The Effect of Weed Control with Pre-Emergence Herbicides on the Yield Level of Mung Bean Yield

Changfeng Jing, Junying Wang, Yonghong Wu, Yufan Zhou, Huijun Zhu, Yaowen Zhang, Shuqi Dong, Xiaorui Li, Juan Zhao, Junli Cao, Xiangyang Yuan, Xi’e SongPlants 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies two pre-emergence herbicides, imazethapyr and oxadiazon, as safe and effective for mung bean cultivation in China. These herbicides successfully controlled weeds without negatively impacting mung bean growth, yield, or physiological processes, offering a crucial solution for improving crop production efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mung beans are a vital leguminous crop in China, but their yield is significantly hampered by weed competition, especially during the early growth stages when the plants are most vulnerable. A major challenge is the lack of registered pre-emergence herbicides specifically for mung bean fields in China. This forces farmers to rely on herbicides used for other crops, potentially leading to suboptimal weed control or unintended harm to the mung beans. The study aims to address this gap by screening and evaluating pre-emergence herbicides for their efficacy and safety in mung bean cultivation, particularly in the Shanxi province.

Methods

The research employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Petri Dish Screening: Six common pre-emergence herbicides (alachlor, metolachlor, imazethapyr, oxadiazon, pendimethalin, and trifluralin) were tested at recommended doses on mung bean seeds in Petri dishes. The primary metric was the effect on radicle and germ length after germination.
  2. Pot Experiment: Herbicides that showed no significant negative impact on germination and early seedling growth (imazethapyr and oxadiazon) were then tested in potted mung bean plants. This stage assessed their effects on plant height, leaf area, and aboveground dry weight.
  3. Field Experiment: The selected herbicides (imazethapyr and oxadiazon) were applied in a field setting. This comprehensive evaluation included:
  4. Agronomic Traits: Measuring plant height, leaf area, aboveground fresh and dry weight, root length, and root dry weight.
  5. Physiological Indicators: Assessing photosynthetic pigment content (chlorophyll a, b, carotenoids), gas exchange parameters (net photosynthetic rate, stomatal conductance, transpiration rate), and chlorophyll fluorescence (maximum photochemical efficiency, actual photosynthetic efficiency).
  6. Antioxidant Enzyme Activity: Measuring the activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), and catalase (CAT) in mung bean roots.
  7. Soil Enzyme Activity: Analyzing the activity of soil urease, invertase, and alkaline phosphatase at various time points after herbicide application.
  8. Weed Control Efficacy: Quantifying the percentage of weed control (both plant and dry weight) at different intervals after treatment.
  9. Yield and Yield Components: Measuring the number of branches, pods per branch, effective pods per branch, 100-seed weight, and overall yield.

Statistical analysis, including Duncan's new complex range analysis, was used to determine significant differences between treatments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized experimental data collected from controlled laboratory, pot, and field experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Targeted Herbicide Selection is Crucial: Not all herbicides are created equal for mung beans. Initial screening revealed that while some herbicides severely inhibited early seedling growth (radicle and germ length), imazethapyr and oxadiazon showed no such detrimental effects. This highlights the importance of pre-screening for crop safety.
  • Pre-emergence Herbicides Can Enhance Crop Resilience: Beyond just weed control, imazethapyr and oxadiazon appeared to bolster the mung bean's defense mechanisms. The observed increase in antioxidant enzyme activity (SOD, POD, CAT) suggests that the plants were better equipped to handle potential stress, even though the herbicides themselves didn't inhibit growth.
  • Soil Health Indicators Respond Selectively: While soil urease activity decreased, invertase and alkaline phosphatase activities increased. This suggests a complex interaction with soil microbial communities and nutrient cycling, indicating that these herbicides might have a nuanced impact on soil health that warrants further investigation.
  • No Compromise on Yield: Crucially, the selected herbicides did not negatively impact key yield components or the overall yield of mung beans, demonstrating their suitability for agricultural application.

Key Results

  • Screening Success: Imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i. ha⁻¹) and oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i. ha⁻¹) were identified as safe pre-emergence herbicides, showing no significant inhibition of mung bean radicle and germ length in initial tests.
  • Agronomic Safety: In pot and field experiments, imazethapyr and oxadiazon did not inhibit plant height, leaf area, aboveground dry weight, root length, or root dry weight compared to controls.
  • Physiological Stability: Photosynthetic pigment content, gas exchange parameters, and chlorophyll fluorescence were not negatively affected by the application of imazethapyr and oxadiazon at the seed-filling stage.
  • Weed Control Efficacy: Both imazethapyr and oxadiazon demonstrated high weed control rates (often exceeding 80-100% for broadleaf weeds) on common weed species found in mung bean fields.
  • Yield Preservation: No significant differences were observed in yield components (number of branches, pods, effective pods, 100-seed weight) or overall yield between treatments with imazethapyr, oxadiazon, and artificial weeding.
  • Soil Enzyme Dynamics: Soil urease activity decreased, while invertase and alkaline phosphatase activities increased after 60 days of treatment.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study was conducted at a single location for one year. Therefore, they emphasize the need for multiple verifications across different environments and over several years to fully confirm the findings and ensure the broad applicability of these herbicides. Future work could also delve deeper into the specific mechanisms by which these herbicides influence soil enzyme activities and explore their long-term effects on soil microbial communities and overall soil health. Additionally, further research could investigate the potential for developing resistance in weeds to these herbicides over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

The mung bean (<i>Vigna radiata</i> (Linn) Wilczek.) is a major grain crop in China, but its yield is significantly impacted by weeds. However, no pre-emergence herbicides are registered for mung bean fields in the China Pesticide Information Network. Screening for efficient and safe pre-emergence herbicides could improve mung bean production efficiency. In this study, six pre-emergence herbicides were selected: 480 g/L alachlor (1935.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), 720 g/L metolachlor (1620.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), 100 g/L imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), 338 g/L oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), 330 g/L pendimethalin (144.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), and 480 g/L trifluralin (720.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>). Through Petri dish screening, a spraying treatment was carried out before seed germination. By measuring the root length and shoot length, imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>) and oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>) were screened out. They were applied to potted plants and sprayed after sowing. The results showed that imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i. ha<sup>-1</sup>) and oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i. ha<sup>-1</sup>) had no inhibitory effect on the growth and development of the mung bean. Subsequently, experiments were conducted with imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>) and oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>) applied in the field. Compared to the control, under imazethapyr (100.50 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>) and oxadiazon (507.00 g a.i ha<sup>-1</sup>), the agronomic traits, photosynthetic pigment content, yield, and yield components were not inhibited; the activities of superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, and catalase were increased; and gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence were not inhibited. In addition, soil urease activity decreased and soil invertase and alkaline phosphatase activity increased after 60 d of treatment. In summary, imazethapyr and oxadiazon can effectively control weeds and increase mung bean yield. The purpose of this study is to screen out safe and efficient pre-emergence herbicides suitable for the Shanxi mung bean, which is of great significance due to its large-scale planting industrialization and the development of advantageous industries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jing2025effect,
  author = {Changfeng Jing and Junying Wang and Yonghong Wu and Yufan Zhou and Huijun Zhu and Yaowen Zhang and Shuqi Dong and Xiaorui Li and Juan Zhao and Junli Cao and Xiangyang Yuan and Xi’e Song},
  title = {{The Effect of Weed Control with Pre-Emergence Herbicides on the Yield Level of Mung Bean Yield}},
  booktitle = {Plants},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/plants14020275},
}
Figure