The excavation of a cordoned urn at Benderloch, Argyll

Gavin MacGregor, Michael Donnelly, James S. Duncan, Andy M. Jones, Susan Ramsay, Julie RobertsProceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 1999 · DOI

Abstract This paper details the investigation of a Bronze Age cordoned urn discovered accidentally in a private garden at Benderloch, Argyll. Through a multi-disciplinary "biography" approach—incorporating lipid analysis, osteology, palynology, and radiocarbon dating—researchers reconstructed the vessel's prior domestic use and the complex mortuary rituals of the community. The findings challenge the assumption that funerary ceramics were exclusively ritual objects, revealing a 3,500-year-old story of domestic life repurposed for the grave.

Introduction

In archaeology, isolated funerary finds are often treated as static snapshots. However, modern analytical techniques allow for a more dynamic "biography" of objects. This study focuses on a single ceramic urn found in a garden in Benderloch, Scotland. By combining traditional excavation with advanced chemical and botanical analyses, the research demonstrates that this vessel was a repurposed domestic cooking pot, providing rare insights into the health, diet, and ritual complexity of an Early to Middle Bronze Age community.

Site Context and Discovery

The urn was discovered during gardening work at a private residence. Subsequent professional excavation revealed the vessel within a small pit. The site is located in Benderloch, north of Oban, in an area rich with prehistoric activity.

Location maps showing Benderloch and the site plan of the excavation trench.

Methodology

The team employed a suite of specialized techniques to extract maximum data from the find:

  • Lipid and Alkane Analysis: Gas chromatography detected organic residues absorbed into the ceramic fabric, identifying the vessel's prior contents.
  • Osteological Analysis: Detailed examination of 2,956g of cremated bone determined age, sex, and pathology.
  • Palynology (Pollen Analysis): Analyzing pollen trapped in internal encrustations reconstructed the local landscape.
  • Magnetic Susceptibility: Testing soil layers inside the urn determined if the fill was original or filtered in over time.

Excavation and Context

The urn (context 003) was found inverted within a pit. Despite some disturbance during the initial discovery, the excavation successfully recorded the relationship between the vessel and its immediate environment. Magnetic susceptibility confirmed the soil inside the urn was unburnt, indicating it filtered in through hairline cracks over centuries rather than being part of the original pyre fill.

Plan and section of the excavation trench showing the urn (003) within its pit.

Key Findings

The Repurposed Vessel

Lipid analysis provided a breakthrough "aha moment." High concentrations of alkanes (fatty acid remnants) were found approximately 100mm below the rim but were absent at the base. This pattern suggests the pot was used for boiling food while propped at an angle in a fire, confirming its life as a domestic kitchen tool before its funerary use.

Sophisticated Mortuary Rites

The cremation process was complex and deliberate. Bones were burned at high temperatures (645–940°C) and subsequently "winnowed" or washed to remove pyre debris before interment. The urn contained the remains of two individuals: an adult female (aged 20–25) and a young child (aged 16 months to 4 years).

Health and Environment

The female individual showed signs of porotic hyperostosis (pitting in the skull), a skeletal marker of iron-deficiency anemia, suggesting nutritional stress or high pathogen loads. Pollen analysis indicates the burial took place in a managed agricultural landscape dominated by pasture, with local oak forests already significantly cleared by the mid-second millennium BC.

Conclusion

Radiocarbon dating of internal encrustations places the burial between 1626 and 1408 cal BC. The Benderloch urn serves as a powerful example of how multi-proxy analysis can transform an isolated find into a detailed narrative of Bronze Age life and death. The reuse of a domestic vessel for burial suggests a fluid boundary between the mundane and the ritual in prehistoric Scotland.

Summary updated

Abstract

Notes the discovery of a receptacle containing a cremation deposit in the garden of a private house and subsequent investigation at the find spot. The encrustation on the inside of the urn produced a radiocarbon date of 1626--1408 cal BC and it is suggested that the container may have been used for domestic purposes prior to burial. Post excavation analyses include: `Cordoned urn' (146--8) and `Chemical analysis' (151--3) by Andy Jones;`Cremated human remains' by Julie Roberts (148--9); `DNA analysis' by Gavin MacGregor (150); `Magnetic susceptibility' by John Syme Duncan (150--1); `Pollen and macroscopic plant remains' by Susan Ramsay (153--5); and `Quartz' by Mike Donnelly (155--6).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{macgregor1999excavation,
  author = {Gavin MacGregor and Michael Donnelly and James S. Duncan and Andy M. Jones and Susan Ramsay and Julie Roberts},
  title = {{The excavation of a cordoned urn at Benderloch, Argyll}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.9750/psas.128.143.159},
}
Figure