The Effects of Graded Levels of Calorie Restriction: XIV. Global Metabolomics Screen Reveals Brown Adipose Tissue Changes in Amino Acids, Catecholamines, and Antioxidants After Short-Term Restriction in C57BL/6 Mice

Cara L. Green, Sharon E. Mitchell, Davina Derous, Yingchun Wang, Luonan Chen, Jing‐Dong J. Han, Daniel Promislow, David Lusseau, Alex Douglas, John R. SpeakmanThe Journals of Gerontology Series A 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals how calorie restriction (CR) alters the metabolic landscape of brown adipose tissue (BAT) in mice. By analyzing a wide range of metabolites, researchers found that CR impacts energy production pathways, boosts antioxidant levels, and shifts the balance of key neurotransmitters, suggesting a coordinated response to hunger and energy conservation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Calorie restriction (CR) is a well-established intervention for extending lifespan and improving healthspan across various organisms. While its benefits are widely recognized, the precise molecular mechanisms by which CR exerts these effects are still being unraveled. Brown adipose tissue (BAT) is a metabolically active tissue crucial for thermogenesis (heat production) and energy expenditure. It's known to be activated by norepinephrine, especially during periods requiring increased heat. However, how CR, a state of reduced energy intake, influences the complex metabolic machinery within BAT, particularly in response to hunger cues, remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by comprehensively analyzing the metabolomic changes in BAT under different levels of CR.

Methods

The researchers employed a global metabolomics screen using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) on brown adipose tissue samples from C57BL/6 mice subjected to varying degrees of calorie restriction (10%, 20%, 30%, and 40% CR) compared to an ad libitum (AL) fed control group.

Key methodological steps included:

  • BAT Metabolite Extraction: A standardized protocol was used to extract metabolites from frozen BAT samples.
  • LC-MS Analysis: This technique was used to separate and detect a wide array of metabolites based on their mass-to-charge ratio and retention time. Both positive and negative ionization modes were utilized to capture a comprehensive profile.
  • Data Processing and Identification: Specialized software packages (xcms, MSCombine, xMSannotator) were used to process raw data, extract metabolite features, and identify them by comparing against databases like HMDB, KEGG, and LipidMaps.
  • Metabolomic Preprocessing: A rigorous pipeline involving log transformation, signal-to-noise ratio filtering, and imputation of missing values (using a random forest approach) was applied to ensure data quality and robustness.
  • Statistical Modeling: An empirical Bayes moderated linear model was used to identify significantly differentially expressed metabolites between groups. Orthogonal Partial Least Square Discriminant Analysis (O-PLS-DA) was employed for multivariate analysis and to identify key metabolites driving group separation.
  • Biological Pathway Analysis: Two distinct approaches, mummichog and Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA), were used to identify enriched metabolic pathways affected by CR, leveraging both identified and unidentified metabolites.
  • Correlation Analysis: Metabolite levels were correlated with physiological parameters like body temperature, food anticipatory activity (FAA), and physical activity to understand the functional relevance of the observed metabolic changes.

Datasets

The study utilized metabolomic data generated from brown adipose tissue samples collected from C57BL/6 mice. The experimental design involved five different feeding groups:

  • 12-hour ad libitum (12AL) fed control group
  • 24-hour ad libitum (24AL) fed control group (used for comparison in some analyses)
  • 10% Calorie Restricted (10CR) group
  • 20% Calorie Restricted (20CR) group
  • 30% Calorie Restricted (30CR) group
  • 40% Calorie Restricted (40CR) group

The data is available through the Open Science Framework (DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/9YATH).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BAT as a CR Sensor: The study highlights BAT not just as a heat-generating organ but also as a tissue that actively responds to and reflects the metabolic state induced by CR, particularly in relation to hunger.
  • Shifting Neurotransmitter Balance: A key finding is the observed decrease in catecholamine precursors (l-tyrosine and dopamine) coupled with an increase in norepinephrine. This suggests a directed metabolic flux towards the activation of BAT, driven by the need for thermogenesis, rather than a general depletion of these compounds.
  • Antioxidant Boost: The increase in antioxidants with CR is a significant finding, suggesting that CR-induced mitochondrial uncoupling, while potentially generating reactive oxygen species, also triggers a compensatory increase in antioxidant defenses within BAT, contributing to cellular protection.
  • Energy Production Re-wiring: CR significantly impacts the TCA cycle and fatty acid degradation pathways, indicating a fundamental shift in how BAT generates and utilizes energy under restricted conditions.
  • Nucleic Acid Metabolism Upregulation: The increase in nucleic acid pathways is intriguing and may relate to increased cell proliferation or repair mechanisms within BAT in response to CR.

