The efficacy of acupuncture on endometrial receptivity in infertile women: an overview of systematic review and meta-analysis

Huaying Fan, Jie Zhou, Chenjian Tang, Huan LiuFrontiers in Medicine 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper is an "umbrella review" (an overview of systematic reviews) that audits the evidence for using acupuncture to improve endometrial receptivity in infertile women. While combination therapies show some clinical promise, the authors reveal a sobering reality: 100% of the existing systematic reviews in this field suffer from "critically low" methodological quality and high risk of bias.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For many women struggling with infertility, the "window of implantation"—known as endometrial receptivity (ER)—is the primary hurdle. Poor receptivity is estimated to cause roughly two-thirds of implantation failures. While acupuncture is widely used as an adjuvant therapy (offered by 75% of fertility clinics in the UK, for example), the scientific evidence supporting it is a confusing mosaic of conflicting results.

The authors tackle the "evidence of evidence" problem. Instead of looking at individual patients, they evaluate the quality of the Systematic Reviews (SRs) that clinicians and policymakers rely on. They aim to determine if the current consensus on acupuncture is built on a solid methodological foundation or a house of cards.

Methods

The researchers conducted an umbrella review, searching seven major databases (including PubMed, Embase, and CNKI) through March 2025. They applied four rigorous validation frameworks to the 10 included systematic reviews:

  • AMSTAR 2: Evaluates methodological rigor (e.g., did the authors register a protocol beforehand?).
  • ROBIS: Assesses the risk of bias within the review process itself.
  • PRISMA-A: A specialized checklist for reporting quality in acupuncture research.
  • GRADE: Rates the "certainty" of the clinical outcomes (High, Moderate, Low, or Very Low).

This multi-tool approach allows the authors to distinguish between reporting quality (how well the study was written) and methodological quality (how well the study was actually conducted).

Datasets

As an overview of reviews, the "data" consists of 10 previously published systematic reviews (dated 2019–2023).

  • Scope: These reviews encompassed between 7 and 25 Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) each.
  • Population: Total participants across the reviews ranged from 516 to 3,041 women.
  • Interventions: Included manual acupuncture, electro-acupuncture (EA), transcutaneous electrical acupuncture stimulation (TEAS), and moxibustion.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Quality Paradox: There is a disconnect between how reviews are written and how they are performed. While reporting completeness was relatively high (>70% per PRISMA-A), the actual methodological rigor was "critically low" across the board.
  • The "Protocol" Problem: 100% of the reviewed SRs failed to provide a priori protocols or explain deviations from them. In the world of meta-analysis, not having a pre-registered plan is a major red flag for "cherry-picking" data.
  • Synergy is Key: Acupuncture alone rarely showed significant benefits. However, when used as an adjuvant—combined with IVF, Chinese herbal medicine, or standard medications—there was moderate-to-high quality evidence suggesting improved pregnancy and ovulation rates.
  • Evidence Fragility: Of the 55 clinical outcomes evaluated across all reviews, a staggering 92.7% (51/55) were rated as "low" or "very low" quality under the GRADE framework.

Key Results

  • Methodological Rigor: 10 out of 10 reviews were ranked as Critically Low quality via AMSTAR 2.
  • Risk of Bias: 9 out of 10 reviews were judged to have a High Risk of Bias via ROBIS, primarily due to flaws in study identification and selection.
  • Clinical Efficacy: Despite the poor quality of the reviews, descriptive analysis suggests that acupuncture combined with other treatments may improve:
  • Pregnancy Rates (PR): Supported by moderate-to-high quality evidence in specific combination contexts.
  • Endometrial Thickness (EMT): Generally improved when acupuncture was used as an add-on to IVF or medication.
  • Safety: Acupuncture appears safe, with only minor adverse events reported (dizziness, fainting, or local bruising).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Language Bias: The search was restricted to English and Chinese databases.
  2. Heterogeneity: The reviews lumped together very different types of acupuncture (manual vs. electrical) and different patient subtypes, which "muddies" the data.
  3. Gray Literature: The exclusion of unpublished "gray literature" may have introduced publication bias.

Future Directions: The authors call for the adoption of Core Outcome Sets (COS)—standardized metrics like live birth rate and resistive index (RI)—to ensure future trials are comparable. They also emphasize the need for high-quality RCTs specifically designed to isolate acupuncture's contribution from the effects of the "adjuvant" treatments it is paired with.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42024497881).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fan2025efficacy,
  author = {Huaying Fan and Jie Zhou and Chenjian Tang and Huan Liu},
  title = {{The efficacy of acupuncture on endometrial receptivity in infertile women: an overview of systematic review and meta-analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2025.1609519},
}
Figure