TL;DR
This paper investigates how social enterprises grow, moving beyond internal resource focus to explore the impact of "value co-creation" with customers. It finds that while co-creation generally boosts growth, a dynamic and unpredictable external environment can significantly weaken this positive effect.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Traditional research on social enterprise growth often focuses on internal factors like resources and capabilities. However, this approach struggles to explain why some social enterprises thrive while others falter. The authors argue that this is insufficient, especially as the business landscape shifts towards a service-oriented model where customer involvement in value creation is crucial. They aim to bridge this gap by examining how value co-creation, a concept where businesses and customers jointly create value, influences social enterprise growth, and how external environmental factors might interfere with this process.
Methods
The study employs a quantitative approach using hierarchical regression analysis. This statistical technique allows researchers to examine the incremental impact of adding variables to a model. The authors build their model in stages:
- Model 1: Establishes a baseline with control variables.
- Model 2: Introduces "value co-creation" as the independent variable to assess its direct effect on social enterprise growth.
- Model 3: Incorporates "environment dynamics" as a moderating variable.
- Model 4: Adds an interaction term between value co-creation and environment dynamics to test for a moderating effect.
The data was collected through a survey of social enterprises in China.
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 172 usable questionnaires from social enterprises across 29 provinces and municipalities in China. The survey was conducted between October 2015 and March 2016. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses data collected for this specific research.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Internal Focus: Social enterprise growth isn't just about what's inside the organization; external collaboration, particularly with customers, is vital.
- Value Co-Creation as a Growth Engine: When social enterprises actively involve customers in creating value, it can lead to better market performance, increased customer loyalty, and ultimately, growth. This is especially important for social enterprises facing resource constraints.
- The Double-Edged Sword of Environment Dynamics: While a stable environment might allow value co-creation to flourish, a rapidly changing or unpredictable external environment (e.g., policy shifts, market volatility) can create uncertainty that hinders effective co-creation and thus dampens growth.
- Value Co-Destruction is Real: The paper hints at the concept of "value co-destruction," where customer interactions can sometimes lead to negative outcomes, especially when combined with environmental turbulence.
Key Results
- Hypothesis 1 (H1): Value co-creation has a significant positive effect on the growth of social enterprises. This was partially confirmed, with a significant positive coefficient for value co-creation when it was the primary independent variable (Model 2).
- Hypothesis 2 (H2): Environment dynamics have a negative moderation effect on the relationship between value co-creation and social enterprise growth. This hypothesis was confirmed. The interaction term between environment dynamics and value co-creation was significant and negative (Model 4), indicating that the positive impact of value co-creation on growth is weaker in high-dynamism environments.
- Control Variables: Only work experience and the number of employees showed a significant impact in the initial model, suggesting that longevity and scale might play a role, but their influence diminishes when more impactful variables are considered.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Definition Ambiguity: The definition of a social enterprise is still evolving, which could lead to inaccuracies in data collection and analysis.
- Cross-Sectional Design: The study used a single snapshot in time. A longitudinal design would provide stronger evidence for causality and avoid common method biases.
- Limited Items: The theoretical framework and measurement scales for the variables (especially value co-creation) were based on a limited number of items, suggesting room for improvement in capturing the complexity of these constructs.
Future work could focus on:
- Improving the quality of interaction between enterprises and consumers.
- Establishing systems for offering unique consumer experiences.
- Investigating how consumers can be more efficiently involved in value co-creation.
- Exploring value co-creation under different tactical approaches by social enterprises.
- Considering a broader range of factors within environment dynamics.
Summary updated