly with the user's expectations and natural behaviors.

This transcendental approach maps onto modern design theory by moving beyond the "instinctive" level (what looks good) and the "behavioral" level (what works well) to the "reflective" level, where the product resonates with the user’s identity and cultural background.

Visual and Auditory Design Pillars

The authors categorize sensory design into specific pillars to provide a roadmap for designers:

Visual Design

Visual design is broken down into four essential components:

  1. Color: The primary driver of instinctive emotional response.
  2. Shape/Form: The physical manifestation that dictates ergonomics and aesthetic appeal.
  3. Dynamics: The perceived movement or flow of the design.
  4. Space: The arrangement of elements that guides the user's interaction path.

Auditory Design

Sound is often overlooked but remains critical for psychological engagement. The paper distinguishes between:

  • Functional Feedback: Sounds that confirm an action, such as the beep of an air conditioner.
  • Psychological Influence: Sounds designed to evoke specific emotions, such as the engineered roar of a sports car engine versus the quiet hum of a family vehicle. These choices provide "psychological pleasure" tailored to specific demographics.

Addressing "Invisible Needs"

A key insight of the paper is that the most profound UX design addresses latent demands that consumers cannot yet articulate. The authors cite IKEA as a prime example of this principle. By offering low-cost snacks (like their signature ice cream) at the end of a long, potentially exhausting shopping path, IKEA addresses the "invisible" need for a psychological reward and physical refreshment. This creates a positive lasting impression that transcends the functional act of furniture shopping.

Similarly, the work of Naoto Fukasawa is highlighted for its minimalism, where the design focuses on the harmony between the object and its environment, fulfilling a need for simplicity and unobtrusive utility.

Cultural Affinity as UX

Design is not merely about ergonomics; it is a medium for cultural expression. The authors argue that incorporating traditional Chinese elements—such as tenon-and-mortise structures—into modern furniture creates a sense of "affinity" and national pride. This cultural resonance operates at the reflective level of UX, where the user feels a deeper connection to the product because it reflects their heritage and values.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The integration of traditional Chinese philosophy with industrial design creates a productive "collision" that benefits both fields. For designers, it provides a culturally nuanced vocabulary for sensory design. For culture, it offers a method to preserve and spread traditional principles by embedding them in modern, everyday objects.

However, the paper notes several limitations. As a qualitative study, it lacks empirical data or A/B testing to measure the quantitative impact of these philosophical applications. Future research should expand the scope to other volumes of the Huainanzi and develop technical frameworks to help engineers systematically implement these "invisible" needs into the manufacturing process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The research on visual and auditory design has been mentioned in the ancient Chinese Book “Huainanzi”. This book discusses its influence on user experience and hopes to provide reference for product design. Due to give users a better experience, the following research methods are often used in product design: analyzing the embodiment of visual and auditory design in life to explore its application; consulting relevant literature, analyzing the connection with visual and auditory to explore effective design methods.
BibTeX
@article{yang2021eyes,
  author = {Shangshang Yang},
  title = {{"The Eyes Have No Sight, the Ears Have No Hearing"—On the Research of User Experience Based on Vision and Hearing}},
  journal = {International Journal of Frontiers in Sociology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.25236/ijfs.2021.030410},
}
Figure