The Effect of the Intensity of Happy Expression on Social Perception of Chinese Faces

Yaning Li, Zhongqing Jiang, Yisheng Yang, Haizhou Leng, Fuhua Pei, Qi WuFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Numerous studies have shown that facial expressions influence trait impressions in the Western context. There are cultural differences in the perception and recognition rules of different intensities of happy expressions, and researchers have only explored the influence of the intensity of happy expressions on a few facial traits (warmth, trustworthiness, and competence). Therefore, we examined the effect of different intensities of Chinese happy expressions on the social perception of faces from 11 traits, namely trustworthiness, responsibility, attractiveness, sociability, confidence, intelligence, aggressiveness, dominance, competence, warmth, and tenacity. In this study, participants were asked to view a series of photographs of faces with high-intensity or low-intensity happy expressions and rate the 11 traits on a 7-point Likert scale (1 = "not very ××," 7 = "very ××"). The results indicated that high-intensity happy expression had higher-rated scores for sociability and warmth but lower scores for dominance, aggressiveness, intelligence, and competence than the low-intensity happy expression; there was no significant difference in the rated scores for trustworthiness, attractiveness, responsibility, confidence, and tenacity between the high-intensity and low-intensity happy expressions. These results suggested that, compared to the low-intensity happy expression, the high-intensity happy expression will enhance the perceptual outcome of the traits related to approachability, reduce the perceptual outcome of traits related to capability, and have no significant effect on trustworthiness, attractiveness, responsibility, confidence, and tenacity.

Introduction

First impressions are often formed within milliseconds based on facial expressions, a phenomenon known as the social perception of faces. While Western research has extensively documented the "halo effect" of smiling, where positive expressions lead to favorable trait attributions, these studies often focus on a limited set of traits and utilize artificial stimuli. Furthermore, cultural differences play a significant role; for instance, while broad smiles are often associated with leadership in Western contexts, Chinese culture may favor more subtle expressions for authority figures. This study investigates how the intensity of happy expressions affects the perception of 11 distinct personality traits in a Chinese context, specifically testing the "morality differentiation hypothesis"—the distinction between being perceived as "nice" (warmth) versus "moral" (trustworthy).

Methods and Materials

Participants and Stimuli

The study recruited 32 Chinese college students to evaluate 132 natural photographs of Chinese faces. Each of the 66 individuals depicted was photographed twice: once with a high-intensity smile (showing teeth) and once with a low-intensity smile (closed lips). The use of natural photos rather than morphed composites ensures higher ecological validity for real-life interactions.

Examples of high-intensity (A) and low-intensity (B) happy expressions used as stimuli.

Datasets and Validation

Stimuli were sourced from the Taiwan Facial Expression Image Database (TFEID) and a newly collected set of 56 images of Chinese college students, standardized using the Facial Action Coding System (FACS). A separate validation group of 30 students assessed the emotional intensity and recognition accuracy of the stimuli prior to the main experiment to ensure consistency.

Validation metrics for the facial expression stimuli, showing high recognition accuracy and distinct intensity ratings.

Procedure

Participants rated each face on a 7-point Likert scale across 11 traits. To prevent judgment fatigue and cross-contamination between traits, the experiment was conducted in 11 blocks with mandatory rest periods.

Results

Statistical analysis using repeated measures ANOVA revealed significant differences based on smile intensity:

  • High-Intensity Smiles: Received significantly higher ratings for Sociability ($F=39.61$) and Warmth ($F=30.64$).
  • Low-Intensity Smiles: Received significantly higher ratings for Intelligence ($F=19.63$), Competence ($F=14.76$), Dominance ($F=21.53$), and Aggressiveness ($F=23.23$).
  • Non-Significant Traits: No significant differences were found for trustworthiness, attractiveness, responsibility, confidence, or tenacity.
  • Gender Effects: Female faces generally received higher ratings for trustworthiness, responsibility, and attractiveness, independent of smile intensity.

Discussion

The findings highlight a distinct "approachability-capability trade-off." While high-intensity smiles enhance perceptions of sociability, they simultaneously reduce perceived dominance and competence. This may be explained by the baby-face overgeneralization effect, where the facial changes associated with a broad smile (e.g., rounded face, widened nose) mimic infantile features, triggering perceptions of warmth but lower capability.

Furthermore, the results support the morality differentiation hypothesis. In Chinese culture, trustworthiness is viewed as a moral norm, whereas warmth is considered a social skill. The data suggest that while a big smile is a potent social signal boosting warmth, it does not influence the perception of moral character (trustworthiness). This distinction aligns with cultural leadership cues in China, where leaders often adopt reserved expressions to project intelligence and competence.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that smile intensity significantly modulates the social perception of Chinese faces across approachability and capability dimensions. While a broad smile makes a person seem warmer, a subtle smile may be more effective for projecting intelligence and authority in a Chinese cultural context.

Summary updated

Abstract

Numerous studies have shown that facial expressions influence trait impressions in the Western context. There are cultural differences in the perception and recognition rules of different intensities of happy expressions, and researchers have only explored the influence of the intensity of happy expressions on a few facial traits (warmth, trustworthiness, and competence). Therefore, we examined the effect of different intensities of Chinese happy expressions on the social perception of faces from 11 traits, namely trustworthiness, responsibility, attractiveness, sociability, confidence, intelligence, aggressiveness, dominance, competence, warmth, and tenacity. In this study, participants were asked to view a series of photographs of faces with high-intensity or low-intensity happy expressions and rate the 11 traits on a 7-point Likert scale (1 = "<i>not very ××</i>," 7 = "<i>very ××</i>"). The results indicated that high-intensity happy expression had higher-rated scores for sociability and warmth but lower scores for dominance, aggressiveness, intelligence, and competence than the low-intensity happy expression; there was no significant difference in the rated scores for trustworthiness, attractiveness, responsibility, confidence, and tenacity between the high-intensity and low-intensity happy expressions. These results suggested that, compared to the low-intensity happy expression, the high-intensity happy expression will enhance the perceptual outcome of the traits related to approachability, reduce the perceptual outcome of traits related to capability, and have no significant effect on trustworthiness, attractiveness, responsibility, confidence, and tenacity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021effect,
  author = {Yaning Li and Zhongqing Jiang and Yisheng Yang and Haizhou Leng and Fuhua Pei and Qi Wu},
  title = {{The Effect of the Intensity of Happy Expression on Social Perception of Chinese Faces}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.638398},
}
Figure