The Effects of Sound Speed Profile to the Convergence Zone in Deep Water

Shuanglin Wu, Zhenglin Li, Jixing Qin, Mengyuan Wang, Wen J. LiJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the sound speed profile (SSP) in deep ocean waters influences the formation and characteristics of convergence zones (CZs), areas of focused sound intensity crucial for underwater acoustics. By comparing experimental data from the East Indian Ocean (EIO) and South China Sea (SCS), the study reveals that SSP structure significantly impacts CZ range and width, with implications for sonar detection and long-range communication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep-water sound propagation is a complex phenomenon, and the formation of convergence zones (CZs) is a key aspect. CZs are regions where sound rays, refracted by variations in sound speed, focus at shallow depths, creating areas of high sound intensity. Understanding and predicting CZs is vital for applications like underwater acoustic detection and long-range communication. While much research has focused on CZs, there's a need to systematically analyze how different oceanographic environments, specifically the sound speed profile (SSP), and seasonal variations affect CZ characteristics like range and width. This paper aims to fill this gap by comparing CZs in two distinct ocean regions (EIO and SCS) and examining seasonal effects within one region.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach combining experimental data collection, theoretical analysis, and numerical simulations.

  • Experimental Data Collection: Acoustic propagation experiments were conducted in the East Indian Ocean (EIO) in August 2019 and March 2021, and in the South China Sea (SCS) in April 2018. These experiments involved deploying a vertical line array (VLA) of hydrophones and using explosive charges (TNT) as sound sources. Sound speed profiles (SSPs) were measured using Expendable Bathythermographs (XBTs) and Conductivity-Temperature-Depth (CTD) sensors.
  • Data Analysis: Received acoustic signals were processed to calculate transmission loss (TL) as a function of range and frequency. The energy of the direct sound wave was isolated for analysis.
  • Theoretical Analysis: The study utilized a linearized sound speed profile and ray tracing principles to derive an analytical solution for the horizontal range of sound rays. This theoretical framework, based on Snell's Law and the parabolic equation theory, was used to estimate CZ ranges.
  • Numerical Simulation: The RAM-PE (Parabolic Equation) model was employed to simulate sound propagation and generate two-dimensional transmission loss maps. This allowed for comparison with experimental data and exploration of scenarios with altered parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected during three distinct acoustic propagation experiments:

  • EIO 2019: Conducted in August in the East Indian Ocean (Area I).
  • EIO 2021: Conducted in March in the East Indian Ocean (Area I).
  • SCS 2018: Conducted in April in the South China Sea (Area II).

These datasets included measured sound speed profiles (SSPs), bathymetry, and recorded acoustic transmission loss data. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather uses these collected experimental datasets for analysis and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SSP is King for CZ Range: The sound speed profile (SSP) is the primary driver of convergence zone (CZ) range. Differences in SSP structure between the EIO and SCS led to a significant difference in CZ range, with the EIO exhibiting a farther CZ.
  • Seasonal Shifts Affect Width, Not Range: While seasonal changes in the EIO didn't drastically alter the CZ range, they did influence its width. This suggests that while the overall focusing mechanism is stable, the precise spread of the focused energy can be modulated by seasonal variations.
  • Water Depth's Role: Water depth plays a crucial role in enabling CZ formation by providing sufficient "depth excess" for sound rays to refract. However, once CZ formation is possible, water depth has a less significant impact on the CZ range compared to the SSP. It does, however, influence CZ width.
  • Layered Influence: The study highlights that the sound channel mixing layer and the isothermal layer of the SSP have a greater impact on CZ range than the thermocline, especially when the conjugate depth is below the surface mixed layer.

Key Results

  • EIO vs. SCS CZs: The first CZ in the East Indian Ocean (EIO) was found to be 7–8 km farther than in the South China Sea (SCS) at similar receiving depths. Conversely, the CZ width in the EIO was approximately 2–3 km narrower than in the SCS.
  • Seasonal CZ Width Variation: In the EIO, the width of the CZ in summer was about 2 km narrower than in spring, while the range remained largely consistent.
  • Model Validation: Numerical simulations using the RAM-PE model closely matched experimental data for transmission loss and CZ characteristics, validating the theoretical framework and simulation approach.
  • Theoretical CZ Range Estimates: Theoretical calculations using Equation (4) predicted first CZ ranges of 58.6 km for EIO 2019, 61.1 km for EIO 2021, and 49.3 km for SCS 2018, which were in good agreement with experimental and simulated results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Range Independence Assumption: For short-distance sound propagation, the study assumes range-independent SSPs. While stated to have little effect on the overall analysis, this simplification might overlook finer details in complex environments.
  • EIO 2021 Data Gap: The EIO 2021 experiment did not collect data at the specific receiving depth of 255 m, preventing a direct comparison of CZ range error for that experiment.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research could explore the influence of more complex environmental factors, such as varying bottom topography and more dynamic oceanographic conditions, on CZ formation and propagation. Investigating the impact of CZ characteristics on specific underwater acoustic detection systems would also be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

The structure of a sound speed profile (SSP) in deep water causes refraction of sound rays and Convergence Zones (CZs) of high intensity where the rays focus at shallow depth. Study of sound field characteristics in the CZs has always been the focus of deep-water acoustics research. Many studies have been conducted on sound propagation in different parts of the oceans with different environments and, in this paper, the range and width of CZ is analyzed in the East Indian Ocean (EIO) and the South China Sea (SCS). Through the experimental data collected in different seasons with the propagation conditions change in the EIO and the SCS, we observe that the SSPs in different marine environments have a significant impact on the CZs of deep water. The sound channel mixing layer and isothermal layer have great effect on the CZ ranges. The water depths in the two experimental areas are similar, the range of the first CZ in the EIO is 7–8 km farther than that in the SCS, and the width of the CZs in the EIO is about 2–3 km narrower than that in the SCS. The surface mixed layer and the thermocline affect the CZ width but has little effect on the CZ range when the sound speed at the source and the bottom are practically the same. As the propagation conditions change along the seasons in the EIO, the range of the first CZ is almost the same, but the width of the CZs in the summer is about 2 km narrower than that in the spring. The water depth affects the CZ width but has little effect on the CZ range if the CZs can be formed. The different CZ characteristics between EIO and SCS are explained by both theoretical calculation and numerical simulation. The influence of the SSP structure and water depth on the CZ range are analyzed and the corresponding mechanism is explained. The research results are of great significance for underwater acoustic detection in deep sea.
BibTeX
@article{wu2022effects,
  author = {Shuanglin Wu and Zhenglin Li and Jixing Qin and Mengyuan Wang and Wen J. Li},
  title = {{The Effects of Sound Speed Profile to the Convergence Zone in Deep Water}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10030424},
}
Figure