TL;DR
This paper describes the organization and goals of the EICS 2014 Doctoral Consortium, a pre-conference event designed to foster PhD students in Engineering Interactive Computing Systems (EICS). The consortium aimed to provide students with valuable feedback on their research from senior academics and peers, and to integrate their work into the broader EICS community through dedicated presentations and posters at the main conference.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the challenge of effectively supporting and integrating early-career researchers within specialized academic communities like Engineering Interactive Computing Systems (EICS). PhD students, especially in rapidly evolving fields, often benefit from early and constructive feedback on their research direction, methodology, and findings. Furthermore, connecting these emerging researchers with established members of the community and exposing their work to a wider audience can accelerate their progress and foster collaboration. The EICS Doctoral Consortium was conceived as a solution to provide this structured environment for feedback and community integration.
Methods
The EICS 2014 Doctoral Consortium was structured as a closed, day-long event held the day before the main conference. It involved a selected group of doctoral candidates presenting their ongoing research to a panel of advisors and their peers. The presentations were designed to be concise, focusing on key research questions, methods, and initial results. A crucial element of the consortium was the interactive discussion, where participants were encouraged to play a "supporting/opposing" role, offering constructive criticism and identifying strengths and weaknesses in each other's work. To further integrate the students' work into the main conference, participants also presented their research during a dedicated session at EICS 2014, accompanied by posters displayed throughout the conference.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The value of peer feedback: The consortium highlighted the significant benefit of having doctoral candidates present their work to a diverse group of peers and senior researchers. This cross-pollination of ideas and perspectives can be invaluable for refining research questions and methodologies.
- Bridging the gap between doctoral work and the broader community: By holding the consortium before the main conference and including dedicated presentation slots and poster sessions, the event effectively served as a bridge, introducing emerging research to the established EICS community.
- Structured interaction for constructive criticism: The "supporting/opposing" role-playing encouraged a more active and critical engagement with each other's research, moving beyond passive listening to active contribution.
- Early integration for sustained engagement: Presenting work early in the conference allowed participants to engage in further discussions with attendees throughout the event, fostering deeper connections and potential collaborations.
Key Results
The paper does not present quantitative results in terms of student outcomes or feedback metrics. However, it details the successful selection of seven doctoral candidates for the consortium, covering a range of EICS topics. The structure of the consortium, with its distinct sessions on "HCI and Model-Driven Engineering" and "Large, Complex and Critical Systems," indicates a deliberate effort to group related research for more focused discussions. The paper lists the names and affiliations of the seven participating students and their research topics, demonstrating the breadth of work presented.
Limitations and Future Work
The paper does not explicitly discuss limitations of the consortium itself. However, it implies that the success of such events relies heavily on the active participation and engagement of both students and advisors. Future work could involve evaluating the long-term impact of the consortium on the participants' research trajectories and career development. Further research could also explore different formats for the consortium to maximize feedback and networking opportunities.
Summary updated