The Effect of Geometry Parameters on Energy and Thermal Performance of School Buildings in Cold Climates of China

Anxiao Zhang, Regina Bokel, Andy van den Dobbelsteen, Yanchen Sun, Qiong Huang, Qi ZhangSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how building geometry (shape, window-to-wall ratio, room depth, orientation) impacts the energy consumption and thermal comfort of Chinese schools in cold climates. By combining computer simulations and student surveys, the research identifies optimal design strategies that can lead to significant energy savings and improved comfort, with the H-shape building performing best overall.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Energy efficiency and thermal comfort are critical for non-domestic buildings, with schools representing a significant portion of energy consumption in China. While research has explored building geometry's impact on residential and office buildings, school buildings, especially in cold climates, have been less studied. Furthermore, the subjective preferences of students regarding building geometry, which can influence their learning environment and efficiency, are often overlooked in design decisions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive analysis of how various geometric parameters affect both the objective performance (energy use, thermal comfort) and subjective perception of school buildings in cold Chinese climates.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Computer Simulations: The researchers used DesignBuilder, an energy analysis software package powered by EnergyPlus, to simulate the annual energy consumption and summer thermal discomfort of various school building models. Seven archetypal school building shapes were developed based on a survey of existing school designs in China: rectangular, L-shape, C-shape, H-shape, H-shape with an atrium (Ha shape), courtyard, and high-rise. For each shape, simulations were run by varying three key geometry parameters:
  2. Window-to-Wall Ratio (WWR): Tested across nine values from 10% to 90%.
  3. Room Depth (RD): Tested across four values: 6 m, 8 m, 10 m, and 12 m.
  4. Orientation: Rotated by 0°, 90°, 180°, and 270°. This resulted in a total of 900 energy simulations. The simulations considered district heating for winter and natural ventilation for summer, reflecting typical conditions in cold Chinese climates.

  5. Questionnaire Survey: A survey was conducted with students from a high school attached to Tianjin University to gauge their subjective preferences for building geometry parameters (shape, WWR, room depth, orientation) and their perceived effect on learning efficiency. A seven-point Likert scale was used for ratings.

Datasets

  • Existing School Building Data: Information on 170 local school designs (207 teaching buildings) from eight cities in the cold climate zone of China was collected and analyzed to inform the selection of typical school building typologies and design parameters.
  • Climatic Data for Tianjin: Monthly average outdoor dry bulb temperature and wind speed data for Tianjin were used for the simulations.
  • Student Questionnaire Data: Responses from 156 valid questionnaires were collected and statistically analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometry is a Powerful Tool: Building geometry is not just an aesthetic choice; it has a tangible and significant impact on energy consumption and thermal comfort, offering a passive design strategy.
  • The H-Shape Reigns Supreme (for now): The H-shape building emerged as the best performer, balancing energy savings, thermal comfort, and student preference. Its complex form and multiple design options contributed to its success.
  • WWR Sweet Spot: A WWR of 20-40% generally provided the best balance for energy savings and thermal comfort. However, deeper rooms benefit from larger windows to mitigate lighting demand and improve heat dissipation.
  • Depth vs. Preference Conflict: While deeper rooms (around 6-8m) offer better energy performance, students strongly prefer more spacious classrooms (around 10m depth), creating a design tension.
  • Orientation Matters for Comfort: Orientation significantly impacts summer thermal comfort, especially for buildings with geometric anisotropy. West-facing rooms should be minimized due to increased heat risk. Energy demand, however, is less sensitive to orientation.
  • Internal Layout's Minor Role: The arrangement of internal spaces had a relatively small impact on overall building energy demand and thermal comfort.

Key Results

  • Maximum Energy Savings: The H-shape building achieved a maximum of 13.6% energy savings.
  • Maximum Thermal Comfort Improvement: The H-shape building also showed the highest thermal comfort improvement at 3.8%.
  • Student Preferences: The Ha shape was the students' favorite, while the rectangle and high-rise were least preferred. The H-shape ranked second in preference.
  • WWR Impact: Increasing WWR from 10% to 40% significantly decreased summer discomfort while marginally reducing energy consumption. Beyond 40%, energy consumption increased rapidly.
  • Room Depth Impact: Deeper rooms (up to 12m) generally led to lower energy demand but higher summer discomfort.
  • Orientation Impact: 0° and 180° rotation angles showed better thermal performance and higher student preference than 90° and 270° angles, likely due to reduced west-facing exposure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Shading Systems: A key limitation acknowledged by the authors is the exclusion of shading systems in the simulation models. Future research should incorporate these to provide a more complete picture.
  • Cold Climate Focus: The study is specific to cold climates in China. Further research could explore the applicability of these findings in different climatic zones.
  • Student Sample: While 156 students participated, the sample was from a single high school. Expanding the survey to a broader demographic could enhance generalizability.
  • Simplified HVAC: The study assumed district heating and natural ventilation, which is typical but might not cover all HVAC scenarios.

The authors suggest that future research should clarify the impact of shading systems and explore these findings in different climatic contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper discusses the role of geometry parameters including building shape, window to wall ratio, room depth, and orientation on the energy use and thermal comfort of school buildings in cold climates of China. The annual total energy demand and summer thermal discomfort time were compared through computer simulations with DesignBuilder. Furthermore, a questionnaire was conducted that related to the students’ subjective preference for various building geometry parameters. Results showed that a maximum of 13.6% of energy savings and 3.8% of thermal comfort improvement when compared to the reference case could be achieved through variations in geometry parameters. The H shape performed the best when the building thermal performance and students’ preferences were considered, as well as the various design options for architects. Window to wall ratio, room depth, and orientation should also be carefully addressed in terms of different building types. The results of this study can serve as a reference for architects and school managers in the early design stages of schools in cold climates of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017effect,
  author = {Anxiao Zhang and Regina Bokel and Andy van den Dobbelsteen and Yanchen Sun and Qiong Huang and Qi Zhang},
  title = {{The Effect of Geometry Parameters on Energy and Thermal Performance of School Buildings in Cold Climates of China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9101708},
}
Figure