The Effect of Water–Zeolite Amount–Burial Depth on Greenhouse Tomatoes with Drip Irrigation under Mulch

Ming Zhang, Tao Lei, Xianghong Guo, Jianxin Liu, Xiaoli Gao, Zhen Lei, Xiaolan JuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the optimal combination of water levels, zeolite application rates, and burial depths for greenhouse tomatoes using drip irrigation and mulch. By employing an Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to evaluate multiple growth, physiological, yield, and quality indicators, the research identifies a specific set of conditions that maximize tomato yield and overall quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optimizing crop production, especially in controlled environments like greenhouses, requires a nuanced understanding of how various inputs interact. For tomatoes, a globally important vegetable, water management is critical, and soil amendments like zeolite can enhance water retention and nutrient availability. However, the specific effects of combining water levels, the amount of zeolite, and its burial depth on tomato growth, physiology, yield, and quality are not fully understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically exploring these interactions and developing a comprehensive evaluation framework to determine the most suitable strategy for high-quality, high-yield tomato cultivation.

Methods

The researchers conducted greenhouse planting experiments using a three-factor orthogonal test design. The factors investigated were:

  • Water level (W): Three levels representing 50-70%, 60-80%, and 70-90% of field capacity.
  • Zeolite Amount (Z): Three levels of 3, 6, and 9 t·hm⁻².
  • Zeolite Burial Depth (H): Three levels of 15, 30, and 45 cm.

They meticulously measured a wide array of parameters, including:

  • Growth: Plant height, stem diameter.
  • Physiology: Net photosynthetic rate, stomatal conductivity, transpiration rate, intercellular CO₂ concentration.
  • Root characteristics: Total root length, surface area, volume, and average diameter.
  • Quality: Organic acid, vitamin C, nitrate, and soluble solids content.
  • Yield and Efficiency: Dry matter quality, yield, and water use efficiency (WUE).

To synthesize these diverse measurements into a single, objective evaluation, the study employed the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). This method allows for the systematic weighting and comparison of multiple criteria, enabling the determination of an overall optimal treatment combination.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from greenhouse experiments conducted in Yangqu County, Shanxi Province, China. The soil type was loess-like and light brown. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; the research generated its own experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interactions are complex: The study highlights that the effects of water, zeolite amount, and burial depth are not always linear and can interact in complex ways, sometimes promoting a trait initially and then inhibiting it.
  • Water is King (mostly): Water level (W) consistently emerged as the most influential factor across many indicators, often playing a dominant role in growth, physiology, and yield.
  • Zeolite's dual role: Zeolite application can be beneficial, but its effectiveness is highly dependent on the amount and depth. Too much or too little, or incorrect placement, can lead to suboptimal results.
  • Holistic evaluation is crucial: Relying on a single metric (like yield alone) can be misleading. The AHP approach, which considers multiple growth, physiological, and quality factors, provides a more robust understanding of optimal conditions.
  • Specific optimal window: The research pinpoints a narrow range of conditions that yield the best overall results, suggesting that precise management is key.

Key Results

  • Water's impact: Increasing water levels generally promoted plant height, stem diameter, root growth, photosynthetic rates, and yield, but inhibited intercellular CO₂ concentration and nitrate content.
  • Zeolite's nuanced effects: Zeolite amount and burial depth had varied effects. For instance, increasing zeolite amount promoted plant height and photosynthetic rates but could inhibit nitrate content. Increasing burial depth promoted plant height and organic acid content but inhibited intercellular CO₂ concentration.
  • Dominant factors: The influence of factors on different indicators varied. For example, water (W) was more influential than zeolite depth (H) and amount (Z) on stem diameter, transpiration rate, and root length (W > H > Z). However, for many other indicators like yield and WUE, the order was W > Z > H.
  • Optimal combination: The highest comprehensive score, indicating the best overall performance, was achieved with a water level of 70-90% field capacity, 6 t/hm² of zeolite, and a 15 cm burial depth.
  • Weighting of indicators: Using AHP, the study determined the relative importance of various indicators for overall success, with yield (Ay) being the most critical, followed by WUE, nitrate (NO), and organic acid (OA).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in a specific greenhouse environment with loess-like soil. The findings might vary in different soil types, climates, or greenhouse conditions.
  • Zeolite type: The paper doesn't specify the type of zeolite used, which could influence its properties and effectiveness.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that their comprehensive evaluation model can provide theoretical guidance for tomato planting and water regulation. Further research could explore different zeolite types, investigate the long-term effects of these strategies, and validate these findings across a wider range of agricultural settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The water–zeolite amount–burial depth coupling regulation strategy of high-quality and high-yield tomatoes was explored with drip irrigation under mulch. Greenhouse planting experiments were performed to monitor and analyze the tomato growth, physiology, yield, quality, and water use efficiency (WUE). The suitable amounts of the water–zeolite amount–burial depth for the tomato growth were determined through the analytic hierarchy process (AHP). The results showed that the effects of increasing the water of the intercellular CO2 concentration (Ci), nitrate content (NO), vitamin content (VC), and soluble solids (SS), increasing the WUE, increasing the zeolite amount of the NO, and increasing the zeolite burial depth of the Ci and SS, were inhibited. The effects of increasing the zeolite amount of the plant height (Kh), stem thickness (Kt), total root length (Rl), total root volume (Rv), root average diameter (Rd), net photosynthetic rate (Pn), stomatal conductivity (Gs), organic acid (OA), VC, yield (Ay), and WUE, and of increasing the zeolite burial depth of the Kh, OA, dry matter quality (Ad), and WUE, were promoted first and then inhibited. The other indicators showed a positive response to increasing the water, zeolite amount, and burial depth. The influence of the water (W), zeolite amount (Z), and zeolite depth (H) on the Kt, Tr, Rl, and Rd, was W > H > Z, and that of the Kh, Gs, Pn, Ci, Ra, Rv, OA, VC, NO, SS, Ad, Ay, and WUE was W > Z > H. The order of weight of each index, based on the AHP, is as follows: Ay > WUE > NO > OA > Ad > Kh > Kt > VC > SS > Pn > Rv > Rd > Tr. The highest comprehensive score was W70–90Z6H15, and the most suitable water conditions for the tomato planting under drip irrigation were 70–90% field capacity, 6 t/hm2 zeolite, and 15 cm depth of zeolite.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023effect,
  author = {Ming Zhang and Tao Lei and Xianghong Guo and Jianxin Liu and Xiaoli Gao and Zhen Lei and Xiaolan Ju},
  title = {{The Effect of Water–Zeolite Amount–Burial Depth on Greenhouse Tomatoes with Drip Irrigation under Mulch}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15065220},
}
Figure