The Effects of the NBA COVID Bubble on the NBA Playoffs: A Case Study for Home-Court Advantage

Michael Price, Jun YanarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The 2020 NBA playoffs were played inside of a bubble in Disney World because of the COVID-19 pandemic. This meant that there were no fans in attendance, games played on neutral courts and no traveling for teams, which in theory removes home-court advantage from the games. This setting has attracted much discussion as analysts and fans debated the possible effects it may have on the outcome of games. Home-court advantage has historically played an influential role in NBA playoff series outcomes. The 2020 playoff provided a unique opportunity to study the effects of the bubble and home-court advantage by comparing the 2020 season with the seasons in the past. While many factors contribute to the outcome of games, points scored is the deciding factor of who wins games, so scoring is the primary focus of this study. The specific measures of interest are team scoring totals and team shooting percentage on two-pointers, three-pointers, and free throws. Comparing these measures for home teams and away teams in 2020 vs. 2017-2019 shows that the 2020 playoffs favored away teams more than usual, particularly with two point shooting and total scoring.

Introduction

In sports analytics, "home-court advantage" (HCA) is a well-documented phenomenon, but its underlying mechanisms—crowd influence, venue familiarity, or travel fatigue—are difficult to isolate. The 2020 NBA COVID Bubble in Disney World provided a unique "control" environment where every game was played on a neutral court with no fans and no travel. This allowed researchers to compare performance across different environments (Bubble vs. Traditional) to identify which metrics shift when the traditional pillars of HCA are removed.

Methods

The study employed a comparative statistical approach, testing nine hypotheses regarding win percentages, scoring totals, and shooting accuracy (2-pointers, 3-pointers, and free throws).

  • Datasets: The researchers analyzed 83 games from the 2020 NBA Playoffs (the "Bubble" group) and 243 games from the 2017–2019 NBA Playoffs (the "Control" group). This resulted in 166 observations for 2020 and 486 for the control period.
  • Statistical Analysis: Two-sample z-tests were used for point estimates and proportions. To ensure robustness, non-parametric tests—Fisher’s exact test for win/loss contingency and the Wilcoxon rank-sum test for distributions—were also conducted.
  • Controls: To account for the risk of false positives across multiple tests, the authors applied the Bonferroni correction. Additionally, the control group was limited to recent seasons to ensure the data wasn't skewed by the NBA's general trend toward faster play and increased three-point volume.

Key Insights and Results

The "Inhibition" Effect

The most striking takeaway is that home teams in the Bubble did not actually perform worse than they did in previous years. Instead, away teams played significantly better. This suggests that HCA is primarily a "debuff" applied to visitors (via crowd pressure and travel fatigue) rather than a "buff" granted to the home team.

Scoring and Efficiency

Visiting teams saw a statistically significant increase in mean points per game, jumping by approximately 5 points (95% CI: 2.083, 7.988) compared to previous years. The most significant efficiency gain occurred in two-point shooting percentage, which improved by roughly 3% for away teams (p-value of 0.0003). This result remained significant even after the strict Bonferroni correction, suggesting that the absence of a hostile crowd allows visiting players to finish better at the rim or hit mid-range jumpers more consistently.

Win Rate Inversion

Historically, home teams win about 60% of playoff games. As shown in the historical data, the 2020 Bubble represented a massive departure from this trend.

Figure 1: Historical NBA playoff home win percentages (2010–2020). The 2020 Bubble season (red) marks the only year in the decade where the designated home team won less than 50% of games.

In the Bubble, the designated "home" team (the higher seed) won only 48.2% of the time. While the statistical correction makes this result only "cautiously" significant, the raw shift is a stark outlier compared to the previous decade of NBA playoff data.

Limitations and Future Work

The study is limited to a single, non-replicable "Bubble" event. Future research could expand on these findings by examining "hustle" statistics—such as turnovers, steals, and rebounds—to see if the lack of travel fatigue impacts defensive intensity. Additionally, analyzing foul calls in the Bubble could help determine if referees are subconsciously influenced by crowd reactions, further clarifying the role of officiating in home-court advantage.

Summary updated

Abstract

The 2020 NBA playoffs were played inside of a bubble in Disney World because of the COVID-19 pandemic. This meant that there were no fans in attendance, games played on neutral courts and no traveling for teams, which in theory removes home-court advantage from the games. This setting has attracted much discussion as analysts and fans debated the possible effects it may have on the outcome of games. Home-court advantage has historically played an influential role in NBA playoff series outcomes. The 2020 playoff provided a unique opportunity to study the effects of the bubble and home-court advantage by comparing the 2020 season with the seasons in the past. While many factors contribute to the outcome of games, points scored is the deciding factor of who wins games, so scoring is the primary focus of this study. The specific measures of interest are team scoring totals and team shooting percentage on two-pointers, three-pointers, and free throws. Comparing these measures for home teams and away teams in 2020 vs. 2017-2019 shows that the 2020 playoffs favored away teams more than usual, particularly with two point shooting and total scoring.
BibTeX
@misc{price2021effects,
  author = {Michael Price and Jun Yan},
  title = {{The Effects of the NBA COVID Bubble on the NBA Playoffs: A Case Study for Home-Court Advantage}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2103.02832},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.02832},
}
Figure