The Effect of Extensor Muscle Strength on Meniscus Progression in Subjects Without Radiologic Knee Osteoarthritis -- Data From the Osteoarthritis Initiative

Mingyang Li, Yong Nie, Kang Li, Yi Zeng, Yuangang Wu, Yuan Liu, Limin Wu, Bin ShenResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

While the benefits of quadriceps strengthening for symptomatic knee osteoarthritis (KOA) are well-established, its impact on structural disease progression remains less clear. This study investigated the association between baseline knee extensor strength and meniscal health over 24 months in individuals without radiologic KOA. Analyzing data from the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI), researchers found that high baseline extensor strength in females significantly reduced the risk of medial meniscus progression and extrusion. These findings suggest that muscle strength serves as a structural "shield," potentially delaying the onset of degenerative joint disease by protecting the knee's primary shock absorbers.

Introduction: The Meniscus as a Structural Sentinel

Knee osteoarthritis is a leading cause of global disability. While clinical guidelines prioritize strengthening exercises, evidence for whether muscle strength prevents structural damage—such as the breakdown of the meniscus—has been inconsistent. The meniscus, a crescent-shaped fibrocartilage, acts as the knee's primary shock absorber. Damage to this structure often precedes visible cartilage loss or joint space narrowing on X-rays. By focusing on individuals with minimal radiologic signs of OA (Kellgren-Lawrence grade ≤ 1), this study aimed to determine if muscle strength could predict meniscal durability.

Methods and Study Design

The researchers conducted a longitudinal analysis using the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) dataset. The study included participants with a BMI under 30 and minimal radiologic OA.

  • Strength Assessment: Isometric knee extensor strength was measured using a specialized "Good Strength Chair." Participants were categorized into "high" and "low" strength groups based on the median strength-to-weight ratio.
  • Imaging: MRI scans were analyzed using the MRI Osteoarthritis Knee Score (MOAKS) to track changes in meniscal morphology (tears) and extrusion (displacement from the joint space) at 12 and 24 months.
  • Statistical Approach: Sex-stratified analyses and logistic regression models adjusted for age, height, weight, and KL grade were employed to isolate the protective effects of muscle strength.
Baseline characteristics and meniscus status of the study cohort, divided into low and high strength groups.

Key Results: A 24-Month Protective Effect

The study revealed a significant protective association specifically within the female cohort over a 24-month period.

  • Medial Meniscus Progression: Women in the high-strength group experienced significantly less overall medial meniscus progression (11.1%) compared to the low-strength group (23.2%, $P=0.04$).
  • Meniscal Extrusion: High strength was particularly effective at preventing medial meniscal extrusion (5.2% vs. 12.5%, $P=0.04$) and anterior extrusion (0% vs. 5.3%, $P=0.03$).
  • Risk Reduction: After adjusting for age and BMI, women in the high-strength group had an adjusted Odds Ratio (OR) of 0.50 for meniscal progression, representing a 50% reduction in risk.
  • Time and Sex Specificity: No significant differences were observed at the 12-month mark, suggesting that structural benefits require long-term maintenance. Furthermore, no significant associations were found in the male cohort or for the lateral meniscus.

Discussion and Implications

The findings highlight a "protective threshold" in females. The authors suggest that because women generally have lower absolute baseline strength, reaching the "high" strength category may provide the critical joint stability needed to prevent structural decay. The specific protection against extrusion suggests that strong quadriceps help maintain proper joint alignment and load distribution.

Limitations

The study's limitations include a relatively small sample size for specific tear types and the lack of adjustment for daily physical activity levels. Additionally, the lack of significant findings in men suggests that joint geometry or different strength requirements may play a role, warranting further investigation.

Conclusion

High baseline extensor strength in women is a significant predictor of better meniscal outcomes over two years. This research underscores the importance of strength training not just for symptom management, but as a potential intervention to preserve joint structure in the early stages of osteoarthritis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background High extensor strength decreased knee osteoarthritis symptomatic progression in female was well demonstrated. However, few studies detected a significant association between extensor strength and structural progression when joint space narrowing or cartilage loss were the indicators. The pathological change in meniscus could come earlier than that in cartilage and JSN, but no studies have specifically investigated the association between extensor strength and meniscus progression. Methods Participants in Osteoarthritis Initiative with both muscle strength and meniscus assessment, KL grade ≤ 1, and BMI < 30, were enrolled. In separate-sex analysis, participants were divided into the high strength group and the low strength group referring to the median baseline maximum extensor muscle strength/weight. Overall and classified meniscus progression in MRI Osteoarthritis Knee Score was compared between the two groups, at 12 months (622 knees) and 24 months (548 knees). Results In females, less overall medial meniscus progression (11.1% [17/153] VS 23.2% [32/138], P=0.04), less medial meniscal medially extrusion (5.2 % [8/155] VS 12.5 % [18/144], P =0.04), and less medial meniscal anteriorly extrusion progression (0 % [0/108] VS 5.3% [6/113], P=0.03), was presented in the high strength group over 24 months. No significant difference was detected in other comparisons (in males, or in lateral meniscus, or in 12 months). Conclusion High baseline extensor strength in females was associated with a decreased risk of 24- month medial meniscus progression. High extensor strength does not only correlate with less symptomatic progression of KOA, but also with lower risk of structural progression.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021effect,
  author = {Mingyang Li and Yong Nie and Kang Li and Yi Zeng and Yuangang Wu and Yuan Liu and Limin Wu and Bin Shen},
  title = {{The Effect of Extensor Muscle Strength on Meniscus Progression in Subjects Without Radiologic Knee Osteoarthritis -- Data From the Osteoarthritis Initiative}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-285410/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure