The end user sensor tree: An end-user friendly sensor database

Joost L.d. Nelis, Aristeidis S. Tsagkaris, Yunfeng Zhao, Javier Lou-Franco, Philana Nolan, Huiyu Zhou, Cuong Cao, Karen Rafferty, Jana Hajšlová, Christopher T. Elliott, Katrina CampbellBiosensors 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "The End user Sensor Tree" (TEST), a novel interactive platform that aims to bridge the gap between scientific sensor development and end-user needs. By classifying over 900 sensor-based methods using user-centric criteria, TEST provides a comprehensive, accessible database to aid in sensor selection and promote commercialization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of sensor technology for food contamination detection is rapidly advancing, but this progress often leads to a fragmentation of knowledge. Detailed information about robust, calibrated sensors is frequently buried in scientific journals or scattered across commercial kits, making it difficult for end-users (whether researchers or industry professionals) to identify the most suitable tools for their specific needs. This lack of accessibility and a clear comparison framework hinders the commercialization of promising academic innovations and can lead to the "reinvention of the wheel." The authors aim to address this by creating a centralized, user-friendly repository that maps sensor capabilities and facilitates informed decision-making.

Methods

The core of the TEST platform is a non-linear, interactive decision tree that guides users through a classification system based on four key criteria:

  1. Expertise needed: Whether a scientist or technician is required, or if a non-expert can operate the sensor.
  2. Method portability: Categorizing sensors as non-portable, semi-portable, or fully portable.
  3. Quantification capability: Differentiating between methods that provide precise quantitative results, semi-quantitative approximations, or qualitative presence/absence detection.
  4. Multiplexing ability: Whether the sensor can detect multiple analytes simultaneously.

This classification system is applied to over 900 sensor-based methods, drawn from both scientific literature and commercial products, covering aquatic toxins, mycotoxins, pesticides, and microorganisms. The data is presented in "e-docs" with a fixed layout, providing tailored information accessible via the decision tree. Analytical parameters are also recorded in Excel files for further analysis.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" for this work is a curated collection of over 900 sensor-based methods. This collection was compiled through:

  • Academic Literature: Exploiting the Scopus database with specific keyword searches combining analyte type, portability, quantification, and food matrices. Articles were selected based on being original research from 2013-2017, peer-reviewed, cited at least twice or recently published, and written in English.
  • Commercial Products: Identified through cross-referencing, a previous review, and manual Google searches.

This resulted in 633 detection methods from scientific literature and 309 commercial sensors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • User-Centric Classification is Key: The authors argue that traditional sensor classification based on recognition elements or transducers is less useful for end-users than a system focused on practical aspects like portability, expertise, and quantification.
  • The "Valley of Death" is Real: There's a significant gap between promising academic sensor technologies (especially electrochemical and nanomaterial-based ones) and their commercial availability, suggesting a need for more investment in validation and market capture.
  • Test Strips Bridge the Gap: While advanced technologies struggle to cross the commercialization hurdle, simple test strips are effectively bridging the "valley of death" by offering rapid, user-friendly solutions, even if they sometimes offer only rough quantification.
  • Multiplexing is Lacking Commercially: Despite the prevalence of multiplexed sensors in research, there's a notable scarcity of commercially available multiplex kits, particularly for aquatic toxins and pesticides.
  • Geographic Concentration: Sensor development for food contaminants is heavily concentrated in China and the USA, followed by the EU.

Key Results

  • The TEST platform integrates data on 942 detection methods (633 research reports and 309 commercial sensors).
  • ELISA and test strips are the dominant analytical techniques in commercially available kits across most target groups, except for microorganisms where PCR and plating prevail.
  • Non-portable sensors still dominate for pesticides, microorganisms, mycotoxins, and aquatic toxins, with LC-MS being a common non-portable method.
  • Electrochemical (EC) and nanomaterial-based sensors show high potential for sensitivity, with EC sensors achieving sub-ppt sensitivity in some cases.
  • Analysis times vary significantly: Mycotoxin strip tests can be as fast as 5 minutes, while pathogen detection often requires enrichment steps, extending analysis times to 24-48 hours.
  • Commercialization Gaps: No commercial test kits using EC or nanomaterial components were identified for aquatic toxins and pesticides, highlighting a significant market gap.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensitivity Evaluation: The authors acknowledge that sensitivity data (LODs) from the literature may sometimes be evaluated in buffer rather than real matrix, which can be misleading.
  • Commercial Data Difficulty: Reviewing commercial products was more challenging due to limited publication beyond early-stage prototypes.
  • Future Work: The authors hope TEST will increase sensor promulgation and aim to expand it into a comprehensive platform for numerous analytes across food and medical sectors. They also envision it fostering better communication between stakeholders and shaping the future of biosensing. They encourage other enthusiasts and stakeholders to contribute to this effort.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{nelis2019end,
  author = {Joost L.D. Nelis and Aristeidis S. Tsagkaris and Yunfeng Zhao and Javier Lou-Franco and Philana Nolan and Huiyu Zhou and Cuong Cao and Karen Rafferty and Jana Hajšlová and Christopher T. Elliott and Katrina Campbell},
  title = {{The end user sensor tree: An end-user friendly sensor database}},
  booktitle = {Biosensors},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.bios.2019.01.055},
}

Loading related content...

Figure