The Evolution of China’s New Energy Vehicle Industry from the Perspective of a Technology–Market–Policy Framework

Peng Yu, Jian Zhang, Defang Yang, Xin Lin, Tian‐Ying XuSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the rapid growth of China's New Energy Vehicle (NEV) industry through a "technology-market-policy" framework. It identifies three key drivers for China's success: government and market co-direction of technological development, proactive policy-making aligned with market cycles, and the government's adaptive role.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Air pollution and energy security are pressing global concerns. China, a major contributor to CO2 emissions and a significant oil importer, has prioritized the development of New Energy Vehicles (NEVs) as a solution. While China's NEV industry has seen remarkable growth, the underlying factors driving this success, particularly the interplay between technological advancements, market dynamics, and government policy, remain complex and warrant detailed investigation. This paper aims to dissect this evolution to understand China's unique path to becoming a global leader in NEVs.

Methods

The authors employ a qualitative research approach using a "technology-market-policy" framework to analyze the evolution of China's NEV industry. This framework breaks down the industry's development into three dimensions:

  • Technology: Focuses on technological standards, R&D investment, and industrial investment.
  • Market: Examines consumer demand and consumption structure.
  • Policy: Investigates government interventions, including administrative policies (technical support, R&D funding) and economic policies (subsidies, tax exemptions, government procurement, demonstration projects).

The study divides China's NEV development into three distinct stages (2001-2007: Preliminary; 2008-2013: Rearing; 2014-2017: Growth) based on market sales data. National policies relevant to each stage were collected and analyzed using content analysis to identify trends and the impact of different policy types.

Datasets

  • Patent Data: Collected from the Patent Search and Analysis database to track technological development trends in HEVs, PHEVs, BEVs, and FCVs.
  • NEV Sales Volume Data: Obtained from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA) to delineate market growth and identify developmental stages.
  • National Policy Documents: Gathered from various Chinese government ministries and commissions to understand the policy landscape.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Co-evolution of Technology and Market: Unlike traditional market-driven industries, China's NEV technological trajectory has been significantly shaped by both government guidance and market demand. This dual influence has ensured that technological development is not only innovative but also aligned with practical market needs.
  • Periodicity of Market and Proactive Policy: The authors highlight that markets exhibit cyclical behavior. China's success is partly attributed to its ability to anticipate these cycles and implement forward-looking policies that support the industry's growth and transition through different phases.
  • Adaptive Government Role: The Chinese government has strategically evolved its role from an active partner in the early stages to a facilitator and supporter of infrastructure development in later, more mature phases. This adaptability has been crucial in navigating the complexities of fostering a nascent industry.
  • Policy Diversity: China's policy approach is characterized by its diversity and comprehensiveness, encompassing both administrative and economic measures, which has been instrumental in mobilizing resources and driving industry development.

Key Results

The study identifies three key reasons for China's NEV industry success:

  1. Dual Direction of Technical Road: The technical path for NEVs has been guided by both government directives and market signals.
  2. Market Periodicity and Proactive Policies: Policies have been strategically set ahead of market trends, anticipating its cyclical nature.
  3. Government Role Transformation: The government has effectively adapted its role throughout the industry's development.

The paper also details the policy landscape across three stages:

  • Preliminary Stage (2001-2007): Focused on R&D and manufacturing, with early administrative policies like the "863 program" and the "three verticals and three horizontals" plan.
  • Rearing Stage (2008-2013): Saw the rise of PHEVs and BEVs, driven by policies like the "ten cities and thousand vehicles" demonstration program, government procurement, and financial support. Economic policies, particularly subsidies and tax exemptions, played a dominant role.
  • Growth Stage (2014-2017): Characterized by the dominance of BEVs, with policies shifting towards building charging infrastructure, promoting technical innovation, and encouraging social capital investment. The government began to reduce subsidies while implementing tax exemptions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on National Policies: The study primarily analyzes national-level policies, acknowledging that local policies can also have significant influence (e.g., Beijing's subsidy policy for BEVs and FCVs).
  • Future Development Inferences: The authors suggest that based on the current resource endowment, future developments will likely involve increased internationalization of Chinese NEV companies, a continued focus on technological advancement (especially fuel cell vehicles), and further development of charging infrastructure. They also propose that the government's role will continue to evolve towards supporting infrastructure and fostering a stable market environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since air pollution and energy safety have become two worldwide concerns, New Energy Vehicles (NEVs) are one of the solutions to solve these problems. China has been taking action toward the NEV industry and has been successful. This paper aims to explore the evolution of the Chinese NEV industry. By using a three-dimensional model of technology, market and policy, we collected the national level policies from three NEV developmental stages based on the market sales. We found three reasons for its rising up in China: first, the NEV technical road has been directed by both the government and the market; second, the market has periodicity, so the prospective policies have been set ahead; and third, the government has transformed its role on time. Based on the resource endowment the industry has now, we can draw some inferences on its further development in the longitudinal direction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2019evolution,
  author = {Peng Yu and Jian Zhang and Defang Yang and Xin Lin and Tian‐Ying Xu},
  title = {{The Evolution of China’s New Energy Vehicle Industry from the Perspective of a Technology–Market–Policy Framework}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11061711},
}
Figure