The European CO 2 , CO, CH 4 and N 2 O balance between 2001 and 2005

Sebastiaan Luyssaert, Gwénaël Abril, R. J. Andres, David Bastviken, Valentin Bellassen, P. Bergamaschi, Philippe Bousquet, Frédéric Chevallier, Philippe Ciais, M. Corazza, René Dechow, Karl‐Heinz Erb, Giuseppe Etiope, Audrey Fortems‐Cheiney, Giacomo Grassi, J. Hartman, Martin Jung, Juliette Lathière, Annalea Lohila, Nils Moosdorf, Sylvestre Njakou Djomo, Juliane Otto, Dario Papale, Wouter Peters, Philippe Peylin, Peter A. Raymond, Christian Rödenbeck, Sanna Saarnio, Ernst‐Detlef Schulze, Sophie Szopa, Rona L. Thompson, Pieter Johannes Verkerk, Nicolas Vuichard, R. Wang, M. Wattenbach, Sönke Zaehle2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of Europe's greenhouse gas (GHG) balance from 2001-2005, using a novel dual-constraint approach that combines inventory data, flux measurements, and atmospheric inversions. The study confirms Europe is a net source of GHGs, with terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems absorbing some fossil fuel emissions but being insufficient to mitigate overall climate change impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, terrestrial ecosystems are known to absorb a significant portion of anthropogenic emissions, with a notable fraction occurring north of the equator. However, understanding the precise balance of greenhouse gases (CO2, CO, CH4, and N2O) within specific regions like Europe, and how this balance is influenced by various ecosystems, remains a challenge. Accurately quantifying these regional balances is crucial for climate modeling and policy development. This paper addresses the need for a robust, multi-faceted assessment of Europe's GHG budget, confronting different estimation methods to build confidence in the results and identify key areas of uncertainty.

Methods

The authors employ a "dual-constraint approach" to estimate Europe's GHG balance. This involves:

  1. Land-based balance from ecosystem carbon inventories: This method relies on tracking changes in carbon stocks within various ecosystems (forests, grasslands, croplands, etc.) and biological products.
  2. Land-based balance from flux measurements: This approach utilizes eddy-covariance measurements to directly quantify the exchange of GHGs between ecosystems and the atmosphere.
  3. Atmospheric-based balance from inversion: This method uses atmospheric GHG concentration measurements and sophisticated models to infer the net flux of GHGs from the European continent.

By confronting these three independent approaches, the researchers aim to increase confidence in their findings and identify discrepancies that highlight areas of uncertainty. They also incorporate a life cycle analysis (LCA) to estimate the "CO2 cost" of land management practices, acknowledging that ecosystem services are not entirely "free."

Datasets

The study utilizes a range of datasets, including:

  • Ecosystem carbon inventories: Data on carbon stocks in terrestrial ecosystems, inland waters, and biological products.
  • Flux measurements: Eddy-covariance data from tower networks measuring CO2 exchange.
  • Atmospheric GHG concentrations: Data used for atmospheric inversion models.
  • Land cover data: CORINE database for spatial extent of land use.
  • Forest inventory data: For estimating carbon budgets in Russian forests.
  • Fertilizer and herbicide consumption data: From the European Fertilizer Association (EFMA).
  • Wood harvest data: From the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO).
  • Emission factors: From the Ecoinvent database.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather synthesizes and analyzes existing data from various sources.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Europe is a net GHG source: Despite some carbon uptake by ecosystems, Europe as a whole releases more GHGs than it absorbs, contributing to climate change.
  • Ecosystems absorb fossil fuel emissions, but not enough: Terrestrial and inland aquatic ecosystems sequester a significant amount of CO2 from fossil fuel burning (around 210 ± 70 Tg C yr⁻¹), but this is insufficient to offset overall emissions.
  • Land management has a CO2 cost: Realizing ecosystem carbon sinks requires energy inputs for land management (ploughing, fertilizing, etc.), which have their own associated CO2 emissions. This means the "ecosystem service" of carbon sequestration comes at a price.
  • Uncertainty remains a major challenge: While the three different approaches show good agreement, the overall uncertainty in the GHG balance is still large, largely due to the unknown uncertainties of many data products.
  • Inland waters are significant carbon sinks: Aquatic systems are estimated to be the second-largest contributors to fossil fuel uptake, ranking above croplands and grasslands.

