The Effects of Sex and Diet on Physiology and Liver Gene Expression in Diversity Outbred Mice

Daniel M. Gatti, Petr Šimeček, Lisa Somes, Clifton T. Jeffrey, Matthew Vincent, Kwangbom Choi, Xingyao Chen, Gary A. Churchill, Karen L. SvensonBiorxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how sex and diet interact to influence metabolic health and gene expression in mice, revealing complex genetic architectures for physiological traits and identifying specific genes involved in cholesterol metabolism. The findings highlight the importance of considering sex and diet in understanding metabolic variation and provide a valuable resource for future research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding individual differences in metabolic health and how they respond to diet is a major challenge for developing effective prevention and treatment strategies for obesity and metabolic disorders. While sex and genetic background are known to play significant roles, disentangling their specific contributions, especially in response to diet, is complex. Human studies are often limited by lifestyle variations and uncontrolled factors. This paper addresses this by using a controlled mouse model (Diversity Outbred mice) to systematically investigate the interplay of sex, diet (high-fat/high-sucrose vs. chow), and genetic background on a wide range of physiological traits and liver gene expression.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Phenotyping: A comprehensive suite of non-invasive phenotyping assays was used to measure clinical chemistry, body composition, and metabolic health over 26 weeks. This included dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA), quantitative NMR (EchoMRI), electrocardiography, and glucose tolerance tests.
  • Genotyping and Diplotype Reconstruction: DNA from tail biopsies was genotyped using Mouse Universal Genotyping Arrays (MUGA and Megamuga). Haplotype blocks were inferred using a hidden Markov model (HMM).
  • Genotyping by RNA-sequence (GBRS): This method was used to reconstruct individual genomes by analyzing RNA-Seq data, offering an efficient way to capture genetic variation.
  • Merging Haplotype Reconstructions: Data from different genotyping methods were merged and interpolated to create a unified dataset.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA was used to reduce the dimensionality of physiological and liver transcription data, revealing patterns of variation related to sex and diet.
  • Correlation Analysis: Pairwise Pearson correlations were calculated for physiological traits after accounting for sex and diet effects.
  • Linkage and Association Mapping: Quantitative Trait Loci (QTL) were identified for physiological traits and liver gene expression using various models that incorporated sex, diet, and genotype interactions.
  • Mediation Analysis: This technique was used to identify candidate genes that might mediate the effects of physiological QTLs by examining their expression levels in the liver.
  • Differential Expression Analysis: Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed on liver transcription data to identify genes differentially expressed between sexes, diets, or their interactions. Gene Ontology (GO) categories were analyzed for enrichment.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 850 Diversity Outbred (DO) mice. The datasets generated and used include:

  • Physiological Phenotypes: Raw and normalized data for 154 traits measured across multiple time points.
  • Liver Gene Expression Data: Transcriptional profiling data from the livers of a subset of mice.
  • Genotype Data: Genotype information for all mice.
  • R Data Objects: Used in all analyses.

This data is made publicly available through supplemental files and the http://do.jax.org website.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complex Genetic Architecture: The study found that the genetic architecture of physiological traits is complex, often involving multiple loci and potentially multiple polymorphisms within a single locus. This challenges simpler models of inheritance.
  • Sex and Diet Interactions are Crucial: Many traits exhibited sex-specific or diet-specific changes, and importantly, complex interactions between sex and diet were observed. This underscores the need to consider these factors simultaneously when studying metabolic health.
  • Liver Gene Expression Response to Diet: While local genetic variations influence constitutive and sex-specific liver gene expression, the response of liver gene expression to diet appears to be less influenced by these local polymorphisms. This suggests that other mechanisms, possibly distant genetic effects or non-transcriptional interactions, play a larger role in diet-induced transcriptional changes.
  • Candidate Genes for Cholesterol Metabolism: The study successfully identified two loci for circulating cholesterol levels and, through mediation analysis, proposed several candidate genes (e.g., Cfhr1, Ctse, F13b, Trafd1, Scarb1) that may modify these physiological traits.
  • DO Mice as a Powerful Model: The use of Diversity Outbred mice, with their inherent genetic diversity, proved effective in dissecting complex genetic influences on metabolic traits and their responses to environmental factors like diet.

