The effects of site asymmetry on near-degenerate state-to-state vibronic mixing in flexible bichromophores

Nathanael M. Kidwell, Benjamin Nebgen, Lyudmila V. Slipchenko, Timothy S. ZwierThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Laser-induced fluorescence excitation and dispersed fluorescence spectra of a model flexible bichromophore, 1,1-diphenylethane (DPE), have been recorded under jet-cooled conditions in the gas phase in the region near the first pair of near-degenerate excited states (S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub>). The S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> origin transitions have been identified at 37 397 and 37 510 cm<sup>-1</sup>, a splitting of 113 cm<sup>-1</sup>. This splitting is four times smaller than the excitonic splitting calculated by ab initio methods at the EOM-CCSD/cc-pVDZ level of theory (410 cm<sup>-1</sup>), which necessarily relies on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. Dispersed fluorescence spectra provide a state-to-state picture of the vibronic coupling. These results are compared with the results of a multimode vibronic coupling model capable of treating chromophores in asymmetric environments. This model was used to predict the splitting between S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> origins close to the experiment, reduced from its pure excitonic value by Franck-Condon quenching. Quantitative accuracy is achieved by the model, lending insight into the state-to-state mixing that occurs between individual S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> vibronic levels. The S<sub>2</sub> origin is determined to be mixed with S<sub>1</sub>(v) levels by two mechanisms common to internal conversion in almost any setting; namely, (i) mixing involving near-degenerate levels with large vibrational quantum number changes that are not governed by Δv = 1 Herzberg-Teller (HT) selection rules, and (ii) mixing with levels with larger energy gaps that do follow these selection rules. In DPE, the asymmetric ring flapping vibrational mode R̄ dominates the HT coupling.

Introduction

In molecular systems containing two identical or nearly identical light-absorbing units, known as bichromophores, the electronic excited states often exist in close proximity. These "near-degenerate" states present a significant challenge to standard computational chemistry, which frequently relies on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. This approximation assumes that electronic and nuclear motions are decoupled; however, in flexible bichromophores, the coupling between electronic states and vibrational modes—vibronic coupling—is often strong enough to invalidate this assumption.

A common observation in such systems is that the "excitonic splitting"—the energy gap between the first two excited states, S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub>—predicted by high-level ab initio theory is significantly larger than the splitting observed experimentally. Furthermore, while many models address perfectly symmetric molecules, real-world systems often exhibit subtle structural asymmetries. This study investigates 1,1-diphenylethane (DPE) as a model flexible bichromophore to understand how site asymmetry influences state-to-state vibronic mixing and energy redistribution.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual approach combining high-resolution gas-phase spectroscopy with advanced theoretical modeling.

Experimental Techniques

To observe individual quantum states without the interference of thermal broadening, the team utilized jet-cooled laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) and dispersed fluorescence (DFL) spectroscopy. Molecules were cooled to near absolute zero in a supersonic expansion. UV-UV holeburning was implemented to isolate the spectra of a single molecular conformer, ensuring that the observed transitions originated from a well-defined geometry.

Theoretical Framework

Baseline electronic energies were calculated using Equation-of-Motion Coupled-Cluster (EOM-CCSD/cc-pVDZ) methods. To bridge the gap between theory and experiment, the researchers applied an asymmetric version of the Fulton-Gouterman model. This model explicitly incorporates vibrational modes into the Hamiltonian, allowing for the simulation of how nuclear motion "quenches" electronic coupling. Crucially, the model accounts for site asymmetry—the difference in local environments of the two phenyl rings caused by the ethyl bridge.

Results and Discussion

The experimental S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> origin transitions for DPE were identified at 37,397 and 37,510 cm⁻¹, respectively, yielding an observed splitting of 113 cm⁻¹. This value is nearly four times smaller than the 410 cm⁻¹ predicted by Born-Oppenheimer-based ab initio calculations.

