The Effects of Transaction Cost Factors on Cooperative Relationship Lasting Factors, Degree of Relationship Satisfaction, and Performance

Sang Wan Lee, Jae Yeol KimJournal of Digital Convergence 2014 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates how transaction cost factors—asset specificity, uncertainty, and opportunism—affect organizational performance both directly and indirectly through cooperative relationship lasting factors and relationship satisfaction. Using a sample of 170 South Korean automotive suppliers, the study finds that uncertainty directly influences both financial and non-financial performance. In contrast, asset specificity and opportunism primarily impact performance indirectly by shaping the longevity and satisfaction of the partnership. Specifically, asset specificity and uncertainty drive relationship longevity, while asset specificity and opportunism determine relationship satisfaction. Ultimately, both relationship longevity and satisfaction are significant predictors of financial and non-financial success.

Introduction

In the global automotive industry, the relationship between a primary manufacturer (OEM) and its parts suppliers is a critical determinant of competitive advantage. In South Korea, this ecosystem has historically been dominated by large OEMs, often placing suppliers in a precarious position characterized by low profit margins and high dependency. This study addresses a fundamental question in organizational economics: How do the "hidden" costs of doing business—transaction costs—translate into bottom-line performance? While traditional research often focuses on the "make or buy" decision, this research investigates the quality of ongoing relationships and how factors like specialized investments or partner opportunism act as barriers or bridges to organizational success.

Theoretical Framework

The study utilizes Transaction Cost Theory (TCT) as its foundation, identifying three independent variables: Asset Specificity, Uncertainty, and Opportunism. To understand the mechanism of their impact, the researchers introduced two mediating variables: "Cooperative Relationship Lasting Factors" (longevity) and "Degree of Relationship Satisfaction."

Conceptual model illustrating the hypothesized relationships between transaction cost factors, mediators, and performance.

The model tests whether these transaction cost factors influence financial and non-financial performance directly or if their impact is filtered through the quality and stability of the partnership.

Methodology

The researchers employed Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to test the complex web of hypotheses. Data was collected via a survey of 170 valid respondents from South Korean auto parts manufacturers, including Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 suppliers across sectors like painting, sewing, and injection molding. Most respondents were high-level managers or executives (44% board-level) with significant industry experience. Performance was measured across financial metrics (ROI, sales growth) and non-financial metrics (quality, delivery speed) using a 7-point Likert scale.

Key Results and Analysis

The statistical analysis validated the measurement model's reliability and the structural model's explanatory power.

Reliability and validity metrics, including AVE, Composite Reliability (CP), R-squared, and Cronbach's alpha.

As shown in the table above, the R² values indicate that the model explains a significant portion of the variance in performance, with financial performance at 0.4905 and non-financial performance at 0.4345.

The Indirect Path to Success

A core finding is that transaction costs, such as specialized equipment (Asset Specificity), do not automatically lead to better performance. Instead, they act as "relationship glue." Investing in assets specific to one OEM makes the relationship harder to break (β = 0.4641, t = 8.1001), which then creates the stability needed for performance to improve.

Uncertainty as a Direct Driver

Unlike other factors, Uncertainty had a direct positive correlation with performance (financial β = 0.1635; non-financial β = 0.1483). This suggests that in highly volatile markets, suppliers that successfully navigate environmental changes and competitive pressures may actually sharpen their internal efficiencies, leading to better outcomes.

The Impact of Opportunism

While opportunism—one party acting in self-interest at the expense of the other—did not directly tank performance, it significantly eroded Relationship Satisfaction. This creates a "slow rot" effect where the partnership becomes less effective over time, eventually impacting the bottom line. Both financial (β = 0.277) and non-financial (β = 0.2725) performance were significantly boosted when suppliers felt satisfied with the partnership.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that transaction cost factors primarily influence organizational performance through the mediators of relationship longevity and satisfaction. For suppliers in the Korean automotive industry, managing these "hidden" costs is not just about efficiency, but about fostering stable and satisfying partnerships. The results highlight that while specialized investments create a structural bond, maintaining satisfaction is equally vital for driving long-term financial and non-financial success.

Summary updated

Abstract

본 연구는 거래비용요소가 경영성과에 미치는 영향을 검증한 것이다. 연구결과, 첫째, 불확실성은 재무적 성과와 비재무적성과에 직접적으로 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났지만, 자산특유성과 기회주의는 경영성과에 직접적인 영향이 없는 것으로 분석되었다. 둘째, 협력관계 지속요인에 직접적으로 영향을 미치는 변수는 자산특유성과 불확실성으로 나타났으나. 기회주의는 직접적인 영향이 없는 것으로 나타났다. 셋째, 관계만족도에 직접적으로 영향을 미치는 변수는 자산특유성과 기회주의로 나타났으며, 불확실성과의 관계는 없는 것으로 분석됐다. 넷째, 협력관계 지속요인과 관계만족도는 재무적 성과와 비재무성과에 각각 직접적으로 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 요약하면, 거래비용요소가 협력관계 지속요인과 관계만족도라는 매개변수를 통하여 경영성과에 영향을 미치고 있음을 발견하였다. This paper investigate how transaction cost factors affect organizational performance both directly and indirectly, through cooperative relationship lasting factors and degree of relationship satisfaction. The results can be summarized as follows: First, asset uncertainty directly influenced financial and non-financial performance. Also asset specificity and opportunism did not influence financial and non financial performance directly. Second cooperative relationship lasting factors were connected with transaction cost factors direct variables on cooperative relationship lasting factors are asset specificity and uncertainty, but opportunism did not directly influence. Third, degree of relationship satisfaction were connected with transaction cost factors direct variables on degree of relationship satisfaction are asset specificity and opportunism, but uncertainty had not affected degree of relationship satisfaction. Fourth, cooperative relationship lasting factors and degree of relation satisfaction had affected financial performance and non financial performance. In summary, this study find that transaction cost factors had indirectly influenced organizational performance through mediated variables such as cooperative relationship lasting factors and degree of relationship satisfaction.
BibTeX
@article{lee2014effects,
  author = {Sang Wan Lee and Jae Yeol Kim},
  title = {{The Effects of Transaction Cost Factors on Cooperative Relationship Lasting Factors, Degree of Relationship Satisfaction, and Performance}},
  journal = {Journal of Digital Convergence},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.14400/jdc.2014.12.4.133},
}
Figure