The effective diffusivity of ordered and freely evolving bubbly suspensions

Aurore Loisy, Aurore Naso, Peter SpeltJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2018 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates how passive scalars (like temperature or chemical concentrations) spread within bubbly suspensions. By using direct numerical simulations, the authors quantify the "effective diffusivity" of these suspensions, finding that the way bubbles move and interact significantly enhances mixing, especially at higher flow rates. This work provides a more accurate understanding of mixing in bubbly flows, crucial for applications in chemical engineering and beyond.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how things like heat or chemicals spread (dispersion) in bubbly flows is vital for many industrial processes, such as chemical reactors and heat exchangers. While it's known that rising bubbles agitate the liquid and enhance mixing, precisely quantifying this "effective diffusivity" has been challenging. Previous theoretical models often assumed simplified conditions like Stokes flow (very slow, viscous flows) or fixed bubble arrangements, which don't fully capture the complex, dynamic nature of real bubbly suspensions where bubbles move and deform. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating scalar dispersion in both ordered and freely evolving bubbly suspensions, considering the effects of bubble inertia and deformation.

Methods

The researchers employed direct numerical simulations (DNS) to model the fluid dynamics and scalar transport. They focused on the "convective contribution" to the effective diffusivity, which arises from the velocity fluctuations induced by bubble motion.

  • Ordered Suspensions: They extended existing theories (like Koch et al., 1989) to include weak inertial effects for ordered bubble arrangements. This involved analytical calculations and DNS.
  • Freely Evolving Suspensions: For more realistic scenarios, they simulated arrays of bubbles that could move and interact freely within a computational cell. This required more computationally intensive simulations.
  • Scalar Transport Equation: A key aspect was solving the scalar transport equation numerically, accounting for advection by fluid velocity and diffusion.
  • Effective Diffusivity Tensor: The core output is the effective diffusivity tensor, which describes the overall mixing properties. They specifically analyzed its longitudinal and transverse components relative to the bubble rise direction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inertia Matters, But Scaling Persists: Even with weak inertial effects (non-zero Reynolds numbers), the fundamental scaling of effective diffusivity with the Péclet number (which compares advective to diffusive transport) remains largely the same as in Stokes flow for ordered suspensions. Inertia primarily affects the proportionality constants.
  • Ordered vs. Free: A High-Pe Difference: While ordered and freely evolving suspensions show similar mixing behavior at low Péclet numbers (convectively enhanced dispersion), they diverge at high Péclet numbers. Ordered arrays exhibit "Taylor dispersion," but in freely evolving systems, this is replaced by a "mechanical dispersion" scaling, even with low levels of disorder.
  • Longitudinal Dominance: The longitudinal component of the effective diffusivity (in the direction of bubble rise) is significantly larger than the transverse component, except in specific scenarios. This highlights the primary role of bubble motion in driving mixing along the flow direction.
  • Deformation and Flow Regime Influence: Bubble shape (spherical vs. deformed) and the flow regime (characterized by Archimedes and Bond numbers) influence the mixing, but these effects are often quantitative rather than qualitative, particularly for the longitudinal dispersion.

Key Results

  • Ordered Suspensions: Analytical and numerical results for ordered suspensions showed that the effective diffusivity scales quadratically with the Péclet number at low Pe (convectively enhanced dispersion) and linearly at high Pe (Taylor dispersion). Inertial effects (Re up to ~40) were found to modify the proportionality constants but not the overall scaling.
  • Freely Evolving Suspensions: For freely evolving suspensions, the low-Pe scaling remained similar to ordered arrays. However, at high Pe, the longitudinal component showed a scaling consistent with mechanical dispersion (proportional to Udb, where U is velocity and db is bubble diameter), and the transverse component also followed this mechanical dispersion trend.
  • System Size Insensitivity: For freely evolving suspensions, the longitudinal effective diffusivity was found to be largely independent of the number of bubbles in the simulation cell (Nb) for 2 < Nb < 12, suggesting that relatively small systems can capture the essential physics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Conditions: The study assumes a constant scalar diffusivity in both phases and continuity of the scalar across the interface. Real systems may have different diffusivities or solubility differences, which would introduce additional diffusive contributions.
  • Limited Parameter Space for Free Arrays: Due to computational costs, the investigation of freely evolving suspensions was limited to one flow regime (ellipsoidal bubbles) and a specific intermediate volume fraction.
  • Experimental Comparison: While the results are qualitatively consistent with some experimental data, quantitative comparisons are limited due to differences in Reynolds numbers and other factors.

Future work could explore the impact of unequal diffusivities, varying volume fractions, and a wider range of flow regimes in freely evolving suspensions. Investigating the precise role of disorder and its quantitative effect on dispersion would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the dispersion of a passive scalar such as the concentration of a chemical species, or temperature, in homogeneous bubbly suspensions, by determining an effective diffusivity tensor. Defining the longitudinal and transverse components of this tensor with respect to the direction of averaged bubble rise velocity in a zero mixture velocity frame of reference, we focus on the convective contribution thereof, this being expected to be dominant in commonly encountered bubbly flows. We first extend the theory of Koch et al. ( J. Fluid Mech. , vol. 200, 1989, pp. 173–188) (which is for dispersion in fixed beds of solid particles under Stokes flow) to account for weak inertial effects in the case of ordered suspensions. In the limits of low and of high Péclet number, including the inertial effect of the flow does not affect the scaling of the effective diffusivity with respect to the Péclet number. These results are confirmed by direct numerical simulations performed in different flow regimes, for spherical or very deformed bubbles and from vanishingly small to moderate values of the Reynolds number. Scalar transport in arrays of freely rising bubbles is considered by us subsequently, using numerical simulations. In this case, the dispersion is found to be convectively enhanced at low Péclet number, like in ordered arrays. At high Péclet number, the Taylor dispersion scaling obtained for ordered configurations is replaced by one characterizing a purely mechanical dispersion, as in random media, even if the level of disorder is very low.
BibTeX
@article{loisy2018effective,
  author = {Aurore Loisy and Aurore Naso and Peter Spelt},
  title = {{The effective diffusivity of ordered and freely evolving bubbly suspensions}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2018.84},
}
Figure