Franck-Condon Quenching

The discrepancy between theory and experiment is primarily attributed to Franck-Condon quenching. When the molecule transitions to an excited state, its equilibrium geometry shifts. The resulting reduction in the overlap of vibrational wavefunctions (Franck-Condon factors) acts to suppress the electronic coupling. The researchers calculated a total vibrational quenching factor (Γ) of 0.118, indicating that vibrational interactions reduce the pure electronic coupling by approximately 88%.

The Role of Site Asymmetry

In symmetric molecules like diphenylmethane (DPM), excitation is delocalized equally across both rings. In DPE, the ethyl bridge introduces a "site energy" difference of approximately 30 cm⁻¹ because the group is oriented differently relative to each ring (one "in-plane" and one "out-of-plane"). This asymmetry leads to partial localization of the excitation on a single ring, altering the vibronic landscape.

Mechanisms of Vibronic Mixing

The study identified two primary pathways through which the S<sub>2</sub> state mixes with S<sub>1</sub> vibrational levels:

  1. Near-degenerate mixing: Coupling occurs between S<sub>2</sub> and S<sub>1</sub> vibrational levels that are nearly equal in energy. This mechanism allows for mixing even when large changes in vibrational quantum numbers are involved, bypassing standard selection rules.
  2. Herzberg-Teller (HT) coupling: This involves mixing with levels separated by larger energy gaps, mediated by specific "symmetry-breaking" vibrations. In DPE, the asymmetric ring flapping mode ($̄{R}$), with a frequency of 126 cm⁻¹, was found to be the dominant driver of HT coupling.

Conclusion

By integrating jet-cooled spectroscopy with an asymmetric vibronic coupling model, this work provides a definitive state-to-state map of energy redistribution in flexible bichromophores. The successful prediction of the 113 cm⁻¹ splitting demonstrates that accounting for both vibrational quenching and site asymmetry is essential for accurate modeling of near-degenerate systems.

Future research will focus on scaling these models to larger chromophore arrays, such as those found in biological light-harvesting complexes. Additionally, time-resolved studies are needed to observe the real-time dynamics of energy oscillation between rings, and further work is required to understand how these interactions are modified by the presence of a solvent or protein environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Laser-induced fluorescence excitation and dispersed fluorescence spectra of a model flexible bichromophore, 1,1-diphenylethane (DPE), have been recorded under jet-cooled conditions in the gas phase in the region near the first pair of near-degenerate excited states (S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub>). The S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> origin transitions have been identified at 37 397 and 37 510 cm<sup>-1</sup>, a splitting of 113 cm<sup>-1</sup>. This splitting is four times smaller than the excitonic splitting calculated by ab initio methods at the EOM-CCSD/cc-pVDZ level of theory (410 cm<sup>-1</sup>), which necessarily relies on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. Dispersed fluorescence spectra provide a state-to-state picture of the vibronic coupling. These results are compared with the results of a multimode vibronic coupling model capable of treating chromophores in asymmetric environments. This model was used to predict the splitting between S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> origins close to the experiment, reduced from its pure excitonic value by Franck-Condon quenching. Quantitative accuracy is achieved by the model, lending insight into the state-to-state mixing that occurs between individual S<sub>1</sub> and S<sub>2</sub> vibronic levels. The S<sub>2</sub> origin is determined to be mixed with S<sub>1</sub>(v) levels by two mechanisms common to internal conversion in almost any setting; namely, (i) mixing involving near-degenerate levels with large vibrational quantum number changes that are not governed by Δv = 1 Herzberg-Teller (HT) selection rules, and (ii) mixing with levels with larger energy gaps that do follow these selection rules. In DPE, the asymmetric ring flapping vibrational mode R¯ dominates the HT coupling.
BibTeX
@article{kidwell2019effects,
  author = {Nathanael M. Kidwell and Benjamin Nebgen and Lyudmila V. Slipchenko and Timothy S. Zwier},
  title = {{The effects of site asymmetry on near-degenerate state-to-state vibronic mixing in flexible bichromophores}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1063/1.5107423},
}
Figure