The Effects of Fireworks Discharge on Atmospheric PM2.5 Concentration in the Chinese Lunar New Year

Xuechen Zhang, Huanfeng Shen, Tongwen Li, Liangpei ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the significant, yet short-lived, impact of Chinese Lunar New Year fireworks on nationwide PM2.5 levels, showing a dramatic instantaneous spike but a surprisingly low sustained effect. While firework bans effectively curb immediate pollution bursts, their overall impact on the entire celebration period is limited, suggesting a need for nuanced, technology-assisted approaches to manage this deeply rooted cultural tradition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The annual Chinese Lunar New Year celebration is synonymous with widespread fireworks, a tradition deeply embedded in Chinese culture. While visually spectacular, this custom is suspected to be a major contributor to air pollution, particularly PM2.5, a pollutant known for its severe health impacts. Previous research on this topic has largely been limited to individual cities, lacking a comprehensive national-scale assessment. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a nationwide analysis of the fireworks' impact on PM2.5 concentrations, considering both instantaneous and sustained effects, and evaluating the efficacy of firework prohibition policies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining ground-based monitoring data with satellite remote sensing. To overcome the limitations of unevenly distributed ground stations and expand the research timeframe, they utilized Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) aerosol optical depth (AOD) products. A three-layer back-propagation neural network (BPNN) model was developed to retrieve historical PM2.5 concentrations from AOD and meteorological data, extending the analysis period from four years of ground data to fifteen years of satellite-derived data. The study also defined a 17-day time division schema around each Lunar New Year to analyze PM2.5 concentrations during pre-celebration, celebration, and post-celebration periods. Finally, they analyzed data from specific cities that implemented firework prohibition policies to assess their effectiveness.

Datasets

  • Ground PM2.5 Observations: Data from approximately 1600 ground monitoring stations across China (2013-2016).
  • MODIS AOD Products: Level 2 Collection 6 10-km AOD products from Terra and Aqua satellites (2002-2016).
  • Meteorological Data: NCEP GDAS/FNL 0.25 Degree Global Tropospheric Analyses and Forecast Grids data (1991 onwards), including relative humidity, temperature, wind speed, surface pressure, and planetary boundary layer height.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Instantaneous Shockwave": Fireworks create a dramatic, short-lived spike in PM2.5 that far surpasses other daily pollution sources. This highlights the immediate and potent nature of firework emissions.
  • The "Holiday Effect" Mitigation: Counterintuitively, the overall PM2.5 levels during the entire Lunar New Year celebration period were often lower than in the periods immediately before and after. This is attributed to reduced industrial and traffic emissions due to factory shutdowns and holiday travel, effectively masking the firework impact over a longer duration.
  • Policy Effectiveness is Nuanced: Firework bans are highly effective at reducing the immediate PM2.5 surge in the early hours of New Year's Day. However, their impact on the overall air quality throughout the entire 17-day celebration period is less pronounced, suggesting that other factors (like weather and ongoing daily emissions) play a significant role.
  • Cultural Significance vs. Environmental Impact: The study acknowledges the deep cultural roots of fireworks. It argues against a complete ban, advocating instead for a balanced approach that minimizes negative effects through technological advancements and scientific governance.

Key Results

  • Nationwide PM2.5 concentrations increased by 159% to 223% of the average level on New Year's Eve due to fireworks.
  • The averaged PM2.5 concentrations during the 17-day celebration period were 0.99 to 16.32 µg/m³ lower than the average values of the pre- and post-celebration periods.
  • In 31 provincial capital cities, a significant response of PM2.5 to fireworks was observed in the majority of cases during the 2013-2016 periods (ranging from 51.6% to 74.2%).
  • Firework prohibition policies significantly reduced the instantaneous PM2.5 peaks, but no obvious air quality improvement was observed over the entire celebration period.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while firework prohibition policies can reduce instantaneous peaks, their impact on the entire celebration period is limited due to other influencing factors like meteorological conditions and daily emissions. They suggest that a complete ban might be overly simplistic given the cultural significance of fireworks. Future work should focus on developing more humanized and scientific approaches, such as guiding public fireworks discharge to appropriate times and places, and encouraging the development of low-pollution substitutes like environmentally friendly explosives and electronic fireworks. The study also implicitly points to the need for better understanding of the interplay between cultural practices, policy interventions, and complex atmospheric dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Discharging fireworks during the Chinese Lunar New Year celebrations is a deep-rooted custom in China. In this paper, we analyze the effect of this cultural activity on PM<sub>2.5</sub> concentration using both ground observations and satellite data. By combining remote sensing data, the problem of uneven spatial distribution of ground monitoring has been compensated, and the research time span has been expanded. The results show that the extensive firework displays on New Year's Eve lead to a remarkable increase in nationwide PM<sub>2.5</sub> concentration, which were 159~223% of the average level, indicating the instantaneous effect far exceeds that of any other factor over the whole year. However, the averaged PM<sub>2.5</sub> concentrations of the celebration period were 0.99~16.32 μg/m<sup>3</sup> lower compared to the average values of the corresponding pre-celebration period and post-celebration period, indicating the sustained effect is not very significant. The implementation of firework prohibition policies can greatly reduce the instantaneous PM<sub>2.5</sub> increase, but no obvious air quality improvement is observed over the entire celebration period. Combining these findings and the cultural significance of this activity, we recommend that this custom is actively maintained, using new technologies and scientific governance programs to minimize the negative effects.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2020effects,
  author = {Xuechen Zhang and Huanfeng Shen and Tongwen Li and Liangpei Zhang},
  title = {{The Effects of Fireworks Discharge on Atmospheric PM2.5 Concentration in the Chinese Lunar New Year}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17249333},
}
Figure