The Effects of Coastal Dune Volume and Vegetation on Storm-Induced Property Damage: Analysis from Hurricane Ike

Jacob M. Sigren, Jens Figlus, Wesley E. Highfield, Rusty A. Feagin, Anna R. ArmitageJournal of Coastal Research 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the economic value of coastal sand dunes in mitigating storm-induced property damage, using Hurricane Ike as a case study. The research demonstrates that both dune volume and vegetation significantly reduce damage, providing a strong economic argument for investing in these natural defenses as a form of green infrastructure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal communities worldwide are increasingly vulnerable to the devastating impacts of tropical storms and hurricanes. While the protective role of coastal ecosystems like dunes is recognized, there's a significant knowledge gap regarding their quantitative economic benefits. Specifically, understanding the monetary value of dune volume and vegetation in reducing property damage is crucial for informing coastal management and hazard mitigation strategies. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a data-driven economic valuation of these natural protective services.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel Geographic Information System (GIS)-based approach to delineate and quantify coastal dune characteristics. They then used multivariate regression analysis to relate these ecological variables (dune volume and vegetation area), along with built-environment (home value, age) and geographic (distance from shore, storm eye) covariates, to sustained property damage claims from Hurricane Ike.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Dune Delineation: A 6-degree slope threshold derived from LIDAR data was used to distinguish coastal dunes from the beach and shore, ensuring that even embryonic dunes were included.
  • Quantification: Dune sediment volume and vegetation area were quantified using pre-storm LIDAR and aerial photography data from 2006 (two years prior to Hurricane Ike).
  • Multivariate Regression: A backward, stepwise regression was used to identify significant predictors of property damage. A Chow test was employed to determine if Galveston and Bolivar should be modeled separately due to differing storm conditions, which they were. Further Chow tests were used to analyze Galveston by shoreline quartile zones.
  • Economic Valuation: The study utilized a log-linear model semielasticity approach to estimate the "per unit value" of dune ecosystem variables. This was then used to calculate the total storm mitigation value by comparing the estimated damage with existing dune conditions versus a hypothetical scenario with minimal dune presence.

Datasets

  • Property Damage Data: National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) claims from FEMA for properties affected by Hurricane Ike.
  • Dune Data:
    • LIDAR data (2006) for topographic information and dune volume quantification.
  • Aerial photography (2006) for vegetation area assessment.
  • Built-Environment Data: Home structure value and age data obtained from the Galveston County Appraisal District.
  • Geographic Data: Home distance from the shoreline and from the eye of Hurricane Ike at landfall, calculated using ArcMap 10.1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dunes are Economically Valuable: The study provides concrete economic figures for the protective services of dunes, demonstrating they are not just ecological features but also significant economic assets.
  • Both Volume and Vegetation Matter: Both the physical volume of sand and the presence of vegetation on dunes contribute to reducing property damage, though their effects are collinear.
  • Location Matters: The protective value of dunes diminishes with distance from the shoreline. Homes closer to the coast benefited more directly from dune protection.
  • Regional Differences: Storm conditions significantly impacted the effectiveness and value of dunes, with Bolivar experiencing higher surge and wind, leading to different damage patterns and dune valuations compared to Galveston.
  • Green Infrastructure Justification: The findings strongly support the integration of bioengineered, green infrastructure (like restored dunes) as a viable and cost-effective alternative to traditional hard coastal structures.