Key Results

  • Body Weight Differences: Males generally weighed more than females, and mice on the high-fat diet weighed more than those on the chow diet.
  • Sex Effects on Traits: Sex had a significant effect on 130 traits (FDR ≤ 0.05), with males showing higher mean values for 101 traits (e.g., body weight, glucose tolerance) and females for 29 traits (e.g., hemoglobin, %Fat).
  • Diet Effects on Traits: Diet affected 116 traits (FDR ≤ 0.05). The high-fat diet (HFD) led to higher levels of adiponectin, weight, fat traits, insulin, leptin, and cholesterol, while the chow diet was associated with higher BUN, kidney weight, and triglycerides.
  • Sex by Diet Interactions: 14 traits showed significant sex by diet interactions (FDR ≤ 0.05), with bone mineral density (BMD2) being a notable example where males on the HFD had higher BMD than females.
  • Liver Transcription Effects: 7,723 genes showed sex effects (FDR ≤ 0.01), 5,299 showed diet effects (FDR ≤ 0.01), and 757 genes had significant sex by diet interactions.
  • Cholesterol QTLs: Two loci for circulating cholesterol levels were identified on chromosomes 1 and 5.
  • Candidate Genes for Cholesterol: Six genes were identified that reduced the LOD score by more than six standard deviations in mediation analysis for cholesterol on chromosome 1, including Cfhr1, Ctse, and F13b. Scarb1 and Trafd1 were identified for cholesterol on chromosome 5.
  • eQTLs: The study found local eQTLs for additive and sex-interactive models, suggesting constitutive and sex-differential regulation by local polymorphisms. However, diet-interactive models yielded few local eQTLs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Disentangling Complex Loci: The authors acknowledge that many loci in multi-parent crosses may be caused by more than one genetic variant, making it complex to disentangle the signal from different alleles. More sophisticated, multi-locus approaches may be needed for candidate gene selection.
  • Non-Transcriptional Mechanisms: The finding that diet response in liver transcription is not primarily altered by local genetic variants suggests that other molecular measurements (protein, metabolite levels) might be more useful for understanding diet effects. Future work could explore these.
  • Candidate Gene Validation: While candidate genes were identified through mediation analysis, further experimental validation is needed to confirm their causal roles in the observed phenotypes.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in mice. While DO mice offer genetic diversity, translating findings to human populations requires careful consideration.
  • XO Females: The study identified two XO females with distinct phenotypes, suggesting that sex chromosome aneuploidy can lead to varied metabolic outcomes. Further investigation into these cases could be valuable.

The authors have made their data publicly available, which will facilitate future research and the exploration of these findings by the broader scientific community.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Inter-individual variation in metabolic health and adiposity is driven by many factors. Diet composition and genetic background and the interactions between these two factors affect adiposity and related traits such as circulating cholesterol levels. In this study, we fed 850 Diversity Outbred mice, half females and half males, with either a standard chow diet or a high fat, high sucrose diet beginning at weaning and aged them to 26 weeks. We measured clinical chemistry and body composition at early and late time points during the study, and liver transcription at euthanasia. Males weighed more than females and mice on a high fat diet generally weighed more than those on chow. Many traits showed sex- or diet-specific changes as well as more complex sex by diet interactions. We mapped both the physiological and molecular traits and found that the genetic architecture of the physiological traits is complex, with many single locus associations potentially being driven by more than one polymorphism. For liver transcription, we find that local polymorphisms affect constitutive and sex-specific transcription, but that the response to diet is not affected by local polymorphisms. We identified two loci for circulating cholesterol levels. We performed mediation analysis by mapping the physiological traits, given liver transcript abundance and propose several genes that may be modifiers of the physiological traits. By including both physiological and molecular traits in our analyses, we have created deeper phenotypic profiles to identify additional significant contributors to complex metabolic outcomes such as polygenic obesity. We make the phenotype, liver transcript and genotype data publicly available as a resource for the research community.
BibTeX
@misc{gatti2017effects,
  author = {Daniel M. Gatti and Petr Šimeček and Lisa Somes and Clifton T. Jeffrey and Matthew Vincent and Kwangbom Choi and Xingyao Chen and Gary A. Churchill and Karen L. Svenson},
  title = {{The Effects of Sex and Diet on Physiology and Liver Gene Expression in Diversity Outbred Mice}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/098657},
  howpublished = {Biorxiv},
}
Figure