Key Results

  • 883 Differentially Expressed Metabolites: The study identified a substantial number of metabolites (883) that were significantly altered in BAT under graded CR compared to the 12AL control group.
  • Pathway Impacts: Pathway analysis revealed significant impacts on the TCA cycle, fatty acid degradation, nucleic acid metabolism, and catecholamine pathways.
  • Norepinephrine Upregulation: Norepinephrine, a key activator of BAT, was found to be increased with CR.
  • Precursor Decrease: Conversely, precursors to norepinephrine, l-tyrosine and dopamine, were decreased.
  • Antioxidant Increase: Antioxidant levels were observed to increase with CR.
  • Correlations with Physiology: Several key metabolic changes were correlated with food anticipatory activity (FAA) and body temperature, supporting the idea that BAT activation is linked to hunger responses and thermoregulation. For instance, dopamine was negatively correlated with CR level, while s-adenosyl-l-methionine and oxidized glutathione correlated positively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Snapshot in Time: The study provides a metabolomic snapshot, which represents steady-state levels. The authors acknowledge that this is a limitation, as metabolite flux (the rate of metabolic reactions) would provide a more dynamic understanding of the metabolic responses to CR.
  • Causality: Metabolomics alone cannot establish causality. Further investigation is needed to determine whether the observed metabolic changes are a cause or consequence of CR-induced BAT activation.
  • UCP1 Measurement: While the study infers changes related to UCP1 activity (uncoupling protein 1), direct measurements of UCP1 expression or activity were not performed on these specific samples. Future work could integrate transcriptomic or proteomic data to confirm these links.
  • Systemic vs. Local Effects: While some BAT-specific changes were observed, the authors note that similar metabolic remodeling was seen in liver and plasma of the same mice, suggesting systemic effects of CR. Future research could further explore the interplay between BAT and other tissues.
  • Functional Roles: The precise functional roles of all identified metabolites and pathways in the context of CR and BAT activation require further elucidation.

The study opens avenues for exploring how BAT can be targeted to mitigate metabolic disorders beyond diabetes, such as atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease, by understanding its role in energy balance and antioxidant defense under CR.

Summary updated

Abstract

Animals undergoing calorie restriction (CR) often lower their body temperature to conserve energy. Brown adipose tissue (BAT) is stimulated through norepinephrine when rapid heat production is needed, as it is highly metabolically active due to the uncoupling of the electron transport chain from ATP synthesis. To better understand how BAT metabolism changes with CR, we used metabolomics to identify 883 metabolites that were significantly differentially expressed in the BAT of C57BL/6 mice, fed graded CR (10%, 20%, 30%, and 40% CR relative to their individual baseline intake), compared with mice fed ad libitum (AL) for 12 hours a day. Pathway analysis revealed that graded CR had an impact on the TCA cycle and fatty acid degradation. In addition, an increase in nucleic acids and catecholamine pathways was seen with graded CR in the BAT metabolome. We saw increases in antioxidants with CR, suggesting a beneficial effect of mitochondrial uncoupling. Importantly, the instigator of BAT activation, norepinephrine, was increased with CR, whereas its precursors l-tyrosine and dopamine were decreased, indicating a shift of metabolites through the activation pathway. Several of these key changes were correlated with food anticipatory activity and body temperature, indicating BAT activation may be driven by responses to hunger.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{green2019effects,
  author = {Cara L. Green and Sharon E. Mitchell and Davina Derous and Yingchun Wang and Luonan Chen and Jing‐Dong J. Han and Daniel Promislow and David Lusseau and Alex Douglas and John R. Speakman},
  title = {{The Effects of Graded Levels of Calorie Restriction: XIV. Global Metabolomics Screen Reveals Brown Adipose Tissue Changes in Amino Acids, Catecholamines, and Antioxidants After Short-Term Restriction in C57BL/6 Mice}},
  booktitle = {The Journals of Gerontology Series A},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/gerona/glz023},
}
Figure