The effects of immunocontraception on harem fidelity in a feral horse (Equus caballus) population

Jessa Madosky, Daniel I. Rubenstein, Jerome J. Howard, Sue StuskaApplied Animal Behaviour Science 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how immunocontraception (using PZP) affects the social behavior of feral horses, specifically their harem fidelity. The research reveals that PZP treatment significantly increases harem changes in mares, suggesting that the behavioral effects of this contraceptive may persist long after its physiological effects have worn off, complicating population management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Feral horse populations, particularly on sensitive barrier islands like Shackleford Banks, can have significant negative impacts on native ecosystems through overgrazing and habitat degradation. Management strategies often involve reducing population size through removal or fertility control. Immunocontraception, specifically using Porcine Zona Pellucida (PZP), is a promising tool for fertility control as it can be administered remotely and is generally considered safe. However, there's a concern that PZP might influence the social behavior of the treated animals, potentially disrupting established social structures. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how PZP affects harem fidelity in feral horses, a crucial aspect of their social organization, and whether these behavioral effects are temporary or long-lasting.

Methods

The researchers conducted a two-year observational study on the Shackleford Banks feral horse population. They tracked individual mares and their harem associations during the breeding seasons of 2007 and 2008.

  • Harem Fidelity Measurement: Harem fidelity was quantified by counting the number of harem changes each mare made and the number of distinct harems each mare visited within a given breeding season.
  • Statistical Analysis: Mann-Whitney U tests were primarily used to compare harem changes between contracepted and control mares due to the non-normal distribution of the data and unequal sample sizes. Effect sizes were calculated to quantify the strength of the observed relationships.
  • Control Group: A small group of mares from distinct genetic lineages that had never been contracepted served as controls.
  • Contracepted Group: This group included any mare that had ever been treated with PZP, regardless of whether they were actively contracepted in the current year. This approach was taken because of evidence suggesting PZP's effects might last longer than one year.
  • Additional Factors: The study also analyzed the influence of mare age and foaling status on harem changes, as well as the impact of historical PZP treatment (number of years treated, consecutive years treated, years off contraception) on current behavior.

Datasets

The study utilized observational data collected over two breeding seasons (2007 and 2008) on the Shackleford Banks feral horse population. This dataset comprised:

  • Mare Harem Affiliations: Detailed records of which mare was associated with which harem at specific times.
  • Harem Composition: Information on the individuals within each harem.
  • GPS Locations: Location data for each observed harem.
  • Contraceptive Records: National Park Service records detailing which mares had received PZP treatment and when.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relied on existing observational data and historical records.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PZP Disrupts Social Stability: The most striking insight is that PZP immunocontraception significantly disrupts harem fidelity in feral horses, leading to more frequent harem changes. This suggests that fertility control can have unintended consequences on social behavior.
  • Behavioral Effects Persist: The study found that the behavioral effects of PZP treatment appear to be long-lasting. Mares that had been contracepted in the past, even if not currently treated, showed a similar increase in harem changes compared to actively contracepted mares. This challenges the assumption that PZP's effects are purely temporary and physiological.
  • Population-Wide Impact: The high percentage of harems affected by these changes indicates that the disruption isn't isolated to individual mares but influences the entire social structure of the population.
  • Foaling May Mitigate, But Not Eliminate, Effects: While mares with foals tended to change harems less frequently, suggesting foals might increase fidelity, this effect did not entirely negate the impact of prior contraception.

Key Results

  • Increased Harem Changes: Contracepted mares changed harems significantly more often than control mares in both 2007 (P=0.0415) and 2008 (P=0.0205).
  • More Harems Visited: Contracepted mares also visited significantly more harems than control mares in both years (2007: P=0.021; 2008: P=0.011).
  • Historical Treatment Matters: The number of years treated with PZP, or the time since discontinuation, did not significantly affect the number of harem changes. This implies that even a single exposure to PZP can have lasting behavioral consequences.
  • Active vs. Past Treatment: There was no significant difference in harem changes between mares actively contracepted and those previously treated but not currently contracepted, reinforcing the idea of persistent behavioral effects.
  • Foaling Effect: Mares with foals changed harems less than mares without foals in both years, though the difference was only statistically significant in 2008 (P=0.042).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Control Group Size: The authors acknowledge that the control group was necessarily small due to management concerns, which could limit the power of some comparisons. Further studies with larger control groups are recommended.
  • Persistent Behavioral Effects: A key limitation is the apparent long-lasting nature of the behavioral effects of PZP. The study suggests that reducing these effects may not be possible, even if physiological fertility is restored.
  • Distinguishing Male vs. Female Choice: The motivations behind increased harem infidelity (whether driven by male preference for fertile mares or female avoidance of harassment) remain unclear. Future work should aim to distinguish between male and female choice in these dynamics.
  • Fitness Impacts: The study highlights the potential fitness impacts of decreased harem stability on both males and females (e.g., reduced grazing time, increased guarding time). Future research should investigate whether body condition has decreased since the implementation of the PZP program.
  • Broader Applicability: Given that PZP is used in many species, the authors emphasize the need for further research into its behavioral effects on other animals, as social behavior can significantly impact reproductive success and complicate management.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{madosky2010effects,
  author = {Jessa Madosky and Daniel I. Rubenstein and Jerome J. Howard and Sue Stuska},
  title = {{The effects of immunocontraception on harem fidelity in a feral horse (Equus caballus) population}},
  booktitle = {Applied Animal Behaviour Science},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1016/j.applanim.2010.09.013},
}
Figure