Abstract
This research investigates the impact of different game formats—educational versus competitive relay races—on the aggressive behaviors of seven-year-old children. Utilizing video analysis, a specialized observation matrix, and the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test, the study explores whether competitive pressure triggers specific types of aggression and if traditional psychological assessments can predict these behaviors. Findings indicate that competitive play significantly increases verbal aggression and teammate-directed frustration, while the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test showed no significant correlation with observed real-world aggression.
Introduction: Addressing Aggression in Play
Aggression in school settings remains a critical focus for educators and developmental psychologists. While play is fundamental to child development, the structure of games can inadvertently foster negative behaviors. This study bridges the gap between theoretical psychological assessment and real-world observation by addressing two primary questions:
- How do different game formats (cooperative/educational vs. competitive/relay) influence physical and verbal aggression?
- Can the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test accurately predict which children are prone to aggressive behavior during play?
Methods and Assessment Tools
The researchers conducted a field study in Istanbul involving 13 seven-year-old children (9 boys, 4 girls). A multi-modal observation approach was employed:
- Video Analysis: Children were recorded from multiple angles before, during, and after educational games and competitive relay ("stafet") races.
- Observation Form for Aggressive Behaviors: A custom matrix used to score specific actions (e.g., pushing, hitting, yelling) directed at teammates, opponents, referees, or equipment.
- Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test: A projective test where children draw a human figure, scored based on 27 criteria (e.g., omitted limbs, sharp teeth) intended to reflect emotional and behavioral issues.
- Statistical Analysis: Non-parametric tests (Wilcoxon Signed Ranks and Mann-Whitney U) were used to compare behaviors across game types and gender due to the small sample size.
Key Insights
The Predictivity Gap
A major finding of this study is the lack of a significant relationship between the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test scores and actual observed aggression in the gymnasium. This suggests that static "paper-and-pencil" psychological indicators may fail to capture behavioral tendencies in high-arousal, physical environments.
Competition-Induced Frustration
Aggression was not a constant state but was triggered by specific conditions. Verbal aggression, particularly "yelling out loud," increased significantly following games compared to baseline levels. The researchers attribute this to "competition-induced frustration."
Target of Aggression: Teammates vs. Opponents
In competitive relay races, aggressive behaviors were frequently directed at teammates rather than opponents. This indicates that the pressure to perform within a team can transform social play into a source of interpersonal conflict.
Gendered Material Aggression
While overall aggression levels were similar across genders, boys were significantly more likely to direct frustration toward equipment (e.g., kicking or stepping on game materials) compared to girls.
Results Summary
- Verbal Shifts: "Self-yelling" and "yelling out loud" were virtually non-existent before educational games but rose significantly afterward ($p < .01$).
- Physical Markers: Pushing, pulling, and hitting were common during relay races. Notably, extreme behaviors like biting were never observed.
- Drawing Test Inefficacy: Comparing "low" and "high" score groups from the drawing test revealed no statistically significant difference in their actual aggression points during play.
- Carry-over Effect: Aggressive acts toward materials were more prevalent after games, suggesting a lingering state of high arousal.
Limitations and Future Directions
The study's primary limitation is its small sample size ($n=13$) and geographic specificity, which limits generalizability. Future research should explore larger, more diverse cohorts and investigate "cooperative" game designs specifically intended to reduce aggression. The findings underscore the need for educators to utilize dynamic, observation-based tools rather than relying solely on traditional psychological screenings to manage classroom behavior effectively.
Summary updated