The effect of the surgical microscope on the outcome of root scaling.

Haiqing Liao, Huihui Zhang, Junbo Xiang, Guanting Chen, Zhengguo CaoPubMed 2020

TL;DR

This study provides laboratory evidence that using a surgical microscope during root scaling significantly improves the removal of bacterial deposits and calculus, leading to root surfaces with mechanical and topographical properties closer to healthy teeth. This enhanced cleaning also promotes better adhesion and proliferation of periodontal ligament cells and reduces inflammatory markers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Periodontitis, a common inflammatory disease affecting the gums and supporting structures of teeth, requires thorough removal of bacterial deposits (calculus and endotoxin) for successful treatment. While surgical microscopes are increasingly used in dentistry for their magnification and illumination benefits, their specific advantages in periodontal therapy, particularly root scaling, have largely been based on subjective reports rather than objective, laboratory-based evidence. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing quantitative data on the impact of microscope-assisted root scaling on the physical and biological properties of the root surface.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to evaluate the effectiveness of microscope-assisted root scaling. Extracted teeth were divided into four groups:

  • Normal Control (NC): Healthy teeth.
  • Periodontitis Control (PC): Untreated periodontitis teeth.
  • Macro Group: Periodontitis teeth scaled without magnification.
  • Micro Group: Periodontitis teeth scaled using a surgical microscope (10x magnification).

Key techniques included:

  • Stained Deposits Evaluation: Visual assessment of residual calculus after staining.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To examine the surface morphology of the root surfaces.
  • Nanoindentation: A high-precision technique to measure the nanotopography, elastic modulus, and nanohardness of the root surface at the nanoscale. This is a more advanced method than traditional profilometry for assessing mechanical properties.
  • Cell Culture and Assays:
    • Periodontal Ligament Cell (PDLC) Culture: PDLCs were cultured on the treated root surfaces to assess cell adhesion, morphology, and proliferation.
  • Immunofluorescence Assay: Used to visualize cell morphology and F-actin cytoskeleton.
  • Cell Counting Kit-8 (CCK-8): To quantify cell proliferation.
  • Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA): To measure the levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6 and IL-8) secreted by PDLCs.

Datasets

The study utilized extracted human teeth from patients diagnosed with advanced chronic periodontitis and healthy individuals. These teeth served as the biological samples for the experimental groups. No new digital datasets were introduced or benchmarked.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Microscope Enhances Calculus Removal: The most direct benefit observed was a statistically significant reduction in residual calculus when scaling was performed under a surgical microscope. This suggests that enhanced visualization allows for more thorough debridement.
  • Restoration of Root Surface Integrity: Nanoindentation revealed that root surfaces scaled with a microscope had nanotopography, elastic modulus, and nanohardness values closer to those of healthy (NC) teeth compared to those scaled without magnification (macro group). This implies better preservation of the natural root structure.
  • Improved Biocompatibility: PDLCs showed better adhesion, more extensive projections, and enhanced proliferation on root surfaces treated with the microscope. This indicates that microscope-assisted scaling results in a more favorable environment for cellular regeneration.
  • Reduced Inflammation: Levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-8 were significantly reduced in the micro group compared to the periodontitis control group, and slightly lower than the macro group, suggesting a less inflammatory response from the root surface.
  • Beyond Subjective Benefits: The study moves beyond anecdotal evidence by providing objective, quantitative data on the mechanical, topographical, and biological improvements achieved with microscope-assisted root scaling.

Key Results

  • Calculus Reduction: The micro group showed a significantly lower percentage of residual calculus (9.9%) compared to the macro group (17.0%) (P < 0.01).
  • Mechanical Properties: While the PC group exhibited the highest modulus and nanohardness (likely due to calculus), the micro group's mechanical properties were closer to the NC group, indicating a more natural root surface. The macro group showed more pronounced surface damage and a thicker smear layer.
  • Cellular Response: PDLCs exhibited significantly better adhesion and proliferation on micro-group root surfaces compared to the macro group.
  • Inflammatory Markers: IL-6 and IL-8 levels were significantly reduced in both scaled groups compared to the PC group. The micro group showed a trend towards lower levels than the macro group, though this difference was not statistically significant.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • In Vitro Study: The study was conducted in vitro, which does not fully replicate the complex in vivo environment of a patient's mouth, including factors like bleeding, suppuration, and probing depths.
  • Operator Skill and Training: The effectiveness of microscope use can be influenced by the operator's skill and training, which is a crucial factor in clinical application.
  • Limited Scope: The study focused on root scaling. Further research could explore the benefits of microscopes in other periodontal procedures.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Randomized Clinical Trials: Implementing randomized clinical trials to evaluate the real-world clinical merits of using surgical microscopes in periodontics.
  • Standardization of Care: Determining if surgical microscopes should become a standard of care in periodontal practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

The benefits of using a surgical microscope in periodontal therapy were mainly based on subjective statements made by patients or periodontists. We aimed to provide laboratory evidence for the advantages of using a surgical microscope during root scaling on periodontitis teeth. In the present study, the extracted teeth were categorized into four groups: normal teeth (normal control [NC] group), untreated periodontitis teeth (periodontitis control [PC] group), root surface scaled without magnification (macro group), and root surface instrumented with a microscope (micro group). To analyze both the mechanical and biological properties of the root surfaces, we performed nanoindentation in addition to the traditional methods. We found that by using a surgical microscope, we improved the clearance of bacterial deposits and calculi on periodontitis root surfaces. Nanoindentation results revealed that the nanotopography pattern, elastic modulus, and nanohardness of the root surface in the micro group were closest to those in the NC group. The immunofluorescence assay and cell proliferation analyses revealed improved morphology and enhanced adhesion and proliferation of periodontal ligament cells on the root surface in the micro group compared with the macro group. After instrumentation, the expression levels of interleukin-6 and interleukin-8 decreased when compared with the PC group. Our results demonstrated that surgical microscope application could improve the outcomes of periodontal treatment, implying that a surgical microscope can be a powerful tool for periodontists to seek accurate clinical periodontal performance and gain better biocompatibility of the treated root surfaces.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liao2020effect,
  author = {Haiqing Liao and Huihui Zhang and Junbo Xiang and Guanting Chen and Zhengguo Cao},
  title = {{The effect of the surgical microscope on the outcome of root scaling.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure