The Effect of Recycled Sand on the Tensile Properties of Engineered Cementitious Composites

Zhifu Dong, Tan Yan, Xiangru Jian, Jiangtao Yu, Kequan YuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the use of recycled sand (RS) as a sustainable alternative to natural sand (NS) in engineered cementitious composites (ECC). The findings reveal that RS-ECC exhibits superior tensile properties, including enhanced strain capacity and better crack distribution, while maintaining comparable compressive and flexural strengths to NS-ECC. This suggests RS can be a viable component for developing more sustainable and ductile ECC.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry heavily relies on concrete, a material that consumes vast amounts of fine aggregates like river sand and manufactured sand. The overexploitation of river sand poses environmental challenges, and the production of manufactured sand contributes to CO2 emissions. Simultaneously, construction and demolition (C&D) waste is a significant environmental concern. Recycled sand (RS), a byproduct of C&D waste processing, presents an opportunity for sustainable material utilization. However, the mechanical properties of concrete incorporating RS are not fully understood, especially in advanced materials like Engineered Cementitious Composites (ECC), which are known for their ductility and crack control. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by exploring the feasibility and impact of replacing natural sand with recycled sand in ECC, focusing on enhancing tensile properties and understanding the underlying mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers conducted a comprehensive experimental program to evaluate the effect of recycled sand on ECC properties. This involved:

  • Material Characterization: Recycled sand (RS) and natural sand (NS) were analyzed for their chemical compositions (using X-ray fluorescence - XRF), physical properties, and particle size distribution.
  • Mix Design: Four different ECC mixtures were prepared: two using natural sand (NS-ECC-12 grid and NS-ECC-20 grid) and two using recycled sand (RS-ECC-12 grid and RS-ECC-20 grid), with variations in sand sieve size (12-grid and 20-grid). All mixtures incorporated ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (PE) fibers at a constant volume fraction of 2%.
  • Mechanical Testing: A suite of mechanical tests was performed on the prepared specimens:
  • Uniaxial Tension Test: To assess tensile properties, including peak tensile strength, strain capacity, and crack behavior.
  • Uniaxial Compression Test: To evaluate compressive strength.
  • Three-Point Bending Test: To determine flexural strength and mid-span deformation.
  • Single Crack Tension Test: To investigate the fiber bridging stress and complementary energy related to fiber pull-out.
  • Fracture Toughness Test: To measure the matrix fracture toughness.
  • Microstructure Analysis: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), three-dimensional shape measurement, and nano-indentation tests were employed to examine the microstructure, interfacial transition zone (ITZ), and elastic modulus of different phases within the ECC.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the prepared ECC specimens.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RS Enhances Tensile Ductility: The most significant finding is that replacing NS with RS in ECC leads to improved tensile ductility. This is evidenced by a higher tensile strain capacity (up to 7% for RS-ECC compared to around 4.7% for NS-ECC) and a better multi-cracking behavior.
  • Mechanism for Improved Ductility: The enhanced ductility is attributed to the reduced matrix fracture toughness of RS-ECC. This reduction is linked to the presence of residual old mortar on the recycled sand particles, creating a weaker interfacial transition zone (ITZ) between the sand and the new cement matrix. This weaker ITZ facilitates crack propagation through the aggregate rather than around it, requiring less energy and leading to finer, more distributed cracks.
  • Comparable Strength: Despite the changes in microstructure and fracture toughness, the compressive and flexural strengths of RS-ECC were comparable to, and in some cases slightly lower than, NS-ECC, but still well within acceptable engineering ranges (over 50 MPa for compressive and 20 MPa for flexural).
  • Fineness Matters: The study also indicated that finer aggregate (20-grid) generally leads to better tensile strain capacity and crack distribution compared to coarser aggregate (12-grid), regardless of whether it's natural or recycled sand.

Key Results

  • Tensile Strain Capacity: RS-ECC achieved a peak tensile strain capacity of up to 7%, significantly higher than NS-ECC (around 4.7%).
  • Crack Behavior: RS-ECC exhibited a higher number of cracks (e.g., 44.5 for RS-ECC-20 grid vs. 29.7 for NS-ECC-20 grid) and narrower crack widths, indicating better multi-cracking.
  • Pseudo-Strain-Hardening (PSH) Index: The PSH index (Jb'/Jtip), a measure of strain-hardening behavior, increased by 46% and 70% for RS-ECC-20 grid and RS-ECC-12 grid, respectively, compared to their NS-ECC counterparts.
  • Compressive Strength: RS-ECC achieved compressive strengths over 50 MPa.
  • Flexural Strength: RS-ECC achieved flexural strengths over 20 MPa.
  • Matrix Toughness: RS-ECC demonstrated lower fracture toughness (Ko values around 0.39 MPa-m¹/²) compared to NS-ECC (around 0.51 MPa-m¹/²).
  • Microstructure: SEM analysis revealed a thicker and weaker ITZ in RS-ECC compared to NS-ECC.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Variance in Tensile Properties: The study noted a larger variance in the tensile properties of RS-ECC compared to NS-ECC. This is attributed to the irregular morphology of RS and its potential impact on fiber dispersion.
  • Focus on Specific RS Characteristics: The study used RS derived from C&D waste. The properties of RS can vary significantly depending on the source material and processing methods. Future work could explore RS from different sources.
  • Long-Term Durability: While the study focused on mechanical properties, long-term durability aspects of RS-ECC under various environmental conditions were not extensively investigated.
  • Optimization of RS Content: The study used full replacement of NS with RS. Further research could explore the optimal replacement ratios of RS to balance sustainability and performance.
  • Further Investigation of Microstructure: While SEM and nano-indentation provided insights, a more in-depth understanding of the interaction between the residual mortar on RS and the new cement matrix could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research aims to investigate the feasibility of replacing natural sand (NS) with recycled sand (RS) to enhance the mechanical property of engineered cementitious composites (ECC). For a comparative study, ECCs incorporating natural sands (NS) and recycled sands with different sieve sizes were taken as experimental subjects. The results demonstrated that RS-ECC possessed better tensile properties featuring saturated cracks and superior strain-hardening behavior than that of NS-ECC. The highest tensile strain capacity of RS-ECC was up to 7%. Meanwhile, the compressive and flexural strengths of RS-ECC were over 50 and 20 MPa. The pseudo-strain-hardening (PSH) index of the RS-ECC-20 grid and RS-ECC-12 grid were 141 and 201, which increased by 46% and 70% than that of NS-ECC. Furthermore, the thicker weak ITZ and comparatively aggregate/ITZ ratio were found in the RE-ECC by a microstructure test, which revealed and explained the mechanism for the lower matrix fracture toughness of RS-ECC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2022effect,
  author = {Zhifu Dong and Tan Yan and Xiangru Jian and Jiangtao Yu and Kequan Yu},
  title = {{The Effect of Recycled Sand on the Tensile Properties of Engineered Cementitious Composites}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142013530},
}
Figure