TL;DR
This paper surveys the landscape of computational rhetorical figure detection, identifying ten key challenges that hinder progress beyond common figures like metaphor and irony. By analyzing over 40 papers, the authors highlight issues from inconsistent definitions to data scarcity and propose solutions to encourage broader research into the vast array of rhetorical devices.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While natural language processing (NLP) has made strides in understanding text, a significant portion of human communication relies on rhetorical figures – linguistic devices that go beyond literal meaning to add emphasis, emotion, or persuasion. Think of metaphors, irony, sarcasm, but also less commonly studied figures like antithesis, litotes, or polyptoton. Detecting these figures computationally is crucial for improving various NLP tasks, from sentiment analysis to hate speech detection. However, current research heavily favors a few well-known figures, leaving a vast "elephant in the room" of under-researched rhetorical devices. This paper aims to identify and articulate the systemic challenges that prevent researchers from tackling this broader spectrum of figures, offering insights and potential solutions to advance the field.
Methods
The authors conducted a comprehensive survey of over 40 research papers focused on the computational detection of rhetorical figures other than metaphor, simile, analogy, sarcasm, and irony. They analyzed these papers to identify recurring challenges and then compiled a list of ten key issues. For each challenge, they also suggest potential solutions to encourage future research. Their methodology involved searching Google Scholar for relevant work, explicitly excluding only the ACL anthology to capture a wider range of publications. The investigated papers spanned from 2006 to 2024.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it discusses the general characteristics and limitations of existing datasets for rhetorical figure detection. A key observation is that datasets often suffer from imbalanced class distributions (i.e., a vast majority of text does not contain the target rhetorical figure), which can be deceptive when using accuracy as a performance metric. The authors also note that many datasets are English-centric.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Elephant in the Room": The vast majority of research focuses on a handful of rhetorical figures (metaphor, irony, sarcasm), neglecting the hundreds of others that are equally important and prevalent.
- Inconsistent Definitions are a Major Hurdle: The lack of standardized definitions and the varying interpretations of what constitutes a rhetorical figure make consistent annotation and model development extremely difficult. This is exacerbated by language-dependent figures and differing definitions across languages.
- Beyond Binary Classification: Treating rhetorical figure detection as a simple binary (present/absent) task is insufficient. The authors advocate for a ranking scheme based on salience or the degree to which textual definitions are met, suggesting methods like best-worst scaling for more nuanced annotation.
- Context is King (and Hard to Define): Rhetorical figures often rely heavily on context for interpretation, and defining the appropriate boundaries (sentence, paragraph, or whole document) for this context is a significant challenge. Distinguishing between accidental and intentional usage is also problematic.
- Data Scarcity and Bias: While popular figures benefit from user-generated tags (e.g., #sarcasm), less common figures lack readily available annotated data. This can lead to biased datasets that exclude edge cases.
- The Promise and Peril of LLMs: Large Language Models (LLMs) offer potential for generating synthetic data and aiding detection, but they are also limited by their training data and can perpetuate existing biases. Human oversight remains crucial.
- The Neglect of Cognitive Effects: Current research primarily focuses on detection, often overlooking the cognitive effects and interpretative nuances of rhetorical figures, which are essential for understanding their persuasive power.
- The Need for Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Rhetorical figure detection is inherently interdisciplinary, requiring collaboration between computer scientists, linguists, and experts from fields like psychology and law to build a holistic understanding.
Key Results
The paper does not present quantitative results from a specific experiment. Instead, it presents a qualitative analysis of existing research, identifying and categorizing ten key challenges in computational rhetorical figure detection. It also provides suggested solutions for each challenge. The authors analyzed over 40 papers and found that approximately 68.97% of the approaches were rule-based, while only 27.59% were model-based. English is the dominant language of study, with 69.81% of approaches focusing on it.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their survey is based on a review of existing literature and does not involve new experimental work. They highlight the following limitations and suggest future directions:
- Inconsistent Definitions: Future work should focus on developing more standardized ontologies and annotation schemes for rhetorical figures.
- Boundary Definition: More research is needed on how to effectively define contextual boundaries for figure detection.
- Data Scarcity: LLMs can be leveraged for data augmentation, but human annotation and validation remain critical. Game-like platforms for user contribution are also proposed.
- Imbalanced Datasets: Augmentation, over/undersampling, and careful selection of evaluation metrics are crucial.
- Ontologies: Integrating formal ontologies of rhetorical figures into detection systems could improve accuracy and agreement.
- Context: Incorporating broader context (pre- and succeeding sentences) and leveraging LLMs for contextual ambiguity resolution are important.
- Rule-based vs. Model-based: While LLMs are promising, a hybrid approach combining LLMs with rule-based methods might be beneficial for certain figures.
- Multilingualism: Encouraging research in languages other than English and developing multilingual tools is essential to avoid NLP inequalities.
- Cognitive Effects: Future research should move beyond mere detection to interpret the cognitive and emotional impact of rhetorical figures.
- Interdisciplinary Efforts: Fostering collaboration across disciplines will lead to a more comprehensive understanding and improved detection capabilities.
Summary updated