The effect of visibility in the integration of lean and agile for supply chains

Xin WangWarwick 2012

Abstract

Over the last two decades, supply chain researchers have sought to find appropriate ways of achieving lean and agile “LeAgile” supply chains. However, the differences in the priorities of the lean and agile paradigms multiply the challenges in lean and agile combinations. This research evaluates the effect of supply chain visibility (SCV) on improved LeAgile supply chain performance using a role-playing simulation methodology. The results suggest that adopting a supply chain visibility approach can increase overall performance by over 26% compared to traditional decoupling point and postponement strategies.

Introduction

For decades, supply chain managers have struggled to reconcile two opposing paradigms: Lean (minimizing waste and cost in predictable environments) and Agile (maximizing speed and flexibility in volatile markets). The hybrid "LeAgile" approach usually relies on physical structural changes, such as "decoupling points" (strategic inventory buffers) or "postponement" (delaying final product assembly).

However, these traditional methods are often expensive to implement and difficult to calibrate. While visibility—the ability to see real-time data across the entire chain—is often cited as a solution, there has been a lack of quantitative evidence showing exactly how different levels of visibility impact LeAgile performance in complex, multi-tier networks. This paper seeks to quantify that relationship and determine if "more visibility" is always better.

Methodology

The study employed a hybrid simulation methodology combining computer modeling with human role-playing. This approach is unique because it captures the "human factor"—the panic ordering, trust issues, and decision-making biases that occur in real-world supply chains but are often missed by pure mathematical models.

Key components of the method include:

  • The Model: A four-echelon supply chain (Suppliers, OEM, Distributors, and Customers) based on the well-known Hewlett Packard (HP) Deskjet printer case study.
  • The Tech Stack: To simulate modern visibility without the high cost of enterprise ERP systems, a custom, low-cost cloud-based dashboard was built using Google Docs, Google Wave, and Google Sites. This allowed participants to see real-time inventory, demand, and operational status.
  • The Experiments: Three distinct experiments were conducted to test Demand Visibility (sharing requirements), Operational Visibility (sharing machine breakdowns, etc.), and a head-to-head comparison with traditional decoupling/postponement strategies.

Key Insights and Results

Quantitative Performance Gains

The quantitative results from the simulation were striking:

  • Bullwhip Effect: Sharing inventory and demand data across the chain reduced demand amplification (the bullwhip effect) by 43.9%.
  • Leanness: Improved operational visibility led to a 30% reduction in inventory and a 19.4% reduction in total costs.
  • Agility: Customer service levels (order fill rates) increased by 6.5% even as costs and inventory fell—achieving the core goal of LeAgility.
  • Head-to-Head Comparison: The visibility-driven approach outperformed traditional decoupling point and postponement strategies by 26.3% and 26.4% respectively in terms of overall supply chain value.

The Nature of Information Sharing

  • The "Critical Frequency" and Digital Waste: Visibility is not a linear "more is better" relationship. The research identified a "critical frequency" for sharing data. Sharing information too frequently or sharing irrelevant data creates "digital waste," which confuses human decision-makers and can actually erode performance.
  • Operational Visibility as a Catalyst: While sharing demand data is standard, sharing operational data (machine breakdowns, defect rates, late deliveries) provided a massive boost in flexibility, allowing the chain to recover from disruptions much faster.
  • Visibility as a Trust Builder: Visibility compensated for a lack of trust. When participants could "see" the raw demand data from the end customer, they were more likely to follow a centralized plan rather than making "panic orders" based on their immediate neighbor's behavior.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that supply chain visibility is a powerful, low-cost lever for achieving LeAgile performance. The results suggest that achieving visibility through IT can be more effective and significantly cheaper than physically restructuring a supply chain or holding massive amounts of safety stock at decoupling points. Future work should test if these findings hold true for more complex, "mesh-like" supply networks and explore the impact of automated data collection technologies like RFID or IoT sensors on human decision-making.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the last two decades, supply chain researchers have sought to find appropriate ways of achieving lean and agile “LeAgile” supply chains. However, the differences in the priorities of the lean and agile paradigms multiply the challenges in lean and agile combinations. The most discussed approaches in the literature are the decoupling point and the late customisation (postponement) strategies. Supply chain visibility as a solution is less frequently discussed though the ‘Smarter Supply Chain of the Future’ report states that ‘70% of supply chain leaders view Supply Chain Visibility as their number one challenge... the need to ‘see’ and act on the right information’ (IBM, 2010). Technologies such as EDI and RFID have been implemented to improve visibility, have not gained general acceptance. Newer, low cost ‘Cloud’ solutions may be able to address the need better.
\n
\nPrevious research has suggested that increasing information visibility improves supply chain performance, though the relationship between the degree of visibility and resulting performance does not appear to have been addressed. Therefore, a role playing simulation methodology was devised to evaluate the effect of supply chain visibility on improved LeAgile supply chain performance. Role playing simulations better emulate the human control actions in supply chains, but can also suffer/benefit from traits such as learning.
\n
\nA low cost Web and Cloud based system was devised to enable visibility and communication in the simulation. Different information sharing configurations (visibility levels) were evaluated for a typical four-echelon supply chain. The results show a correlation in improved supply chain LeAgility with the degree of visibility of demand and/or operational information, but this was not a linear relationship. A degree of ‘digital’ waste eroded performance with increasing levels of visibility.
\n
\nComparison simulations were then conducted to compare the supply chain visibility strategy with ‘decoupling point’ and ‘postponement’ strategies for the same four-echelon supply chain. The results suggest that after adopting the supply chain visibility approach, the overall performance of the simulation supply chain increased by 26.3% and 26.4% compared to the decoupling point and postponement approach scenarios. Further simulation experiments with different supply chain configurations are required to test the wider applicability of the results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2012effect,
  author = {Xin Wang},
  title = {{The effect of visibility in the integration of lean and agile for supply chains}},
  booktitle = {Warwick},
  year = {2012},
}
Figure