The effects of trauma on feedback processing: an MEG study

Abdul-Rahman Sawalma, Christian M. Kiefer, Frank Boers, N. Jon Shah, Nibal Khudeish, Irene Neuner, Mohammad M. Herzallah, Jürgen DammersFrontiers in Neuroscience 2023 · DOI

Abstract The cognitive impact of psychological trauma can manifest as a range of post-traumatic stress symptoms that are often attributed to impairments in learning from positive and negative outcomes, aka reinforcement learning. Research on the impact of trauma on reinforcement learning has mainly been inconclusive. This study aimed to circumscribe the impact of psychological trauma on reinforcement learning in the context of neural response in time and frequency domains. Two groups of participants were tested - those who had experienced psychological trauma and a control group who had not - while they performed a probabilistic classification task that dissociates learning from positive and negative feedback during a magnetoencephalography (MEG) examination. While the exposure to trauma did not exhibit any effects on learning accuracy or response time for positive or negative feedback, MEG cortical activity was modulated in response to positive feedback. In particular, the medial and lateral orbitofrontal cortices (mOFC and lOFC) exhibited increased activity, while the insular and supramarginal cortices showed decreased activity during positive feedback presentation. Furthermore, when receiving negative feedback, the trauma group displayed higher activity in the medial portion of the superior frontal cortex. The timing of these activity changes occurred between 160 and 600 ms post feedback presentation. Analysis of the time-frequency domain revealed heightened activity in theta and alpha frequency bands (4-10 Hz) in the lOFC in the trauma group. Moreover, dividing the two groups according to their learning performance, the activity for the non-learner subgroup was found to be lower in lOFC and higher in the supramarginal cortex. These differences were found in the trauma group only. The results highlight the localization and neural dynamics of feedback processing that could be affected by exposure to psychological trauma. This approach and associated findings provide a novel framework for understanding the cognitive correlates of psychological trauma in relation to neural dynamics in the space, time, and frequency domains. Subsequent work will focus on the stratification of cognitive and neural correlates as a function of various symptoms of psychological trauma. Clinically, the study findings and approach open the possibility for neuromodulation interventions that synchronize cognitive and psychological constructs for individualized treatment.

Introduction

Psychological trauma often leads to symptoms like avoidance and intrusive memories, which researchers believe are linked to impairments in reinforcement learning—the way we update our behavior based on positive and negative outcomes. However, previous research on this link has been inconsistent. A major challenge has been the tools used: EEG offers great timing but poor spatial resolution, while fMRI shows where things happen but lacks the millisecond-level precision to track fast feedback signals. This study uses Magnetoencephalography (MEG) to bridge that gap, providing a high-resolution look at how trauma affects the brain's response to feedback in space, time, and frequency.

Experimental Design

The study utilized a primary dataset of 76 participants (ages 21–43). The trauma group (n=56) consisted of individuals who had experienced a "Criterion A" traumatic event, while the control group (n=20) had no history of traumatic events. Participants performed a probabilistic classification task while undergoing MEG. In this task, they had to guess whether a fractal image predicted "sun" or "rain."

Figure 1: Experimental paradigm of the probabilistic classification task.

As shown in Figure 1, some images were tied to positive feedback (a green smiley and "+25" points) for correct guesses, while others were tied to negative feedback (a red frowny and "-25" points) for incorrect ones. This design allowed the team to separate learning from positive versus negative outcomes. The team used Spatio-Temporal Cluster Permutation Testing (SCPT) and time-frequency analysis with Morlet wavelets to identify exactly when and where brain activity differed between groups.

Results

Behavioral Resilience vs. Neural Divergence

Surprisingly, there were no significant differences in learning accuracy or reaction times between the groups. This suggests that the behavioral impact of trauma might be subtle or "masked" by compensatory neural mechanisms. However, the MEG data revealed significant differences in neural processing.

Spatial and Temporal Dynamics

Neural differences emerged between 160 and 600 ms after the feedback was presented, coinciding with well-known event-related potentials like the P300 and Late Positive Potential (LPP).

  • Positive Feedback: The trauma group showed increased activity in the medial and lateral orbitofrontal cortices (mOFC and lOFC)—regions involved in calculating value—but decreased activity in the insula and supramarginal gyrus, which are linked to affective processing and memory integration.
  • Negative Feedback: The trauma group displayed higher activity in the medial portion of the superior frontal cortex, a region involved in error monitoring and avoidance behavior.

Frequency Domain Markers

In the lateral OFC, the trauma group showed heightened activity in the 4–10 Hz range (theta and alpha bands). Interestingly, within the trauma group, "non-learners" had even higher power in this range than "learners," suggesting that excessive neural activity in this region might actually interfere with effective learning.

Discussion

The results suggest that trauma survivors might engage in "higher-than-average levels of appraisal" of positive stimuli. Their brains might be working harder to value positive outcomes as a way to counter fear-related symptoms. While the study is cross-sectional and cannot determine causality, it highlights the localization and neural dynamics of feedback processing affected by trauma.

Future work will focus on longitudinal tracking and symptom stratification (e.g., hyperarousal vs. dissociation). Clinically, these findings open the possibility for neuromodulation interventions, such as TMS or tDCS, to synchronize neural dynamics and improve treatment for those with severe post-traumatic symptoms.

Summary updated

Abstract

The cognitive impact of psychological trauma can manifest as a range of post-traumatic stress symptoms that are often attributed to impairments in learning from positive and negative outcomes, aka reinforcement learning. Research on the impact of trauma on reinforcement learning has mainly been inconclusive. This study aimed to circumscribe the impact of psychological trauma on reinforcement learning in the context of neural response in time and frequency domains. Two groups of participants were tested - those who had experienced psychological trauma and a control group who had not - while they performed a probabilistic classification task that dissociates learning from positive and negative feedback during a magnetoencephalography (MEG) examination. While the exposure to trauma did not exhibit any effects on learning accuracy or response time for positive or negative feedback, MEG cortical activity was modulated in response to positive feedback. In particular, the medial and lateral orbitofrontal cortices (mOFC and lOFC) exhibited increased activity, while the insular and supramarginal cortices showed decreased activity during positive feedback presentation. Furthermore, when receiving negative feedback, the trauma group displayed higher activity in the medial portion of the superior frontal cortex. The timing of these activity changes occurred between 160 and 600 ms post feedback presentation. Analysis of the time-frequency domain revealed heightened activity in theta and alpha frequency bands (4-10 Hz) in the lOFC in the trauma group. Moreover, dividing the two groups according to their learning performance, the activity for the non-learner subgroup was found to be lower in lOFC and higher in the supramarginal cortex. These differences were found in the trauma group only. The results highlight the localization and neural dynamics of feedback processing that could be affected by exposure to psychological trauma. This approach and associated findings provide a novel framework for understanding the cognitive correlates of psychological trauma in relation to neural dynamics in the space, time, and frequency domains. Subsequent work will focus on the stratification of cognitive and neural correlates as a function of various symptoms of psychological trauma. Clinically, the study findings and approach open the possibility for neuromodulation interventions that synchronize cognitive and psychological constructs for individualized treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sawalma2023effects,
  author = {Abdul-Rahman Sawalma and Christian M. Kiefer and Frank Boers and N. Jon Shah and Nibal Khudeish and Irene Neuner and Mohammad M. Herzallah and Jürgen Dammers},
  title = {{The effects of trauma on feedback processing: an MEG study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2023.1172549},
}
Figure