Key Results

  • Total Mitigation Value: The estimated total property damage offset value of coastal dunes across the study area (Galveston and Bolivar) due to Hurricane Ike was over $8 million.
  • Per Homeowner Value: On average, the presence of dunes mitigated approximately $8200 in damage per homeowner.
  • Per Unit Value:
    • Dune sediment was valued at roughly $50 per cubic meter** for Galveston and **$12.13 per cubic meter for Bolivar.
  • Dune vegetation was valued at roughly $140 per square meter** for Galveston and **$43.87 per square meter for Bolivar.
  • Annualized Value: Based on historical storm frequency, coastal vegetated dunes were valued at approximately $86,000 per hectare per year.
  • Predictors of Damage: Older homes, more valuable homes, and homes closer to the shoreline sustained significantly more damage.
  • Shoreline Zones: In Galveston, the closest shoreline zone (48-135m from shore) experienced the highest damage per household, and dune protection was most significant in this zone. The protective value of dunes diminished in zones farther from the shore.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Collinearity of Dune Variables: Dune vegetation area and sediment volume were highly collinear, meaning they were modeled separately, and their individual values should not be summed additively. This collinearity likely arises from the relationship between vegetation trapping sediment and larger dune volumes.
  • Dune Morphology: The study treated all dune volume and vegetation similarly, but different dune morphologies and vegetation species can have varying protective capabilities. Future work could incorporate dune morphology categorization.
  • Data Age: The LIDAR and aerial photography data used for dune quantification were collected two years prior to Hurricane Ike. While the authors note that no major storm events occurred in this period, any minor accretion or erosion could introduce noise.
  • Uniform Dune Systems: The methodology relies on variation in dune parameters. For areas with large, uniform dunes, this approach might not be directly applicable, and alternative methods like replacement cost analysis might be more suitable.
  • Single Storm Event: The valuation is based on a single storm event (Hurricane Ike). Additional assessments across multiple storms and diverse dune systems are needed to confirm the generalizability of these findings.
  • "Reach" of Protection: The study suggests that dune protection has a limited "reach" inland, with its influence diminishing significantly beyond a certain distance from the shoreline.
  • Paradoxical Planning: The authors caution against a paradoxical feedback loop where increased protection leads to more development, potentially negating the benefits.

Future work could involve incorporating more detailed dune morphology data, analyzing a wider range of storm events, and applying these methods to other coastal regions to build a more comprehensive understanding of the economic value of coastal dunes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sigren, J.M.; Figlus, J.; Highfield, W.; Feagin, R.A., and Armitage, A.R., 2018. The effects of coastal dune volume and vegetation on storm-induced property damage: Analysis from Hurricane Ike.In response to numerous recent high-profile cases of tropical storm and hurricane damage to coastal communities, there has been increasing attention on the storm protection services provided by coastal ecosystems. However, substantial knowledge gaps exist regarding the quantitative economic benefits of such services, particularly for coastal vegetated dune ecosystems. A novel geographic information system (GIS)-based technique for delineating, quantifying, and relating coastal dune volume, vegetation area, and geographic and built-environment covariates to sustained property damage was used for the upper Texas coast following Hurricane Ike in 2008. The multivariate regression analysis contained more than 1000 homes spanning both sides of the storm's path. Dune volume and vegetation were both significantly related to reduced sustained property damage for the west side of the storm. For this area, model results showed that dune sediment was worth roughly $50 per cubic meter and dune vegetation was worth roughly $140 per square meter. However, because these variables were collinear and modeled separately, these amounts should not be viewed additively. The total property damage offset value of dunes across the study area was estimated to be more than $8 million, or approximately $8200 per homeowner. Based on the frequency of storms for this area over the last 115 years, coastal vegetated dunes were valued at roughly $86,000 per hectare per year. The results indicate that dunes could play an integral role in coastal hazard mitigation strategies and offer a unique opportunity where bioengineered, green infrastructure can be used as an alternative to hard coastal structures.
BibTeX
@article{sigren2018effects,
  author = {Jacob M. Sigren and Jens Figlus and Wesley E. Highfield and Rusty A. Feagin and Anna R. Armitage},
  title = {{The Effects of Coastal Dune Volume and Vegetation on Storm-Induced Property Damage: Analysis from Hurricane Ike}},
  journal = {Journal of Coastal Research},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2112/jcoastres-d-16-00169.1},
}
Figure