Abstract
It is urgent to understand how to most effectively communicate public health messages during the COVID-19 pandemic. Previously, the focus has been on how to formulate the message, rather than on who should send it, and particularly little is known about the latter during times of crisis. We report on the effectiveness of different public figures at promoting social distancing in 6 countries severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Across countries and demographic strata, immunology expert Dr. Anthony Fauci achieved the highest level of respondents’ willingness to reshare a call to social distancing, followed by a government spokesperson. Celebrity spokespersons were least effective. The likelihood of message resharing increased with age and when respondents expressed positive sentiments towards the spokesperson. Effective messaging during the COVID-19 pandemic can save lives, and the messenger matters.
Introduction
Public health officials often focus on the framing of a message—whether to emphasize community benefits or individual risks. However, there is surprisingly little data on who should deliver that message to maximize its reach during a fast-moving crisis. This study quantifies the "spokesperson effect" to understand which public figures move the needle on public compliance and message amplification.
Methodology
The researchers conducted a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 12,194 respondents across six countries: Brazil, Italy, South Korea, Spain, Switzerland, and the United States. Participants were shown a social distancing message attributed to one of five conditions:
- The Expert: Dr. Anthony Fauci.
- The Government Official: A country-specific leader.
- The "Relatable" Celebrity: Tom Hanks.
- The Influencer: Kim Kardashian.
- Control: A "No Speaker" condition.
The primary outcome was "message sharing"—the respondent's self-reported willingness to share the endorsement on social media (1–7 Likert scale). The analysis controlled for variables including age, gender, and existing sentiments toward the government.
Key Results and Insights
The Expertise Premium
Across almost all demographic strata and countries, Dr. Fauci achieved the highest level of willingness to reshare. Fauci’s attribution was 0.51 points higher than the government official and 1.85 points higher than Kardashian. This suggests that in a technical crisis, the public defaults to scientific authority over political or cultural figures.
The Celebrity Paradox
Despite their massive follower counts, celebrities were the least effective. Attributing a message to Kim Kardashian often resulted in lower sharing intent than having no spokesperson at all. This implies that a "bad" messenger can actively damage the reach of a critical message.
Demographic Drivers
- Age: The likelihood of resharing increased significantly with the age of the respondent. Older populations were more willing to act as digital conduits for public health information.
- Likeability: While "liking" a spokesperson boosted sharing, it did not change the hierarchy. Even among those who liked celebrities, the expert's message remained more likely to be shared.
- National Context: Brazil showed the highest overall likelihood of message sharing, while Switzerland showed the lowest, highlighting how cultural context influences communication efficacy.
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that the messenger is just as important as the message. While the authors acknowledge limitations—such as measuring stated intent rather than actual behavior—the data clearly favors scientific experts for public health communication. Future work may explore other influential groups, such as religious leaders, who showed a positive correlation with sharing intent. In a global pandemic, choosing the right spokesperson can save lives by ensuring vital information reaches the widest possible audience.
Summary updated