The efficiency of fishway with different water replenishment methods

Junjun Tan, Dechen Wang, Wang Yuanyang, Sun Junjian, Bixin Cheng, Zhu Dongzhou, Yan Xin, Senfan Ke, Xinyu Li, Shi XiaotaoJournal of Lake Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Optimizing fishway entrances is critical for restoring river connectivity, yet many designs fail because fish simply can't find the "door." This study demonstrates that using parallel water replenishment at the entrance significantly outperforms vertical replenishment, doubling attraction efficiency for the target species, Schizothorax wangchiachii. Furthermore, the research highlights a strong diel rhythm, with over 58% of fish successfully locating the entrance under the cover of night.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydropower dams provide clean energy but create physical barriers for migratory fish. While fishways (fish ladders) are built to bypass these dams, their effectiveness hinges on a "bottleneck" problem: the entrance. If the hydraulic cues at the entrance are weak or confusing, fish will never find the path upstream.

Engineers often use "water replenishment"—adding extra flow at the fishway entrance—to create an attractive plume that guides fish. However, the optimal angle and volume of this replenishment are often debated. This paper specifically investigates how different replenishment strategies affect the attraction and entrance efficiency for the short-bearded snowtrout (Schizothorax wangchiachii) in the Heishui River, a tributary of the Jinsha River in China.

Methods

The researchers conducted field experiments at the Songxin Fishway between 2021 and 2023. Their approach combined biological monitoring with advanced hydraulic modeling:

  • PIT Tagging: Experimental fish were equipped with Passive Integrated Transponder (PIT) tags. Antennas placed at the fishway entrance and within the channel tracked exactly when and if a fish arrived and entered.
  • Hydraulic Simulation: The team used FLOW-3D software to model flow velocity and Turbulence Kinetic Energy (TKE) under different replenishment scenarios (parallel vs. vertical angles).
  • Statistical Modeling: To identify key drivers, they employed a Cox proportional hazards regression model to analyze "attraction time" (how long it takes a fish to find the entrance) and a logistic regression model to evaluate "entrance efficiency" (the probability of a fish successfully entering once attracted).
  • Experimental Design: They compared a control group (no replenishment) against four experimental conditions varying the replenishment flow rate ($Q_a$) and the angle of injection.

Datasets

The study relied on several integrated datasets:

  • Fish Capture Data: 392 fish from 11 species were sampled to determine the dominant species and size distributions.
  • Experimental Tracking: Data from 457 PIT-tagged S. wangchiachii across multiple trials.
  • Hydraulic Data: Real-time monitoring of water temperature, river discharge, and fishway flow rates via an automated hydrological station.
  • Numerical Validation: A dataset of 19 measured flow velocity points used to validate the accuracy of the FLOW-3D simulations ($R^2 = 0.906$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parallel is Paramount: Parallel replenishment (where the extra water is injected in the same direction as the fishway flow) creates a stable, elongated high-velocity plume. Vertical replenishment, by contrast, creates "dead zones" and turbulent cross-currents that seem to confuse the fish, leading to much lower attraction rates.
  • The Night Shift: The study found a significant "diel rhythm." Fish were much more likely to arrive at the entrance at night (specifically between 18:00 and 06:00). This suggests that S. wangchiachii may rely more on hydraulic cues when visual cues are absent, or simply prefer migrating under the safety of darkness.
  • The "Goldilocks" Flow: There is a specific hydraulic window for success. If the replenishment flow is too low, the signal is lost in the river's main current. If it's too high, the resulting turbulence can exceed the fish's swimming capability. The authors identified an optimal replenishment flow range of 0.94–2.42 m³/s.
  • Attraction vs. Entrance: The factors that help a fish find the entrance (attraction) aren't necessarily the same as those that make them go inside (entrance). While replenishment angle was vital for attraction, once the fish reached the door, the entrance efficiency remained relatively high (above 56%) across both replenishment types.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Gains: Parallel replenishment achieved an average attraction efficiency of 26.47%, compared to just 13.11% for vertical replenishment.
  • Time to Attraction: The Cox model showed that parallel replenishment and nighttime conditions significantly reduced the time it took for fish to locate the entrance.
  • Optimal Hydraulics: The best results were observed when the fishway entrance flow was between 0.16–0.58 m³/s and the replenishment flow was 0.94–2.42 m³/s.
  • Nighttime Dominance: 58.50% of successful attractions occurred at night, with a peak arrival window between 02:00 and 04:00 AM.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few areas for further exploration:

  • Species Specificity: The study focused on a single target species. Different species with different swimming abilities (e.g., burst speeds vs. endurance) might respond differently to the same hydraulic cues.
  • Long-term Monitoring: While the 2021–2023 data is robust, long-term changes in river morphology or fish population dynamics could shift these "optimal" ranges.
  • Multi-Entrance Designs: The study looked at a single entrance. Future research could investigate how replenishment strategies interact in fishways with multiple entrance points.
  • Lighting Effects: Given the strong nighttime preference, investigating the impact of artificial light (or the lack thereof) at the entrance could provide further design optimizations.

Summary updated

Abstract

设计合理的鱼道进口补水角度及补水流量,营造适宜目标鱼类的水流条件是提高鱼道进口诱鱼效果的重要方式。本研究以短须裂腹鱼(Schizothorax wangchiachii)为实验对象,在2021—2023年开展不同补水方式(补水角度、补水流量)下黑水河松新鱼道进口诱鱼效果评估。结果表明:(1)在所有运行工况下,平行补水时鱼道进口平均吸引效率为26.47%,鱼道进口效率达58.89%;垂直补水时,鱼道吸引效率和进口效率分别为13.11%和56.25%;平行补水的诱鱼效果要略优于垂直补水的效果。(2)两种补水方式下58.50%的实验鱼在夜间到达鱼道进口,高于白天鱼道进口诱鱼效果。(3)为识别影响鱼类吸引时间和鱼道进口效率的关键因素,构建了多因素(昼夜节律、竖缝式鱼道流量、补水流量、实验鱼全长、水温、补水角度)的Cox比例风险回归模型和逻辑回归模型,结果表明:补水流量、补水角度和昼夜节律是影响鱼道进口鱼类吸引时间的主要因素。(4)结合短须裂腹鱼上溯时流量情况,当竖缝式鱼道进水口流量范围为0.16~0.58 m<sup>3</sup>/s、补水通道进水口流量为0.94~2.42 m<sup>3</sup>/s时鱼道进口诱鱼效果最佳。本研究结果有助于为引水式水电站过鱼设施的修建以及补水设施设置提供科学支撑。
BibTeX
@article{tan2025efficiency,
  author = {Junjun Tan and Dechen Wang and Wang Yuanyang and Sun Junjian and Bixin Cheng and Zhu Dongzhou and Yan Xin and Senfan Ke and Xinyu Li and Shi Xiaotao},
  title = {{The efficiency of fishway with different water replenishment methods}},
  journal = {Journal of Lake Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.18307/2025.0233},
}

Loading related content...

Figure