The Expressive Power of Ad-Hoc Constraints for Modelling CSPs

Ruiwei Wang, Roland H. C. YapAAAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the "expressive power" of various ad-hoc constraint representations used in Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs). It provides a comprehensive map of how succinctly these representations can model different constraint families and analyzes the tractability of common operations and queries on them, offering valuable guidance for CSP modeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) are powerful tools for modeling real-world problems. Ad-hoc constraints, which are flexible and can represent arbitrary relations, are crucial for this modeling. However, there are many ways to define these ad-hoc constraints (e.g., tables, decision diagrams, grammars). The authors identify a critical gap: while much research focuses on efficient propagation (how to solve CSPs with these constraints), there's less understanding of their expressive power. This includes how succinctly they can represent a constraint (succinctness) and how efficiently operations like combining or querying constraints can be performed (tractability). This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically comparing different ad-hoc constraint representations.

Methods

The authors employ a knowledge compilation (KC) inspired approach to analyze ad-hoc constraints. Their core methodology involves:

  • Succinctness Mapping: They analyze 14 existing ad-hoc constraint representations against 15 families of constraints. They determine if a constraint family can be represented "in polysize" by a given representation, meaning the size of the representation grows polynomially with the size of the constraint. This results in a comprehensive map showing which representations are more compact than others.
  • Operation Tractability Analysis: They investigate whether common operations (like conjunction, disjunction, negation, projection, conditioning) can be performed efficiently (in polynomial time relative to the representation size) for each ad-hoc constraint representation.
  • Query Tractability Analysis: Similarly, they analyze the tractability of various queries (like consistency checking, entailment, validity, model enumeration) on these representations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses predefined "constraint families" as benchmarks for evaluating the expressive power of ad-hoc constraint representations, rather than traditional datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Single "Best" Representation: The study reveals that different ad-hoc constraint representations have vastly different strengths and weaknesses. Some can compactly represent a wide range of constraints, while others struggle with even simple families.
  • Succinctness Matters for Modeling: The ability of a representation to model a constraint family "in polysize" is a fundamental measure of its utility. The paper provides a clear hierarchy of these representations.
  • Operations Dictate Usability: The tractability of operations like conjunction and negation is crucial for building complex CSP models. Some representations that are succinct might not support these operations efficiently, limiting their practical use.
  • KC Concepts Applied to CSPs: The paper cleverly adapts knowledge compilation techniques, typically used for Boolean functions, to the domain of finite-domain CSPs, opening new avenues for analyzing constraint representations.

Key Results

  • Comprehensive Succinctness Map: The paper presents a detailed map (Figure 3) showing the relative succinctness of 14 ad-hoc constraint representations (e.g., Table, CFG, BCT, OMDD, sMDD). For instance, it shows that while a BCT can be encoded as a polysize CFG, the reverse is not always true.
  • Tractability of Operations: Figure 4 illustrates which representations support common logical and variable elimination operations efficiently. For example, BCTs and CFGs generally support a wider range of operations tractably compared to some decision diagram variants.
  • Tractability of Queries: Figure 6 details which representations efficiently support various queries. Ad-hoc constraints with polytime GAC propagators tend to satisfy queries like consistency checking and model enumeration.
  • NP-Hardness Identified: The paper identifies specific constraint families (e.g., F7, related to 3-SAT) that are NP-hard to model, implying that any representation unable to model them efficiently is also likely to face tractability issues for these operations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Polysize: The analysis primarily focuses on whether a representation can encode a constraint family "in polysize." While this is a strong indicator, it doesn't preclude the possibility of exponential blow-ups in specific instances.
  • Specific Constraint Families: The study uses 15 predefined constraint families as benchmarks. While these are designed to be challenging and diverse, they might not cover all possible types of constraints encountered in real-world CSPs.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their results can guide the development of new ad-hoc constraint representations and algorithms. Further research could explore the trade-offs between succinctness and operation/query tractability in more depth, and investigate the practical performance of these representations on real-world CSP instances.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023expressive,
  author = {Ruiwei Wang and Roland H. C. Yap},
  title = {{The Expressive Power of Ad-Hoc Constraints for Modelling CSPs}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v37i4.25526},
}
Figure