Abstract: The objects that emit extragalactic fast radio bursts (FRBs) remain unidentified. Studies of the host galaxies and environments of accurately localised ($\lesssim1$ arcsec) FRBs promise to deliver critical insights into the nature of their progenitors. Here we demonstrate the effects of observational selection biases on analyses of the distributions of FRB host-galaxy properties (including star-formation rate, SFR, and stellar mass, $M_{*}$), and on the distributions of FRB offsets from the centres of their hosts. We consider the effects of "radio selection", wherein FRBs with larger dispersion measures and scattering timescales are less likely to be detected, and the effects of "optical selection", wherein FRBs with fainter host galaxies are more likely to have unidentified or mis-identified hosts. We develop a plausible, illustrative model for these effects in observations of FRBs and their host galaxies by combining the output catalogues of a semi-analytic galaxy formation model with a recently developed algorithm to associate FRBs with host galaxies (PATH). We find that optical selection biases are most important for the host-galaxy $M_{*}$ and SFR distributions, and that radio selection biases are most important for the distribution of FRB projected physical offsets. For our fiducial simulation of FRBs at $z<0.5$, the selection biases cause the median host-galaxy SFR to be increased by $\sim0.3$ dex, and the median $M_{*}$ by $\sim0.5$ dex. The median projected physical offset is increased by $\sim2$ kpc ($\sim0.25$ dex). These effects are sufficiently large so as to merit careful consideration in studies of localised FRBs, and our simulations provide a guide towards their mitigation.
Introduction
Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are millisecond-duration radio transients originating from cosmological distances. Despite their discovery over a decade ago, the physical nature of their progenitors remains one of the most compelling mysteries in modern astrophysics. To solve this, researchers look to the "neighborhoods" of these bursts—the host galaxies. By comparing the properties of FRB hosts to those of known transients like Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) or Supernovae, we can infer the types of stellar populations that produce them.
However, this analysis is complicated by significant observational selection effects. This study investigates how "radio selection" and "optical selection" biases can distort our understanding of FRB environments, potentially leading to flawed conclusions about their origins.
Methodology
The researchers developed a comprehensive simulation pipeline to quantify these biases:
- Galaxy Modeling: Using the L-galaxies semi-analytic model (based on the Millennium simulation), they generated a realistic population of galaxies.
- FRB Seeding: FRBs were placed within these galaxies according to two hypotheses: one where FRB rates follow the star-formation rate (SFR) and another where they follow stellar mass ($M_*$).
- Radio Filtering: The team applied completeness functions derived from real-world CHIME/FRB survey data. This simulated the difficulty of detecting bursts with high dispersion measures (DM) or significant scattering timescales ($\tau$), which often occur in dense galactic environments.
- Host Association: They employed the PATH (Probabilistic Association of Transients to their Hosts) algorithm to match simulated FRBs to galaxies within a magnitude-limited catalog (mimicking surveys like PanSTARRS). This allowed them to identify "False Positives" where a faint true host is missed in favor of a brighter, nearby neighbor.
Radio Selection: The "Outskirts" Bias
Radio selection is primarily driven by the interstellar medium (ISM). Signals originating from the dense, turbulent centers of galaxies are more likely to be "smeared" by scattering or exhibit high DMs, making them harder for telescopes to detect.
As shown in the figure above, the observed population (blue) is significantly shifted away from the true distribution (black line) at higher values of $\tau$ and DM. This creates an "outskirts bias," where we disproportionately detect FRBs on the fringes of galaxies, artificially increasing the perceived physical offset from the galactic center by approximately 2 kpc ($\sim0.25$ dex).
Optical Selection: The "Big Galaxy" Bias
Optical selection bias occurs when the true host galaxy of an FRB is too faint to be detected by follow-up imaging. In these cases, automated association algorithms like PATH may mistakenly assign the FRB to a more massive, luminous galaxy nearby.
This misidentification leads to a "Big Galaxy" bias. For a sample at $z < 0.5$, the researchers found that these biases caused the median host galaxy stellar mass ($M_*$) to be overestimated by ~0.5 dex (a factor of 3) and the median SFR to be inflated by ~0.3 dex (roughly double the true activity).
Key Results and Discussion
The study demonstrates that selection effects are not negligible; they are large enough to fundamentally change the interpretation of FRB progenitor models. The biases become increasingly severe at higher redshifts ($z > 0.5$), where galaxies are harder to resolve and detect.
One critical insight involves the PATH algorithm's $P(U)$ parameter—the prior probability that a host is "unseen." If researchers do not set this parameter high enough, the algorithm will almost always find a "host," but it will frequently be the wrong one.
Conclusion and Future Work
To mitigate these biases, the authors emphasize the necessity of sub-arcsecond localization and extremely deep optical imaging of FRB fields. Future studies could be refined by using high-resolution cosmological hydrodynamical simulations to better model the diverse gas and star distributions within galaxies. Accounting for these selection effects is essential for moving from mere detection to a true physical understanding of Fast Radio Bursts.
Summary updated