The Effects of Instagram Users' Gratification on Psychological Response, and Continued Usage Intention from the Perspective of Uses and Gratification and Stimulus-Organism-Response Theory

Dian Jin, Wan Anita Wan Abas, Syafila KamarudinInternational Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences 2023 · DOI

This study, published in the International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, explores the psychological mechanics behind Instagram’s "stickiness." By combining two foundational theories—Uses and Gratification (U&G) and Stimulus-Organism-Response (S-O-R)—the researchers identify how specific app features (stimuli) trigger internal psychological states (organism) that ultimately lead to the intention to keep using the platform (response).

TL;DR

The paper reveals that while "useful" features make users satisfied, it is social participation and content consumption that forge the emotional bonds necessary for long-term retention. Crucially, it finds that satisfaction and emotional attachment are independent drivers of continued use, rather than one leading to the other.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the hyper-competitive landscape of social networking sites (SNS), user retention is the ultimate metric of success. While previous research has extensively mapped what gratifications users seek (like entertainment or information), there is a gap in understanding the "internal black box"—the psychological transition from using a feature to feeling a specific way about the app.

The authors tackle this by investigating the dual pathways of Satisfaction (a cognitive evaluation) and Emotional Attachment (an affective bond). They aim to determine which specific gratifications trigger which psychological response and how these responses dictate a user's decision to stay or migrate to a competitor.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative survey-based approach, collecting data from 209 university students. To analyze the complex relationships between these variables, they used Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM).

Unlike standard regression, PLS-SEM allows for the simultaneous analysis of multiple relationships and is particularly effective for "path modeling" where one variable (like satisfaction) might be both an outcome of one process and a driver of another. The study utilized a seven-point Likert scale to measure nine distinct dimensions, including:

  • Stimuli: Entertaining value, social value, social participation, utilitarian value, and information consumption.
  • Organism: User satisfaction and emotional attachment.
  • Response: Continued usage intention.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset collected via convenience sampling of students at Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) between January and February 2023.

  • Sample Size: N = 209.
  • Demographics: Roughly equal gender split (52.6% male, 47.4% female), with the majority of users (80%) having more than one year of Instagram experience.
  • Context: The sample represents "digital natives" who are heavy users of social media, making them an ideal proxy for the average active SNS user.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Utility-Satisfaction Link: Utilitarian value (the app's ability to help users achieve specific tasks) was the strongest predictor of user satisfaction. If the app works well and serves a purpose, users are satisfied, but not necessarily "attached."
  • The Social-Attachment Link: Emotional attachment is driven primarily by social participation and information consumption. Interacting with friends and reading others' posts creates a sense of intimacy and community that goes beyond mere functional satisfaction.
  • Parallel Paths to Retention: One of the most surprising findings was that Satisfaction does not significantly lead to Emotional Attachment (H4 was rejected). This suggests that a user can be perfectly satisfied with an app's performance without feeling an emotional bond to it, and vice versa. Both, however, are independent and powerful predictors of whether a user will continue using the app.
  • Information Consumption vs. Satisfaction: Interestingly, simply consuming information did not lead to satisfaction (H3b rejected), but it did lead to emotional attachment. This suggests that "doomscrolling" or passive consumption might fulfill an emotional need for connection even if it doesn't leave the user feeling "satisfied" in a traditional sense.

Key Results

The study validated seven of its ten hypotheses with significant statistical support:

  • Drivers of Satisfaction: Utilitarian value ($\beta=0.396$), Social value ($\beta=0.267$), and Entertaining value ($\beta=0.201$) all positively impacted satisfaction.
  • Drivers of Emotional Attachment: Information consumption ($\beta=0.575$) and Social participation ($\beta=0.301$) were the primary engines of emotional bonding.
  • Predictors of Continued Use: Both Satisfaction ($\beta=0.513$) and Emotional Attachment ($\beta=0.452$) showed strong, positive correlations with the intention to keep using Instagram.
  • Model Fit: The model explained a substantial portion of the variance, accounting for 82.2% of the variation in continued usage intention.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints that provide fertile ground for future research:

  • Demographic Bias: The study focused exclusively on Malaysian college students. Future work should investigate if these psychological pathways hold true across different age groups and cultures.
  • Platform Specificity: The results are specific to Instagram. Comparative studies involving TikTok, Pinterest, or Twitter could reveal if different platforms rely more heavily on "Utility" vs. "Emotion" for retention.
  • Limited Psychological Factors: The "Organism" section of the model could be expanded. The authors suggest that future models should include variables like "pleasure," "compatibility," and "social influence" to provide a more granular view of the user's internal state.

Summary updated

Abstract

Scholars have started to research the effect of satisfaction on users' willingness to continue using social media, such as Facebook, Instagram, Weibo. However, few studies have focused on the effects of these gratification on users’ psychological responses, such as satisfaction and emotional attachment. To bridge this knowledge gap, this study, based on uses and gratification and Stimulus-Organism-Response theory, integrated a new model to study the influence of gratification on psychological response, and the influence of psychological response on Instagram continuance use intention. A sample of students (N = 209) from Universiti Putra Malaysia was selected for this study. PLS-SEM was mainly used for hypothesis testing during data analysis. The results indicate that entertaining value, social value, social participation, and utilitarian value positively affect users' satisfaction. Emotional attachment is significantly influenced by social participation, information consumption. Moreover, psychological response positively affects continued usage intention. In addition, this study can help social media practitioners better understand users' intention to continue using from the perspective of their gratifications and psychological response.
BibTeX
@article{jin2023effects,
  author = {Dian Jin and Wan Anita Wan Abas and Syafila Kamarudin},
  title = {{The Effects of Instagram Users' Gratification on Psychological Response, and Continued Usage Intention from the Perspective of Uses and Gratification and Stimulus-Organism-Response Theory}},
  journal = {International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.6007/ijarbss/v13-i3/16477},
}
Figure