Key Results

  • Good agreement between methods: The GHG balances derived from fluxes (1249 ± 545 Tg C in CO2-eq yr⁻¹), inventories (1299 ± 200 Tg C in CO2-eq yr⁻¹), and inversions (1210 ± 405 Tg C in CO2-eq yr⁻¹) show good agreement, increasing confidence in the accuracy of the estimates.
  • Net CO2 uptake by ecosystems: Terrestrial and inland aquatic ecosystems sequester approximately 210 ± 70 Tg C yr⁻¹ from fossil fuel burning.
  • Impact of land management: Accounting for the CO2 cost of ecosystem management reduces the net uptake by an estimated 45%, though it still indicates substantial sequestration.
  • GHG source overall: When considering all major GHGs, the C-uptake by ecosystems is compensated for by other GHG emissions, making European ecosystems unlikely to mitigate climate change.
  • CO2 cost of management: The CO2 cost for ecosystem management is estimated at 65 Tg C yr⁻¹ for cropland, 14 Tg C yr⁻¹ for grassland, and 10 Tg C yr⁻¹ for forest.

Limitations and Future Work

  • High uncertainty: The paper explicitly states that the uncertainty in the GHG balances remains large and lacks formal estimates for many components. Reducing this uncertainty requires formal estimation of the key dominant fluxes.
  • Temporal consistency: Achieving high temporal consistency in the GHG balances proved difficult due to data limitations, with estimates often assigned to a period (2001-2005) using data from other time frames.
  • Spatial representativeness: While spatial consistency was reasonably achieved, it remains unclear if all data products are representative of the entire spatial domain, as some were sampled only in subregions.
  • Life Cycle Analysis scope: The LCA for the CO2 cost of land management was limited to ecosystem management and did not include subsequent processing of food and raw materials, which could significantly alter the outcome.
  • Future work: The authors emphasize the need for formal uncertainty analyses for upscaled NEE and changes in forest carbon. They also suggest that improved atmospheric transport accounting to adjacent regions could further enhance consistency. Integrated studies accounting for the complex interactions of carbon and nitrogen cycles, land use, and environmental changes are crucial for a better understanding of Europe's land carbon balance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Globally, terrestrial ecosystems have absorbed about 30% of anthropogenic emissions over the period 20007–2007 and inter-hemispheric gradients indicate that a significant fraction of terrestrial carbon sequestration must be north of the Equator. We present a compilation of the CO2, CO, CH4 and N2O balance of Europe following a dual constraint approach in which (1) a land-based balance derived mainly from ecosystem carbon inventories and (2) a land-based balance derived from flux measurements are confronted with (3) the atmospheric-based balance derived from inversion informed by measurements of atmospheric GHG concentrations. Good agreement between the GHG balances based on fluxes (1249 ± 545 Tg C in CO2-eq y−1), inventories (1299 ± 200 Tg C in CO2-eq y−1) and inversions (1210 ± 405 Tg C in CO2-eq y−1) increases our confidence that current European GHG balances are accurate. However, the uncertainty remains large and largely lacks formal estimates. Given that European net land-atmosphere balances are determined by a few dominant fluxes, the uncertainty of these key components needs to be formally estimated before efforts could be made to reduce the overall uncertainty. The dual-constraint approach confirmed that the European land surface, including inland waters and urban areas, is a net source for CO2, CO, CH4 and N2O. However, for all ecosystems except croplands, C uptake exceeds C release and us such 210 ± 70 Tg C y−1 from fossil fuel burning is removed from the atmosphere and sequestered in both terrestrial and inland aquatic ecosystems. If the C cost for ecosystem management is taken into account, the net uptake of ecosystems was estimated to decrease by 45% but still indicates substantial C-sequestration. Also, when the balance is extended from CO2 towards the main GHGs, C-uptake by terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems is compensated for by emissions of GHGs. As such the European ecosystems are unlikely to contribute to mitigating the effects of climate change.
BibTeX
@misc{luyssaert2012european,
  author = {Sebastiaan Luyssaert and Gwénaël Abril and R. J. Andres and David Bastviken and Valentin Bellassen and P. Bergamaschi and Philippe Bousquet and Frédéric Chevallier and Philippe Ciais and M. Corazza and René Dechow and Karl‐Heinz Erb and Giuseppe Etiope and Audrey Fortems‐Cheiney and Giacomo Grassi and J. Hartman and Martin Jung and Juliette Lathière and Annalea Lohila and Nils Moosdorf and Sylvestre Njakou Djomo and Juliane Otto and Dario Papale and Wouter Peters and Philippe Peylin and Peter A. Raymond and Christian Rödenbeck and Sanna Saarnio and Ernst‐Detlef Schulze and Sophie Szopa and Rona L. Thompson and Pieter Johannes Verkerk and Nicolas Vuichard and R. Wang and M. Wattenbach and Sönke Zaehle},
  title = {{The European CO <sub>2</sub> , CO, CH <sub>4</sub> and N <sub>2</sub> O balance between 2001 and 2005}},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.5194/bgd-9-2005-2012},
}
Figure