Abstract Creatine is an organic compound that facilitates the recycling of energy-providing adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in muscle and brain tissue. It is a safe, well-studied supplement for strength training. Previous studies have shown that supplementation increases brain creatine levels, which might increase cognitive performance. The results of studies that have tested cognitive performance differ greatly, possibly due to different populations, supplementation regimens and cognitive tasks. This is the largest study on the effect of creatine supplementation on cognitive performance to date. As part of our study, we replicated Rae et al. (2003). Our trial was cross-over, double-blind, placebo-controlled, and randomised, with daily supplementation of 5g for six weeks each. Like Rae et al. (2003), we tested participants on Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices (RAPM) and on the Backward Digit Span (BDS). In addition, we included eight exploratory cognitive tests. About half of our 123 participants were vegetarians and half were omnivores. There was no indication that vegetarians benefited more from creatine than omnivores, so we merged the two groups. Participants’ scores after creatine and after placebo differed to an extent that was not statistically significant (BDS: p = 0.064, η 2 P = 0.029; RAPM: p = 0.327, η 2 P = 0.008). Compared to the null hypothesis of no effect, Bayes factors indicate weak evidence in favour of a small beneficial creatine effect and strong evidence against a large creatine effect. There was no indication that creatine improved the performance of our exploratory cognitive tasks. Side effects were reported significantly more often for creatine than for placebo supplementation (p = 0.002, RR = 4.25). Our results do not support large effects of creatine on the selected measures of cognition. However, our study, in combination with the literature, implies that creatine might have a small beneficial effect. Larger studies are needed to confirm or rule out this effect. Given the safety and broad availability of creatine, this is well worth investigating; a small effect could have large benefits when scaled over time and over many people.
Introduction
Creatine is widely recognized in sports science for its role in recycling adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the primary energy currency of the body, particularly in muscle tissue. Given that the brain is an exceptionally energy-intensive organ, it has been hypothesized that creatine supplementation could enhance cognitive performance.
However, existing research presents a conflicting landscape. While some studies report significant improvements in reasoning and memory, others find no effect. A seminal 2003 study by Rae et al. suggested large cognitive gains specifically among vegetarians, leading to the theory that supplementation is most effective in those with low baseline dietary intake. This study aims to resolve these contradictions through a large-scale, rigorous replication and expansion of previous work.
Methods
The study utilized a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over trial design. A total of 123 healthy young adult participants (approximately half vegetarians and half omnivores) were recruited. The study design followed participants from enrollment through multiple follow-up stages to final analysis.
Protocol and Testing
Participants consumed 5g of creatine monohydrate or a placebo daily for six weeks. Following a six-week "washout" period, participants switched to the alternate supplement. Cognitive performance was assessed using two primary benchmarks:
- Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices (RAPM): A measure of abstract reasoning.
- Backward Digit Span (BDS): A measure of working memory.
Additionally, an exploratory battery of eight tests was included to assess attention, verbal fluency, and task switching. Statistical analysis included both standard p-values and Bayesian analysis to quantify the strength of evidence for both the null and alternative hypotheses.
Key Results
The study's findings challenge several established notions regarding creatine and cognition:
- Absence of "Vegetarian Advantage": Contrary to previous theories, vegetarians did not show a greater benefit from supplementation than omnivores. This suggests that brain creatine homeostasis may be more resilient to dietary variations than previously assumed.
- Working Memory (BDS): There was a slight trend toward improvement ($p = 0.064$, $\eta^2_p = 0.029$), representing an average increase of approximately 0.41 additional correct items. Bayesian analysis ($BF_{10} \approx 3.6$) provided moderate evidence for a small effect.
- Abstract Reasoning (RAPM): No significant effect was observed ($p = 0.327$), with evidence weakly favoring the null hypothesis.
- Side Effects: Creatine was associated with a significantly higher incidence of digestive issues and minor weight gain compared to placebo (Relative Risk = 4.25). Blinding was also challenged by the difference in solubility and side effects (17% vs 4%).
Discussion
While this study did not find the large cognitive boosts reported in smaller, earlier trials, it provides strong evidence against such large effects while leaving room for the possibility of "micro-gains."
Several limitations may have influenced the results. The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a shift from in-person to remote testing via video calls, potentially introducing noise into the cognitive data. Furthermore, blinding was imperfect; the lower solubility of creatine compared to the maltodextrin placebo was a tell-tale sign for observant participants. Future studies should consider using capsules or better-matched fillers like cellulose.
In conclusion, while creatine is not a "limitless" pill, it remains a safe and affordable supplement that may offer marginal cognitive benefits. Future research with even larger sample sizes and improved blinding techniques is necessary to definitively characterize these small but potentially impactful effects.
Summary updated