The effect of holmium laser resection versus standard transurethral resection on non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Changlong Li, Liang Gao, Jindong Zhang, Xiaokang Yang, Chuan LiuResearch Square 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) represents approximately 75% of all bladder cancer diagnoses. For decades, Transurethral Resection of the Bladder Tumor (TURBT) has served as the "gold standard" treatment. However, TURBT utilizes electrical current, which presents specific surgical risks. The most significant is the obturator nerve reflex—an involuntary leg jerk caused by electrical stimulation that can lead to bladder perforation. Furthermore, the thermal damage associated with electrocautery can prolong recovery.

This systematic review and meta-analysis investigates whether Holmium Laser Resection of the Bladder Tumor (HOLRBT) offers a safer and more effective alternative by utilizing laser energy instead of electricity.

Methods and Study Selection

The researchers conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, searching PubMed, the Cochrane Library, and Embase for studies comparing HOLRBT and TURBT published through March 2019.

PRISMA flow diagram showing the selection process of the 9 included studies from an initial pool of 317 records.

The final analysis included 9 comparative studies (1 Randomized Controlled Trial, 3 prospective cohort studies, and 5 retrospective case-control studies) involving a total of 1,166 patients (473 HOLRBT; 693 TURBT). Statistical analysis was performed using Review Manager 5.3, employing Odds Ratios (OR) for categorical outcomes and Mean Difference (MD) for continuous variables.

Key Results

The meta-analysis revealed several significant clinical advantages for the laser-based approach:

Enhanced Surgical Safety

The use of laser energy effectively eliminated the electrical stimulation of the obturator nerve. HOLRBT demonstrated a significantly lower incidence of:

  • Obturator nerve reflex: OR = 0.06
  • Bladder perforation: OR = 0.15
  • Bladder irritation: OR = 0.45

Improved Patient Recovery

HOLRBT contributed to a faster post-operative recovery phase. On average, patients in the HOLRBT group experienced:

  • Shorter catheterization times: MD = -1.02 days
  • Reduced hospital stays: MD = -1.11 days

Long-term Oncological Efficacy

While 1-year recurrence rates were comparable between the two methods, HOLRBT showed a superior outcome at the 2-year mark. The 2-year recurrence rate was 26.1% for HOLRBT versus 34.3% for TURBT (OR = 0.69). This suggests that laser resection may facilitate a more precise "en bloc" removal of the tumor, potentially leading to cleaner margins.

No significant differences were found regarding operation time or the incidence of urethral strictures.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings suggest that HOLRBT is a safer and potentially more effective alternative to traditional TURBT, particularly in reducing perioperative complications and long-term recurrence. However, several limitations must be considered. Most included studies were retrospective or cohort-based, with only one RCT, which introduces potential bias. Additionally, there was high statistical heterogeneity in recovery times, likely reflecting differences in institutional protocols and surgeon experience.

Conclusion

HOLRBT appears to be a superior choice for treating NMIBC, offering significant improvements in safety and recovery speed without compromising surgical efficiency. Future large-scale, multi-center randomized controlled trials are needed to further standardize the procedure and validate these findings across diverse patient populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Purpose: To explore the advantages and limitations of holmium laser resection of the bladder tumor (HOLRBT) versus standard transurethral resection of the bladder tumor (TURBT) in the treatment of non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC). Methods: The eligible studies were selected from the following databases: PubMed, Cochrane Library and Embase. Studies comparing HOLRBT and TURBT for patients with NMIBC were included. The outcomes of interest were time of operation, catheterization, and hospitalization, rates of recurrence and perioperative complications, including obturator nerve reflex, bladder perforation, bladder irritation and urethral stricture. Results of all data were compared and analyzed by Review Manager 5.3. Results: A total of 9 comparative studies were finally included for analysis. Pooled data demonstrated that HOLRBT could significantly reduce the time in catheterization and hospitalization, the rates of recurrence in 2 years of follow-up, obturator nerve reflex, bladder perforation, bladder irritation compared with those in TURBT, respectively. However, no significant difference could be found between HOLRBT and TURBT in the time of operation, rate of recurrence at 1-year follow-up and urethral stricture. Conclusions: The results of our research showed that HOLRBT would be a better choice than TURBT for patients with NMIBC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019effect,
  author = {Changlong Li and Liang Gao and Jindong Zhang and Xiaokang Yang and Chuan Liu},
  title = {{The effect of holmium laser resection versus standard transurethral resection on non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.12172/v1},
}
Figure