The emergence of AdS(2) from quantum fluctuations

J. Ambjørn, Romuald A. Janik, W. Westra, Stefan ZohrenOxford 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We have shown how the quantization of two-dimensional quantum gravity with an action which contains only a positive cosmological constant and boundary cosmological constants leads to the emergence of a spacetime which can be described as a constant negative curvature spacetime with superimposed quantum fluctuations.

Introduction

A central challenge in theoretical physics is understanding how the smooth, continuous spacetime described by general relativity emerges from the chaotic, discrete fluctuations of quantum gravity. This problem of "background independence" requires that the geometry of spacetime should not be assumed at the outset but should instead arise naturally from the underlying quantum theory.

In this work, we explore this emergence using a simplified two-dimensional (2D) model. While 2D gravity does not possess the complex gravitational waves of our 4D universe, it serves as a rigorous mathematical laboratory for testing whether a specific geometry—specifically Anti-de Sitter space ($AdS_2$)—can be derived purely from quantum building blocks.

Methodology: Causal Dynamical Triangulations

To model the quantum geometry, we utilize the framework of Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT). In this approach, spacetime is approximated using simplicial complexes—tiny, flat triangles. By summing over all possible ways to glue these triangles together (the path integral), we can calculate quantum probabilities for different geometric configurations.

Unlike earlier Euclidean models, CDT imposes a strict "causal" structure by requiring a global time foliation. This ensures that cause precedes effect even at the smallest scales. The dynamics of the model are governed by a simple Einstein-Hilbert action:

$$S = \Lambda \int \sqrt{g} d^2x + X L_{in} + Y L_{out}$$

Here, $\Lambda$ represents the bulk cosmological constant, while $X$ and $Y$ are boundary cosmological constants. In two dimensions, the curvature term is a topological constant, meaning the dynamics are driven entirely by these cosmological parameters. We specifically solve for the "loop-loop propagator," which represents the probability amplitude for a spatial loop to evolve into another loop over a time interval $T$.

Key Insights: Negative Curvature from Positive Constants

One of the most striking results of this derivation is that an action containing only a positive cosmological constant ($\Lambda > 0$) leads to a background geometry characterized by constant negative curvature ($R = -8\Lambda$).

This transition depends on a critical value for the boundary cosmological constant ($Y = -\sqrt{\Lambda}$). At this specific point, the geometry transitions from a compact, closed state to a non-compact, infinite state, effectively "opening up" into a version of $AdS_2$.

Furthermore, we demonstrate that the resulting geometry is remarkably stable. In many quantum models, fluctuations are so violent that they prevent the emergence of a smooth manifold. In this CDT model, however, the relative fluctuations of the spatial length decay exponentially over time:

$$\frac{\delta L(t)}{\langle L(t) \rangle} \sim e^{-\sqrt{\Lambda}t}$$

As time $t$ increases, the "quantumness" of the system diminishes, leaving behind a stable, semi-classical spacetime.

Results and the Emergent Metric

The authors derived the explicit metric for the emergent background geometry:

$$ds^2 = dt^2 + \frac{\sinh^2(2\sqrt{\Lambda}t)}{4\Lambda} d\theta^2$$

This metric is mathematically identical to that of the Poincaré disc, which is the Euclidean (Wick-rotated) version of 2D Anti-de Sitter space ($AdS_2$). Because the fluctuations become exponentially small for large times ($t \gg \Lambda^{-1/2}$), the resulting geometry behaves like a genuine classical background "dressed" with minor quantum jitters.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While these results provide a clear mechanism for the emergence of $AdS_2$, several challenges remain:

  1. Dimensionality: This is a 2D model. While $AdS_2$ is highly relevant to black hole physics and string theory, our universe is 4D.
  2. Wick Rotation: The current result describes a Euclidean version of $AdS_2$. Translating these findings back into Lorentzian space (with real time) is a non-trivial task.

The significance of this work lies in its analytical proof of concepts observed in 4D CDT numerical simulations. By bridging the gap between exact 2D solutions and complex 4D computations, we move closer to explaining how the geometry of our own universe might emerge from fundamental quantum fluctuations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have shown how the quantization of two-dimensional quantum gravity with an action which contains only a positive cosmological constant and boundary cosmological constants leads to the emergence of a spacetime which can be described as a constant negative curvature spacetime with superimposed quantum fluctuations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ambjrn2006emergence,
  author = {J. Ambjørn and Romuald A. Janik and W. Westra and Stefan Zohren},
  title = {{The emergence of AdS(2) from quantum fluctuations}},
  booktitle = {Oxford},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.gr-qc/0610101},
}
Figure