The effects of repeated brain MRI on chromosomal damage

Cécile Hérate, Patricia Brochard, Florent de Vathaire, Michelle Ricoul, Bernadette Martins, Laurence Laurier, Jean-Robert Deverre, Bertrand Thirion, Lucie Hertz‐Pannier, Laure SabatierEuropean 2022 · DOI

Abstract: Our study showed that MRI can affect chromosomal integrity. However, the amount of damage per cell might be so low that no chromosomal rearrangement by fusion of two deoxyribonucleic breaks is induced, unlike that seen after exposure to computed tomography. This study confirms that MRI is a safe imaging technique.

Introduction

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is a cornerstone of modern diagnostic imaging, favored over Computed Tomography (CT) because it does not use ionizing radiation. However, as 3-Tesla (3-T) and higher-strength scanners become standard, concerns regarding the genotoxic potential of intense static magnetic fields, gradient fields, and radiofrequency (RF) pulses have emerged. Previous literature on MRI-induced DNA damage has been inconsistent, often focusing on single exposures or in vitro models. This study addresses this gap by providing a rigorous, longitudinal in vivo follow-up of healthy human volunteers receiving dozens of scans over several years.

Methods

The researchers conducted an ancillary study to the "Individual Brain Charting" (IBC) project, following 13 healthy volunteers (mean age 33) exposed to up to 26 3-T MRI sessions, each lasting 90 minutes. The team utilized the "gold standard" biodosimetry technique augmented with PNA (Peptide Nucleic Acid) FISH staining for telomeres and centromeres. This innovation allowed for the precise identification of "unstable" aberrations, specifically distinguishing between terminal deletions (single breaks) and dicentric chromosomes (two breaks fused together), which are characteristic of ionizing radiation damage.

Results

Single-Scan Safety

The study confirmed that a single 90-minute 3-T session has no detectable impact on chromosomal integrity. As illustrated in Figure 4, there were no statistically significant differences in the frequency of dicentric chromosomes, rings, or total breaks when comparing baseline measurements to those taken after one MRI session.

Figure 4: Comparison of chromosomal abnormalities before and after a single 3-T MRI session, showing no significant (n.s.) increase across all categories.

Cumulative Effects and the "Plateau" Phenomenon

While a single scan is safe, longitudinal tracking revealed that repeated MRI sessions (between 10 and 20 scans) were associated with a small but significant increase in chromosomal terminal deletions. The total frequency of damaged cells increased by approximately 3.2% per MRI session during this phase.

Figure 5: Frequency of damaged cells per 1000 metaphases plotted against the number of MRI sessions, demonstrating a low-level increase that eventually plateaus.

Crucially, this damage did not increase linearly forever. After approximately 20 scans, the damage reached a plateau. The authors suggest this is due to lymphocyte turnover, where the body naturally replaces older, damaged white blood cells with new ones, preventing indefinite accumulation. Furthermore, MRI did not induce "dicentric" chromosomes, which are typical of ionizing radiation (like CT). This suggests that the "damage density" per cell from MRI is too low to facilitate the fusion of multiple breaks into severe structural rearrangements.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study reinforces the safety profile of MRI. While repeated 3-T scans can cause a measurable, low-level increase in chromosomal terminal deletions, the lack of complex rearrangements and the observed plateau effect suggest that the clinical risk is negligible. The qualitative difference between MRI-induced damage and the severe damage caused by ionizing radiation (as seen in a control subject who underwent CT scans) confirms MRI's status as a high-safety imaging modality. Future research aims to follow the cohort up to 50 MRI sessions to confirm the long-term stability of the observed plateau.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study showed that MRI can affect chromosomal integrity. However, the amount of damage per cell might be so low that no chromosomal rearrangement by fusion of two deoxyribonucleic breaks is induced, unlike that seen after exposure to computed tomography. This study confirms that MRI is a safe imaging technique.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{herate2022effects,
  author = {Cécile Hérate and Patricia Brochard and Florent de Vathaire and Michelle Ricoul and Bernadette Martins and Laurence Laurier and Jean-Robert Deverre and Bertrand Thirion and Lucie Hertz‐Pannier and Laure Sabatier},
  title = {{The effects of repeated brain MRI on chromosomal damage}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s41747-022-00264-2},
}
Figure